Splintert said:
Disregarding individual player skill,
If you place one archer versus one swordsman in open ground the swordsman will win.
If you place one archer versus one swordsman where the archer defends a fortress, the archer will win.
If you place one archer versus one swordsman where the swordsman defends a fortress, the swordsman will win.
If you place 2 archers versus 1 swordsman on open ground, the archers win.
If you place 2 swordsmen versus 1 archer who is defending a fortress, the swordsmen will win (unless they are stupid)
Seems pretty balanced to me.
The archer wins in all cases except 2 swordsmen v 1 archer. Even between two experienced players, the archer will still win the majority of the time, as he is only slightly disadvantaged in melee, but has the advantage of 0 shield skill. An inexperienced archer still has a good chance of getting a shot on.
When there is more than one archer, then their ability to crossfire means that any number of melee increasingly becomes obsolete.
I have never seen a full warbow wielding archer faction not dominate.