Experiencing the looting. Instead of reading textes, at some point we should get into the village and shoot, stab villiagers as they run about or some of them fighting back. Breaking the doors of their homes and killing any hiding peasants. Screams, laughters and panic all over. Some killer dialogs maybe: "Please, don't kill me, sire! I have a family!" "Noooo, help mee!".
Well, I have one more idea, and it may sound a little off but here goes: raping. All in text of course, while doing those sick stuff I just told, a running young woman gets close to the player and dialog screen pops out (like at the beginning of the game with the Merchant) "Please, leave me alone!" "You shyless pig, get your hands off me!", "Shut it woman!" "Hey there love, got lost?" "Scream all you want dear, no one can hear you." and so on. All of these actions should decrease the honour point of the player to negative numbers.