Well, let's get started on the wolf killing. Unvote Vote: Vermillion Hawk
He really jumped on my radar lately. Trying not to be too hostile.
He really jumped on my radar lately. Trying not to be too hostile.
Maybe tomorrow, but now I'm convinced of Hawk's guilt. Moose is still acting suspicious, claiming Hawk is not suspicious when clearly he is the most suspicious of the bunch right now.Big McLarge-Huge said:Y no Vieira 4 u?
Phonemelter said:Vieira said:Very possibly. I'd be curious to know if she was the Doctor for Day 1 or not, but I fear that's not information we will be finding out. The narration does allude to that, but I am probably reading too much into it.
For the sake of clarity, the narration is meant to just reveal the dead's role - not what night their action was supposed to take place. Anything that might sound like it is worded that way is just due to my rambling and has no meaning whatsoever.
Lord Brutus said:Well, let's get started on the wolf killing. Unvote Vote: Vermillion Hawk
He really jumped on my radar lately. Trying not to be too hostile.
MaHuD said:For now I am sticking to Eternal Delta being wolves, I could see Moose or Hawk as 3rd but Brutus is not playing how he plays his wolf self.
Vermillion_Hawk said:You mention a specific reason why that might be so in your post, which also happens to inform my own judgement as to why I think Adaham might be suspicious. So it's not necessarily the math that's compelling.
Delta[K] said:@moose couldn't the percentages you calculated for biggie hold true to anyone considering that we don't know roles?
Interesting, but, aside from the fact that Moose is innocent, I don't like cases based on interactions of players still alive. What do you have against Hawk based only on his behaviour?QuailLover said:So Vermillion Hawk suggests that it could be Adaham/McHuge. Nothing suspicious here, right?
But Moose swoops in, with MATH, and tries his hardest to prove that McHuge is indeed a wolf. I think this is packish behavior. Especially since Vermilion Hawk also votes for Moose right after that, and it gets some sort of wagon rolling. At the moment, I think both of them could be wolves.
Tempting. Convince me, how is Hawk trying to no be too hostile and why is that wolfish?Lord Brutus said:Well, let's get started on the wolf killing. Unvote Vote: Vermillion Hawk
He really jumped on my radar lately. Trying not to be too hostile.
Good, you're innocent. I could vote Eternal. What do you have against him?Delta[K] said:Humumummum speculations about the night activity do actually make things confusing. I could very easily go in circles talking about how xardob and/or biggie killed llandy bc it wouldn't make any sense for them to kill her bc of their agreements. Same circular reasoning can be applied to eternal. He wanted to lynch her during the day so it also wouldn't make sense for him to off her during the night.
For the sake of my own sanity I'm not going to go down that path. I'm going to stick with my initial suspicions of eternal. Gonna keep watching him. His actions during day 1 still seem off to me.
But since the wolves have more information than the villagers, they can easily manipulate the information and make a villager look like he has a higher statistical chance of being a wolf.Moose! said:But we do know the roles - didn't you read the description? And, if we have reason to believe that he is not a cop (innocent) because he inadvertently told us that he isn't a cop on the first day. This means that his likelihood of being a wolf is significantly greater - you are either a cop, a doctor, or a wolf. Any player could be all three, but in a game that is purported to be random, I think this is a compelling reason to vote him out.
Moose! said:Delta[K] said:@moose couldn't the percentages you calculated for biggie hold true to anyone considering that we don't know roles?
But we do know the roles - didn't you read the description? And, if we have reason to believe that he is not a cop (innocent) because he inadvertently told us that he isn't a cop on the first day. This means that his likelihood of being a wolf is significantly greater - you are either a cop, a doctor, or a wolf. Any player could be all three, but in a game that is purported to be random, I think this is a compelling reason to vote him out.
Yes, they are.Delta[K] said:Btw... Are vigilantes and cops the same thing (i feel like that question was already asked.. Sorry)?
Delta[K] said:Btw... Are vigilantes and cops the same thing (i feel like that question was already asked.. Sorry)?
Phonemelter said:Not usually. Cops are normally the same as Seers (intended in the original setup, but I changed it because I don't like seers), but I've always thought of them in my mind as Vigilantes because here in 'Murrica cops shoot people.
Delta[K] said:What specific reason?
I don't think vermillion is suspicious. I don't get scummy vibes from any of his posts. I just think he needs to elaborate a bit.