Is it, though? To me it seems like its the other way around.
You guys claim combat is superior to warband, yet fail to name an example.
You guys see that there is a mod that shows how TaleWorlds could easily tweak combat to be flat out better, yet you say that TaleWorlds shouldn't bother looking at it and that it should just stay a mod.
You guys say they should just push it to EA now but fail to realise that while yes, it's still labeled as unfished, the game WILL get negative reviews for being incomplete and having parts that are far below expectations, combat being the most prominent one.
You all keep arguing that the people that played warband just want warband 2.0. That's not the case for most people. People want a good, skillbased game. And no offense to all of you, but claiming you know more than the people that spent thousands of hours playing warband AND hundreds of hours playing the beta is flat out wrong. Change my view.