[WSC2] Questions & Suggestions

Status
Not open for further replies.

Surkan

Baron
WBNW
Best answers
0
Hi guys, sorry for RK's dropping out. Tried to make it work with my busy schedule but couldn't, and there wasn't much will to continue without the in-game leader present, my apologies.
 

Fietta

buıʇʇǝs uoıʇɔǝɹıp ʞɔɐʇʇɐ
Subforum Moderator
M&BWBWF&SNWVC
Best answers
0
Btw in future tournaments, since you've put some strict stupid rules on names, I also suggest that when teams are 're nl', the opposing team can't go to your spawn whilst you're sorting classes and drops. If they randomly come over, they'll know exactly what you're doing. This isn't a problem in group stages but for knockouts it can pose a problem.
 

Aeronwen

Marquis
Best answers
0
Fietta said:
Btw in future tournaments, since you've put some strict stupid rules on names, I also suggest that when teams are 're nl', the opposing team can't go to your spawn whilst you're sorting classes and drops. If they randomly come over, they'll know exactly what you're doing. This isn't a problem in group stages but for knockouts it can pose a problem.
I am going to regret this but...
what strict stupid rules?
 
Best answers
0
Fietta said:
Btw in future tournaments, since you've put some strict stupid rules on names
It's not even a strict rule. It's just never really been enforced in previous tournaments and players have become accustomed to using whichever name they want.
 

Fietta

buıʇʇǝs uoıʇɔǝɹıp ʞɔɐʇʇɐ
Subforum Moderator
M&BWBWF&SNWVC
Best answers
0
How's the prize pool being distributed?
 

Charlini

Master Knight
Best answers
0
Fietta said:
How's the prize pool being distributed?
Once all the money is gathered we'll count, and if we consider it's enough to split we definetly would set a prize for 2nd place. But with the size of the rosters and the quantity presented, I can guarantee that unless something unexpected happens there won't be for a 3rd place.
 
Best answers
0
So Scarta and Hursty did the same thing Bruce did. Both IDs are banned but they get off with a warning and Bruce gets banned for the entire tournament?
He surely ****ed up not checking his key before but that seems a bit harsh.
 

Charlini

Master Knight
Best answers
0
HKP said:
So Scarta and Hursty did the same thing Bruce did. Both IDs are banned but they get off with a warning and Bruce gets banned for the entire tournament?
He surely **** up not checking his key before but that seems a bit harsh.
No, they did not do the same thing that Bruce did, checking all the logs, they never got to play a single round with that ID, they just mistook on the sign up and mixed ids just on forum, so we didn't have a reason to ban the players but only the ID. Bruce on the other hand did play last official with the ID already played by different subjects on previous tournaments, and as rules state, if it happens, we're FORCED to ban him, because rules state it that way.
 

Gibby Jr

Marquis
Best answers
0
Hero_of_Ferelden said:
But it's Arni's ID?
Charlini said:
-Added the ID 689147 and the player 'Bruce' From GR both as permanent bans. ID as it's clearly not unique and therefore banned, and Bruce because he actually got to play with this ID last official, after it has been used in officials on other tournaments. Unfortunetly, any of the players who played with that ID on the past, are not in our tournament, so we can't set any punish to them besides banning the ID. The only case would be Arni but he never got to play a single official round on an official of any tournament with that ID, as the addition itself of the player got rejected by Deacon on that specific tournament back on the day.
 

Charlini

Master Knight
Best answers
0
Hero_of_Ferelden said:
But it's Arni's ID?
Theorically, yeah, he shared it with many people, but he didnt get to play any tournament with it, if it was just arni's ID, Bruce wouldn't be banned, but the thing is that the ID was shared with more than one guy, and there's people who played on different tournaments with that ID, the most recent case Mous, in WSC1
 
Best answers
0
From what i can see there's no evidence of MouS playing on that ID.

Week 1 - https://forums.taleworlds.com/index.php/topic,368753.msg8825487.html#msg8825487

week 2 - No ID check evidence https://forums.taleworlds.com/index.php/topic,369164.msg8831332.html#msg8831332

Week 3 - No ID check evidence https://forums.taleworlds.com/index.php/topic,369428.msg8836364.html#msg8836364

Week 4 - Unity Didn't play

Week 5 - No ID check evidence https://forums.taleworlds.com/index.php/topic,370335.msg8846215.html#msg8846215

Semi finals - No ID check evidence https://forums.taleworlds.com/index.php/topic,370653.msg8854350.html#msg8854350

Finals - https://forums.taleworlds.com/index.php/topic,370812.msg8858689.html#msg8858689
 

Fietta

buıʇʇǝs uoıʇɔǝɹıp ʞɔɐʇʇɐ
Subforum Moderator
M&BWBWF&SNWVC
Best answers
0
Charlini and friends do 1 minute of sense checking for everyone else but 1 hour for teammates

*Charlini attemps to save himself by asking yami pirate for all IDs of Mous in WSC*
 

Watly

Grandmaster Knight
WB
Best answers
0
As for the other people mentioned:

Gangsta_Risen_to_Fight - Can't find any screenshots where he played. He also got removed in the later stage of the ENL.

Bregan_Dert_WENOM - Was part of an application that was weeks late and the team didn't join the tournament.



I understand that you want to deal with ID sharing, but I don't see the ground for it when you don't show that it has been used by others. If some random guy adds my ID to himself, am I suddenly barred from using my ID even though he doesn't have access to it?
 

Charlini

Master Knight
Best answers
0
Hero_of_Ferelden said:
This is actually unexpected, as you can see here https://forums.taleworlds.com/index.php/topic,368791.msg8831284.html#msg8831284 , Saw an addition with this same ID that bruce used, so i went straight to week 5's match and saw that Mous played, assumming that it's based on that same ID. Didn't even consider that he had another one. The only reason that Bruce is actually banned, is because following the rules if the ID is found that has been played before, we have to insta ban the player. So what I'm gonna do now is check if there's any ID screenshot over unity matches, and in case of absence of ID proof or which key he actually used to play, he shall be unbanned(not the ID though).

Fietta said:
As much as I dislike bruce, this decision taken by the admin team is based on something objective, which is the fact of him being found playing under another ID, and cause and consequence written on the same rules that were even reminded last week. Trying to apply the rules over a tournament with this quanity of IDs and names is hard, if Aeronwen finds something we look over it and deliver the punishment based on what rules stablish. So instead of taking another chance to throw another unproductive post Fietta, stay quiet and we'll review this case ourselves.
 

Charlini

Master Knight
Best answers
0
HKP said:
and the point is not that he gets punished. But for the rest of the tournament is hella over the top
I actually do agree, and I think this rule must have been reworked before the tournament started, noone did any complain about it, and as in many previous tournaments there weren't many problems because of it I didn't consider editing it viable aswell. Editing rules mid-tournament is not an option, one of the reasons why WNL6 involved so much unfixable drama. So for now I'll handle Bruce's case today and after that we'll see what happens regarding this type of scenarios where people have shared IDs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.