Summary: I have 3 family members with smithing above 200. My main char is level 255. I crafted hundreds of two handed axes but not a single weapon came out as masterly. The best I have seen so far is "high-quality" (in german localization it's "hochwertig"). I asked myself if chances are too low and I'm too impatient, but even a low chance in % should result in at least 1 masterly weapon out of many hundreds, right? What confirmed that smithing is completely bugged is when I took the perk that adds 2% swing damage. Weapons crafted after I took this don't have any bonus swing damage. It's not working.
And by the way, smithing is a pain in the ass. I'm using a macro now to prevent my hand from dying.
How to Reproduce: Craft a two handed axe above level 200 and wait for perks to kick in
Have you used cheats and if so which: None
Scene Name (if related): --
Media (Screenshots & Video): --
Computer Specs: Not relevant
Mods: Achievement unlocker, banner colors. Only these two.
And by the way, smithing is a pain in the ass. I'm using a macro now to prevent my hand from dying.
How to Reproduce: Craft a two handed axe above level 200 and wait for perks to kick in
Have you used cheats and if so which: None
Scene Name (if related): --
Media (Screenshots & Video): --
Computer Specs: Not relevant
Mods: Achievement unlocker, banner colors. Only these two.