AWdeV:
You are going into the mind****ery bit a little too much. I really don't think Xardob wants to make this game even more confusing than it already is. I mean, what would be his motivation? Everyone at the end of the game would be going "WTF?!" at him and he'd be be like, "Sorry guys. This game was confusing, I know." Honestly, I think he means what he means with his narration. Twisting the word 'wolfsbane' is a little silly and perhaps a little anti village.
I do like your idea, though, AWdeV, about Whoopin being snared. It was "just outside his house" which implies he left his house to do something. Would that imply he was a special? I get this is role fishing at this point and that's entirely anti-village, but that's what Whoopin's noose hangs from at this point. Either he's a special or a wolf. What I DON'T like about that is that we had a kill last night AND a block/whatever Frisian's was + whatever Whoopin's was. So wolves must've had at least one action - and if Whoopin is a villain and was blocked, the chances of that going through is... iffy. Granted, another unblocked villain could've done it, but that block on him does cut into the chances he's a villain.
I did forget about Whoopin's accusation of you, I'm sorry, I feel quite stupid now. I haven't called anyone insane, actually. I find him as suspicious and villainy as I did before. His poor post on you (I didn't even remember it. That's how bad it was) doesn't help matters. Read my first post on Day 2, though. Prior to this theory you just proposed, I did not see a way Whoopin could be a villain, and even now it's.. iffy. It goes against my being to acknowledge the fact he's most likely an innocent.
Yes, when I mentioned vigilante, that was a dun goof. I was going to fix it, then I went "screw it." Also, a block isn't a weapon the villains usually use? Now that's a little ridiculous. In many games I've played the villains had some sort of roleblocker. What 'special' do they have otherwise? I mean, Whoopin's game had quite a few fancy thing, but a staple secondary role for villains has always been a block. Even in traditional Mafia, a Consort was one of the most common roles.
Another point about Whoopin: Yeah, your post was pretty silly. It was pretty much a ridicule post and that's it, with some metagaming thrown in. I don't pretend the net could've only been done by villains. I know the kill was. Crossbow bolt. Villain weapon. The net and the wolfsbane confused me from my first post til now. Even in the very post you quoted, I was hesitant. I don't like Whoopin. He is suspicious. But I'm not going to go on the hunter hunt for a person I believe is innocent from the narration, no matter how much of a grudge I carry.
Regarding Bgfan: I do not understand him. In a game I got him lynched because he did something that only a villain would do, and he turned up innocent. He baffles me. He was suspicious to me in my previous incarnation, but I didn't go on the hunt for him because I do not understand him. He's baffling, and honestly, I was a bit scared to get an innocent Bgfan lynched again. It's the same way here. I don't understand him as him. If you want a case against me based on Bgfan's activity, go ahead. I'd have no defense, because Bgfan is Bgfan and not a creature that I can understand.
Regarding the net: Look at it this way.
Kill: Definitely a villain kill. A crossbow. Why would a wolf have this?
From Crossbow -> net. Understandable, very physical. Weapon, bow, net, something associated with hunters.
From Crossbow -> wolfsbane. Wolfsbane honestly seems to be a more sciencey weapon. I wouldn't be surprised if Hojo used it, actually. It just seems unusual that hunters would swap from a crossbow to suddenly using plants.
If this is redundant, sorry, I didn't proofread. I'm in a bit of a hurry, but I hope this satisfies AWdeV. I am very much liking the theory about Whoopin stepping into it..
