Fawzia dokhtar-i-Sanjar said:
@FritZ_FretZ - RE: your post, you turkey.
Das me
Anyhow, more on topic...
I have to tell you folks again, PoP is simply amazing! I can't thank you all enough for sharing this marvelous piece of artistry. It's truly a credit to each and every person that's contributed.
I'm still relatively new to Pendor, so my experiences are fresh. I've been keeping some notes on things that, to me at least, from my fresh/possibly naive perspective, appear to be asking for slight tweaking to make Pendor an more dazzling experience. Please keep in mind that these are intended to be constructive criticisms only and in no way diminish my appreciation for the exceptional work already done. With this in mind, here are a few suggestions, some specific and others general, in no particular order:
1) In the Pendor troop tree, it seems a bit incongruous to develop a Footknight from a Squire-at-Arms rather than from the non-equestrian Man-at-Arms of equal tier.
2) As the game progresses, rumors don't seem to keep up; E.g. referencing extinct factions and defunct rulers.
3) As in native, the first greeting the PC receives from a lord that has switched to the PC's chosen faction is still in context of being able to fight the PC. It would be more immersive if this greeting were to reflect the lord being in the same faction as the PC.
4) The inclusion of an option to end dialog with a lord or lady other than, "I must beg my leave." This is fine in the beginning of the game, prior to being granted a title as I'm the lord's subordinate. But, once I receive a title, I am their peer and shouldn't have to beg them for anything, let alone my leave. "I must go now." would work fine. It's purely cosmetic of course, but it would add a lot to role playing. Also, with the new ability to become a faction ruler, the only people doing the begging should be the lords themselves.
5) On the note of being a ruler, it would be nice to be recognized as such in the dialogs. I know it's meant to personalize the dialog by inserting the player name, but it would be more immersive if the dialog referred to me with more respect. E.g. instead of 'player name' insert 'my lord' or 'your Eminence' or 'my liege' as appropriate. When speaking to one of your vassals wouldn't it be nicer to here "what is your bidding my lord?" than "Well, 'name'? What is it?" And no more curt "Yes, yes - farewell" either; "Farewell my lord" is as snippety as it should get.
6) Female tavern keepers use the rumor about the windtooth tribe, saying they won't repeat it to their wife. Are they really meant to be that open minded in Pendor?
7) Assigning lords from defunct factions to new factions is fine if you're not the ruler. But if you are, you should have the option to either take the lord on board or tell him to push off. It seems more than a bit silly to be assigned a lord that hates you; after all, who runs this place?
Ultimately it would be nice to have the lord's disposition towards the ruler taken into account when choosing/applying to their new faction.
8 ) When leaving the 'War Room' the PC refers to the steward as "my lord".
9) It would be nice to have the ability to tell someone staying at your castle/town to "Get out!" The game allows the PC to be barred from castles owned by lords that hate them. I'd like this ability too, or at least to kick them out if I find them there. This includes the Ladies of the court. It irritates me to no end to have this... person... squatting in my house telling me she's never heard of me and then telling me I need to kiss her hind-side for her to help me. I want to be able to either kick her out, throw her in the dungeon or put her to the sword; But really any one of those options would work.
10) I know that at the moment there are issues with the repair of structures in villages and towns; And that the issue is on the to do list. Once functional, it would be nice to have the option to toggle an automated repair system that charges repair costs against the income of the town. This would seem to fit in with the roles that the steward/guild masters should play. Providing of course, that you have given them your consent.
That's it for now. If you're interested I'll keep writing things down and sharing them. Let me know
Cheers!
FritZ
Edit:
kaeldragor said:
...snip
...AND certain items are not 'merchandise', so they just don't get sold at all, regardless of the number. Those you must loot (such as the much desired Demonskin Armor.)
Sorry Kael, but I've got to ask since this is second time the demonskin armor has been referred to as 'desirable'. What's so great about it? I've picked up several and IIRC the stats sucked compared to even a coat of plates. I'm confused.
-FF