Well, let's get started on the wolf killing. Unvote Vote: Vermillion Hawk
He really jumped on my radar lately. Trying not to be too hostile.
He really jumped on my radar lately. Trying not to be too hostile.
[Werewolf] Phonewolf: The Appening - Battery drained - Infected Apps win!
- Thread starter Phonemelter
- Start date
Users who are viewing this thread
Votecount
Big McLarge (2) - Moose!, Hawk
Hawk (2) - QuailLover, Brutus
Vieira (1) - Big McLarge
Brutus (1) - Xardob
Eternal (1) - MaHuD
Not Voting (4) - Delta[K], Eternal, Vieira, Lumos
Big McLarge (2) - Moose!, Hawk
Hawk (2) - QuailLover, Brutus
Vieira (1) - Big McLarge
Brutus (1) - Xardob
Eternal (1) - MaHuD
Not Voting (4) - Delta[K], Eternal, Vieira, Lumos
Maybe tomorrow, but now I'm convinced of Hawk's guilt. Moose is still acting suspicious, claiming Hawk is not suspicious when clearly he is the most suspicious of the bunch right now.Big McLarge-Huge said:
![Delta[K]](/data/avatars/m/438/438998.jpg?1579545094){kind=avatar}
Delta[K]
Regular
MaHuD said:
Why?
Vermillion_Hawk said:
What specific reason?
I don't think vermillion is suspicious. I don't get scummy vibes from any of his posts. I just think he needs to elaborate a bit.
Humumummum speculations about the night activity do actually make things confusing. I could very easily go in circles talking about how xardob and/or biggie killed llandy bc it wouldn't make any sense for them to kill her bc of their agreements. Same circular reasoning can be applied to eternal. He wanted to lynch her during the day so it also wouldn't make sense for him to off her during the night.
For the sake of my own sanity I'm not going to go down that path. I'm going to stick with my initial suspicions of eternal. Gonna keep watching him. His actions during day 1 still seem off to me.
@moose couldn't the percentages you calculated for biggie hold true to anyone considering that we don't know roles?
I need to read over vieira's posts again. I think I zone out every time he comes up bc I still don't understand why he is suspicious to so many people
Delta[K] said:
But we do know the roles - didn't you read the description? And, if we have reason to believe that he is not a cop (innocent) because he inadvertently told us that he isn't a cop on the first day. This means that his likelihood of being a wolf is significantly greater - you are either a cop, a doctor, or a wolf. Any player could be all three, but in a game that is purported to be random, I think this is a compelling reason to vote him out.
Interesting, but, aside from the fact that Moose is innocent, I don't like cases based on interactions of players still alive. What do you have against Hawk based only on his behaviour?QuailLover said:
Tempting. Convince me, how is Hawk trying to no be too hostile and why is that wolfish?Lord Brutus said:
Good, you're innocent. I could vote Eternal. What do you have against him?Delta[K] said:
But since the wolves have more information than the villagers, they can easily manipulate the information and make a villager look like he has a higher statistical chance of being a wolf.Moose! said:
Delta[K] said:
Not usually. Cops are normally the same as Seers (intended in the original setup, but I changed it because I don't like seers), but I've always thought of them in my mind as Vigilantes because here in 'Murrica cops shoot people.
Delta[K]
Regular
@xardob from what I remember off the top of my head eternal set up a case against veteran players saying it is typical for hosts to pair up veteran players and new players as packmates. He then grouped you, adaham, and llandy together and then proceeded to single out llandy. This wouldn't stike me as too suspicious as it makes sense to focus your case on one person but I don't recall him ever giving too much explanation as to why llandy was on the top of his list. (I will have to go through day one posts to double check myself. Will do later. Currently on phone.) By his reasoning I would have thought you, ham, and llandy would have had equal chance of being a wolf but he seemed so intent on voting her.
Honestly I originally thought llandy and eternal were packmates. I chose eternal to see if they would react together or if eternal would switch his vote to me but even then he kept his vote on llandy. I still don't understand why.
@eternal mind explaining a bit?
Honestly I originally thought llandy and eternal were packmates. I chose eternal to see if they would react together or if eternal would switch his vote to me but even then he kept his vote on llandy. I still don't understand why.
@eternal mind explaining a bit?
Phonemelter said:
Delta[K] said:
A specific reason that Moose mentions towards the end of his latest MooseMathtm post.
Mention my name (three times or more or less) and here I am.
While I couldn't definitely speak about Vieira,
You should really try harder with your analyses if you don't want to end up with Big-Mc-Super errors.
While I couldn't definitely speak about Vieira,
You should really try harder with your analyses if you don't want to end up with Big-Mc-Super errors.
