Hamel
Sergeant Knight
Why nerf the melee capabilities of archers at all? They're already severely disadvantaged in that regard. It seems to me that most people who think archers are in need of a nerf think it's their ranged abilities that are the problem.
Decreasing archer athletics is a terrible idea. I doubt it will have nearly the beneficial effect on the competitive tactical metagame (which these changes seem to be solely focused on) that Lust seems to think it will. However, it will make a huge difference for archers attempting to melee or dodge anything.
Remember that public games are the foundation of competitive play. It's what people play between matches and what many people only play. Pub archers almost never have shields. Shieldless archers have to dodge or manual block everything with their already inferior stats, lowering their athletics will cripple that.
If archers picking up shields is really a problem for game balance, why not lower quiver sizes? Swapping out one of your quivers for a shield would be a more difficult choice, then. In addition, it would also promote more cautious firing and increase the tactical aspect of retrieving ammunition.
Decreasing archer athletics is a terrible idea. I doubt it will have nearly the beneficial effect on the competitive tactical metagame (which these changes seem to be solely focused on) that Lust seems to think it will. However, it will make a huge difference for archers attempting to melee or dodge anything.
Remember that public games are the foundation of competitive play. It's what people play between matches and what many people only play. Pub archers almost never have shields. Shieldless archers have to dodge or manual block everything with their already inferior stats, lowering their athletics will cripple that.
If archers picking up shields is really a problem for game balance, why not lower quiver sizes? Swapping out one of your quivers for a shield would be a more difficult choice, then. In addition, it would also promote more cautious firing and increase the tactical aspect of retrieving ammunition.