DennyWiseau
Veteran
This would also tie in so well with the education system, you woul actually have to educate your relative to be fit to rule, becuase otherwise your subjects wouldent accept them
-
If you are reporting a bug, please head over to our Technical Support section for Bannerlord.
Bannerlord Wishlist
- Thread starter WhiteEyedSh4rk
- Start date
Users who are viewing this thread
Veteran
This would also tie in so well with the education system, you woul actually have to educate your relative to be fit to rule, becuase otherwise your subjects wouldent accept them
Please at least hide your explanations in spoiler tags, the thread will get messy otherwise. Keep it simple and overviewable so people don't get discouraged from reading through the list.
Seafoodking
Recruit
I doubt TW will be able to implement these within 2 years. Just the combat alone needs so much improvements. I mean AI are like zombies here.
1. They will clash into each other as if their lives don't matter. I'm sure IRL no matter what type of armor you use, you won't dare to throw your own body into another unless he's back is facing you and he's alone. What is he gonna do after he bull rushed you? get stab by everyone nearby? I mean I'm sure every enemies will feel threaten by you because you're so up close and targets you. Same as shield walls, no one will throw themselves at a shield wall like in the movies, unless they are zombies, and TW just makes AI throw their bodies in like zombies and clog up their weapon swings and thrust. If it were in real life, the amount of friendly fire would be absurd.
2. AI are zombies, they have no sense of getting surrounded and mindless continues to fight with the unit he targets. He gets surrounded and bashes to death.
3. Morale system has almost no effect in the game, no routing, no regrouping, no formation functions, no flanking, no ambushes etc. Probably our homo sapiens ancestors will have more organized fights than what we have in BL.
1. They will clash into each other as if their lives don't matter. I'm sure IRL no matter what type of armor you use, you won't dare to throw your own body into another unless he's back is facing you and he's alone. What is he gonna do after he bull rushed you? get stab by everyone nearby? I mean I'm sure every enemies will feel threaten by you because you're so up close and targets you. Same as shield walls, no one will throw themselves at a shield wall like in the movies, unless they are zombies, and TW just makes AI throw their bodies in like zombies and clog up their weapon swings and thrust. If it were in real life, the amount of friendly fire would be absurd.
2. AI are zombies, they have no sense of getting surrounded and mindless continues to fight with the unit he targets. He gets surrounded and bashes to death.
3. Morale system has almost no effect in the game, no routing, no regrouping, no formation functions, no flanking, no ambushes etc. Probably our homo sapiens ancestors will have more organized fights than what we have in BL.
Toast434
Recruit
how do i do that
Mark the text you want to hide, click on "spoiler" (that flag above the text field you're writing in) type in how you want to name the spoiler or just leave it empty, klick continue and thats it.
Blokies
Recruit
-When being attacked while you are sieging fight in the siege map, and have the garrison of the castle you are siege help and attack from the other side
-When you just took a castle and a large enemy army is outside they should siege it while you are weak instead of running away
-When creating an army while in a castle that is under siege, the reinforcements should be able to wait outside and when the siege starts attack in the back, or come inside to help there.
- When breaking or sallying out of the castle actually breaking out instead of a random battle on a weird map, so fight in the castle/siege map
- Faster experience gain, without mods it is just too slow and not fun at all
- Better garrison management, to be able to have garrisons recruit themselves, like garrison 3.0
- Steam workshop for mods
- Have siege weapons become more useful, instead of current strategy.
-Sieges should be more difficult, you are able to easily take an castle with less forces.
- Have sieges continue inside the keep, or at least add doors in between so the sieges are tiered
- Make some original castles with unique things, for example a side gate, a cave which can be entered to get into the castle underneath, or go out and attack the attackers in the back
- Ability to create better divisions in your army, in which you can specify upgrade path, so you dont have to manually click each unit and a bit of automatic recruitment, so that these divisions reinforce themselves when entering a town
- Ability to plan a field battle beforehand, this can be quite difficult to do on horseback because you really lack some overview, so a bit like the way in which you manage sieges
- Make garrisons a bit cheaper to have, or make castle give more, because it feels weird that you pay 3000 Denars for a decent garrison but only get 500 denars from that castle.
-When you just took a castle and a large enemy army is outside they should siege it while you are weak instead of running away
-When creating an army while in a castle that is under siege, the reinforcements should be able to wait outside and when the siege starts attack in the back, or come inside to help there.
- When breaking or sallying out of the castle actually breaking out instead of a random battle on a weird map, so fight in the castle/siege map
- Faster experience gain, without mods it is just too slow and not fun at all
- Better garrison management, to be able to have garrisons recruit themselves, like garrison 3.0
- Steam workshop for mods
- Have siege weapons become more useful, instead of current strategy.
-Sieges should be more difficult, you are able to easily take an castle with less forces.
- Have sieges continue inside the keep, or at least add doors in between so the sieges are tiered
- Make some original castles with unique things, for example a side gate, a cave which can be entered to get into the castle underneath, or go out and attack the attackers in the back
- Ability to create better divisions in your army, in which you can specify upgrade path, so you dont have to manually click each unit and a bit of automatic recruitment, so that these divisions reinforce themselves when entering a town
- Ability to plan a field battle beforehand, this can be quite difficult to do on horseback because you really lack some overview, so a bit like the way in which you manage sieges
- Make garrisons a bit cheaper to have, or make castle give more, because it feels weird that you pay 3000 Denars for a decent garrison but only get 500 denars from that castle.
To bump this thread, here's a few more I idea i have, and they're specific for multiplayer... Granted, I can really only see it happening a few months after this game leaves Early Access:
Bandit faction
Exactly what it says on the tin. Looters, sea raiders, deserters, hillmen, forest bandits and steppe bandits banding together to fill out a multiplayer roster of classes for a new faction.
Classic Voice for Warband owners on Steam
Somehow, i think this would need to be available for male and female avatars. I know there is a proper female voice in Warband, but it's kind of lacking.
Bandit faction
Exactly what it says on the tin. Looters, sea raiders, deserters, hillmen, forest bandits and steppe bandits banding together to fill out a multiplayer roster of classes for a new faction.
Classic Voice for Warband owners on Steam
Somehow, i think this would need to be available for male and female avatars. I know there is a proper female voice in Warband, but it's kind of lacking.
Complete rework of siege battles. As of right now they are really limited and all boil down to the same thing. We need options and castles and towns with personality so it really feels like a different battle. Tiered walls, burning oil, murder doors, and anything really.
Maybe I'm missing something, but where are the er... Banners?
Bwcon
Personally I’ve got a couple of ideas
1. Campaign story: Something I think we could all agree on is the severe lack of story in Bannerlord, and I think is one if not the main reason the world feels so “dead” that a lot of people talk about. Although it is a sandbox game, I think scripting a more meaningful campaign story could be done if cleverly implemented: Specifically a couple of ideas came to mind.
What if for each playable race there were optional story that you could select, like for example a Boudicca themed campaign where it resembles a Battanian female hero based off of history where you resist the encroaching empire invading Battania, where you could resist and unite Battania and fight off and save the land. At a certain point free campaign could take over and you could take the narrative over from there. Or you could choose a normal campaign
Just one race example but I think that this would add a lot more appeal to the game, if done correctly. You could have multiple story arks/options whenever you start a campaign for each race and could be as complicated or as simple (scripting wise) as you needed in order to implement so long as the story is engaging. Although I am kind of dreaming here it would still be cool
I suppose implementing the main campaign would be a start..
2. Proper campaign ai: for me there is nothing more frustrating than being in a small army where you are about to engage a larger force with another smaller ally army nearby that at the last moment takes off at the worst possible moment when the fight is about to start... really annoying. I heard however that some sort of control of armies is on the horizon, how far this is implemented is another story. Control of ai armies to stop all the stupidity on the campaign map and priority aka not going off to defend a far flung castle vs much needed bodies on the front etc is really needed. You all know what I am talking about, needs to be fixed and perhaps player control via influence can fix this
3. Petitions: Something that really lacks in this game is activities to do outside of war, aka peacetime activities, so why not add in some features? Something I thought would be cool is when stationed in your castle or city is the option to hold court, where you then enter your throne room, sit on the throne and take petitions from your peasants, vassals etc where you hear and deal with issues in your kingdom, / fiefdom and- include a kneeling animation for peasants and a bow for Nobles for maximum immersion!
This could have all sorts of interesting stories and effects, such as relations increases, bonuses to settlements, to companions, to yourself, trait increases or decreases, and as much as you can imagine, And have debuffs go these things if you make a poor decision, fail a dialogue check, whatever, with the more kinds of petitions and having lots and lots of varying petitions being better and would finally give us a reason to visit our Castles and throne rooms,
Anyway, yes this game is all about war but fleshing out the game for me would make it way more replay able and adding a lot more activity outside of war would be a bonus
3, Crowns, and banners for that matter, really.. it’s time
4.Way more interesting companions, similar to the mod on the nexus with their own backstories etc, something much better than what we currently have, I think following that mod as an example would be a great starting point.
5. The usual, better battle ai, way more involved diplomacy, more armours, more field battle maps, battania non royal archer line the usual stuff that should be implemented
Also Way better sieges as mentioned two posts above would be great as well,
My two cents
1. Campaign story: Something I think we could all agree on is the severe lack of story in Bannerlord, and I think is one if not the main reason the world feels so “dead” that a lot of people talk about. Although it is a sandbox game, I think scripting a more meaningful campaign story could be done if cleverly implemented: Specifically a couple of ideas came to mind.
What if for each playable race there were optional story that you could select, like for example a Boudicca themed campaign where it resembles a Battanian female hero based off of history where you resist the encroaching empire invading Battania, where you could resist and unite Battania and fight off and save the land. At a certain point free campaign could take over and you could take the narrative over from there. Or you could choose a normal campaign
Just one race example but I think that this would add a lot more appeal to the game, if done correctly. You could have multiple story arks/options whenever you start a campaign for each race and could be as complicated or as simple (scripting wise) as you needed in order to implement so long as the story is engaging. Although I am kind of dreaming here it would still be cool
I suppose implementing the main campaign would be a start..
2. Proper campaign ai: for me there is nothing more frustrating than being in a small army where you are about to engage a larger force with another smaller ally army nearby that at the last moment takes off at the worst possible moment when the fight is about to start... really annoying. I heard however that some sort of control of armies is on the horizon, how far this is implemented is another story. Control of ai armies to stop all the stupidity on the campaign map and priority aka not going off to defend a far flung castle vs much needed bodies on the front etc is really needed. You all know what I am talking about, needs to be fixed and perhaps player control via influence can fix this
3. Petitions: Something that really lacks in this game is activities to do outside of war, aka peacetime activities, so why not add in some features? Something I thought would be cool is when stationed in your castle or city is the option to hold court, where you then enter your throne room, sit on the throne and take petitions from your peasants, vassals etc where you hear and deal with issues in your kingdom, / fiefdom and- include a kneeling animation for peasants and a bow for Nobles for maximum immersion!
This could have all sorts of interesting stories and effects, such as relations increases, bonuses to settlements, to companions, to yourself, trait increases or decreases, and as much as you can imagine, And have debuffs go these things if you make a poor decision, fail a dialogue check, whatever, with the more kinds of petitions and having lots and lots of varying petitions being better and would finally give us a reason to visit our Castles and throne rooms,
Anyway, yes this game is all about war but fleshing out the game for me would make it way more replay able and adding a lot more activity outside of war would be a bonus
3, Crowns, and banners for that matter, really.. it’s time
4.Way more interesting companions, similar to the mod on the nexus with their own backstories etc, something much better than what we currently have, I think following that mod as an example would be a great starting point.
5. The usual, better battle ai, way more involved diplomacy, more armours, more field battle maps, battania non royal archer line the usual stuff that should be implemented
Also Way better sieges as mentioned two posts above would be great as well,
My two cents
Last edited:
Body-sliding; optional controlling units after death/K.O.
Generic parties;
Deserters, Manhunters & Town patrol.
Deeper dialogue:
More dialogue similar to Warband; more lore
Negative/Positive reactions based on relations
More control over character, parties and factions
Events:
Feasts/ Feast @ Tourneys/Duels/Funerals
Weddings
Diplomacy!
Female troop tree; like the Sword sisters.
Special:
Custom Units/Knighthood Orders
Claimants; similar to Warband
Invasion; giant parties like in the Prophesy of Pendor & Perisno.
Generic parties;
Deserters, Manhunters & Town patrol.
Deeper dialogue:
More dialogue similar to Warband; more lore
Negative/Positive reactions based on relations
More control over character, parties and factions
Events:
Feasts/ Feast @ Tourneys/Duels/Funerals
Weddings
Diplomacy!
Female troop tree; like the Sword sisters.
Special:
Custom Units/Knighthood Orders
Claimants; similar to Warband
Invasion; giant parties like in the Prophesy of Pendor & Perisno.
Last edited:
1. Remove trees from the middle of paths and roads.
First priority in making a usable path is removing obstacles or charting a course around them. Why are there some many trees in the middle of roads in all these Battanian villages??
2. Remove grass and shrubs from doorways, tents and houses.
If built a shelter the first thing I'd do is clear the area around it. If I have a entryway, I'm going to be using that to enter and exit my home regularly. Why are there shrubs and grass in the door? Why have you not reviewed the reports i submitted with photos etc showing this issue and fixed this after almost a year? ITS AN EAASY FIX.
3. Remove trees or relocate trees that are growing out of or into buildings.
So much sloppy work. Just fix the mess. Why are there so many trees growing out of buildings.
4. Get rid the dozens of floating objects I've submitted in bug reports. Most are still there.
Fix the sloppy work on nearly every scene before release. Just playtest them. Walk around in them. In nearly every scene I can find half dozen floating and clipping objects within 10-15 minutes. Quit acting like amateurs and have some pride.
5. NPC interaction, Diplomacy, random events, unique discoverable map locations, more immersive scenes, intelligent battle AI
First priority in making a usable path is removing obstacles or charting a course around them. Why are there some many trees in the middle of roads in all these Battanian villages??
2. Remove grass and shrubs from doorways, tents and houses.
If built a shelter the first thing I'd do is clear the area around it. If I have a entryway, I'm going to be using that to enter and exit my home regularly. Why are there shrubs and grass in the door? Why have you not reviewed the reports i submitted with photos etc showing this issue and fixed this after almost a year? ITS AN EAASY FIX.
3. Remove trees or relocate trees that are growing out of or into buildings.
So much sloppy work. Just fix the mess. Why are there so many trees growing out of buildings.
4. Get rid the dozens of floating objects I've submitted in bug reports. Most are still there.
Fix the sloppy work on nearly every scene before release. Just playtest them. Walk around in them. In nearly every scene I can find half dozen floating and clipping objects within 10-15 minutes. Quit acting like amateurs and have some pride.
5. NPC interaction, Diplomacy, random events, unique discoverable map locations, more immersive scenes, intelligent battle AI
Last edited:
One thing I never got about the game is the speed of in-game time.
If you play with dynasties and death enabled, time should move in a significantly faster pace than it does now. It's the only way I see to make dynasties actually matter. Otherwise, it just doesn't matter if you have tons of heirs waiting when you have already conquered the entire map by the time you're like what, 40?
Conquering the entire of Battania shouldn't be possible in just two years. It should be a man's life work. Crossing the entire map shouldn't be a matter of just days, it should be months. Making your precious time in life all the more precious. Of course leveling speed and many, many other aspects of the game would also have to be increased and altered. Just thinking out loud here.
Also: actual banners on the battlefield (available in more than 6 colours...) would also be a lovely addition. But one can only hope.
If you play with dynasties and death enabled, time should move in a significantly faster pace than it does now. It's the only way I see to make dynasties actually matter. Otherwise, it just doesn't matter if you have tons of heirs waiting when you have already conquered the entire map by the time you're like what, 40?
Conquering the entire of Battania shouldn't be possible in just two years. It should be a man's life work. Crossing the entire map shouldn't be a matter of just days, it should be months. Making your precious time in life all the more precious. Of course leveling speed and many, many other aspects of the game would also have to be increased and altered. Just thinking out loud here.
Also: actual banners on the battlefield (available in more than 6 colours...) would also be a lovely addition. But one can only hope.
HugoTheFrenchMan
Grandmaster Knight
Custom Banners and Uniforms Pack (CBU Pack)
NEW VERSION !For the 1.1.5 versionThis mod changes all the banners with custom ones, changes uniform colors, which are natively ovesaturated, thus makes balance in natural cloth color and
www.nexusmods.com
