Yeah. Top problem is people not voting for the wolves. 
[Werewolf] SMAC: Unity [Game ends!]
- 主题发起人 MaHuD
- 开始时间
正在查看此主题的用户
But you're a wolf. Why would I listen to you?
Adaham 说:Actually, Whoopin posting here is the least of the problems this game has. Just sayin'...
Yeah, you sill got me posing from my phone when droning!
Oh lord...
FrisianDude
Archduke
ok, not random. That wasn't entirely fair.Magorian Aximand 说:
Truuue but eh.Adaham 说:
I think I agree with Xardob and Adaham. They make a compelling case! vote: Vieira
I'm not sure what to think right now. I was totally wrong with Eli and now I'm doubting every idea that pops into my brainz.
The events certainly feel like they put more suspicion on Pizza, but I dunno. I don't think Pizza would be dumb enough to kill Facemelter overnight.
As I mentioned in discussion with Face, I would wager there is likely to be one wolf off and one wolf on the wagon. So I'd definitely think there is a wolf between Pizza, Adaham and Hawk (though I think it'd be dumb for Pizza to kill Face if he is a wolf). That would leave a wolf in this list Sootshader, Llandy, Xardob, Frisiandude, Magorian. I would say Soot or Llandy have the safest 'packie voting spot' but my gut is still screaming and sticking the finger at Magorian. But as I mentioned, I'm not sure I can trust my gut after yesterday.
I'm not sure what to think right now. I was totally wrong with Eli and now I'm doubting every idea that pops into my brainz.
The events certainly feel like they put more suspicion on Pizza, but I dunno. I don't think Pizza would be dumb enough to kill Facemelter overnight.
As I mentioned in discussion with Face, I would wager there is likely to be one wolf off and one wolf on the wagon. So I'd definitely think there is a wolf between Pizza, Adaham and Hawk (though I think it'd be dumb for Pizza to kill Face if he is a wolf). That would leave a wolf in this list Sootshader, Llandy, Xardob, Frisiandude, Magorian. I would say Soot or Llandy have the safest 'packie voting spot' but my gut is still screaming and sticking the finger at Magorian. But as I mentioned, I'm not sure I can trust my gut after yesterday.
BTW, re: Pizza...did I miss the point where he actually dropped out of this game completely? Considering the track record he mentioned earlier this game, that's pretty surprising. Does that mean this forum actually managed to turn him from a confident & dedicated spammaster into a lurking no-show....WITHIN ONE GAME-DAY?
That's awesome, even if it's quite terrible, but yeah...awesome, too...
That's awesome, even if it's quite terrible, but yeah...awesome, too...
FrisianDude
Archduke
that's probably my fault :þ
Or Phone/Magorian who debated everything he said somehow. Or both. Or either. Or neither. Eh. I blame Whoopin.
Or Phone/Magorian who debated everything he said somehow. Or both. Or either. Or neither. Eh. I blame Whoopin.
Adaham 说:BTW, re: Pizza...did I miss the point where he actually dropped out of this game completely? Considering the track record he mentioned earlier this game, that's pretty surprising. Does that mean this forum actually managed to turn him from a confident & dedicated spammaster into a lurking no-show....WITHIN ONE GAME-DAY?
That's awesome, even if it's quite terrible, but yeah...awesome, too...
I think he gave up for that game day, but has not checked us to see if it's day 2 yet. I would certainly hope he hasn't dropped.
Well, I was hoping you'd tell me, cause it sure was strange as ****.
Thinking about when Vieira would self-vote him, I come to the conlusion "never". Yet he did. Which is strange. VERY strange.
In my experience, villagers only vote themselves when terribly frustrated (I'm speaking out of experience), yet he doesn't come across as frustrated at all. In fact, it's much more jokey, laissez-fair, en-passant, and other useless French words. Which points at wolfdom. So yeah, it's definitely wolfish.
Why didn't you come to that conclusion yourself? Worried that you might lose your second packmate like that? Is that why you unvoted?
Thinking about when Vieira would self-vote him, I come to the conlusion "never". Yet he did. Which is strange. VERY strange.
In my experience, villagers only vote themselves when terribly frustrated (I'm speaking out of experience), yet he doesn't come across as frustrated at all. In fact, it's much more jokey, laissez-fair, en-passant, and other useless French words. Which points at wolfdom. So yeah, it's definitely wolfish.
Why didn't you come to that conclusion yourself? Worried that you might lose your second packmate like that? Is that why you unvoted?
As weird as that vote was from a villager perspective, it's even weirder from a wolf. My initial read was the same as yours, yet I can't see what a wolf would gain from that without entering on deep WIFOM territory. I guess I wanted the opinion of an expert on self votes.
And I'm still waiting for that wall of laments. Maybe it could spark some new discussion.
And I'm still waiting for that wall of laments. Maybe it could spark some new discussion.
FrisianDude
Archduke
Good question actually. Vieira, what's the dealio?
Deep WIFOM territory is an excellent hiding place for a wolf. You can always WIFOM a step further, or claim that somebody else is taking it too far. In any case, it causes confusion and that's something that helps a wolf more than it does an innocent.Xardob 说:As weird as that vote was from a villager perspective, it's even weirder from a wolf. My initial read was the same as yours, yet I can't see what a wolf would gain from that without entering on deep WIFOM territory. I guess I wanted the opinion of an expert on self votes.
Also, the fact you're doubting that it could/should be wolfish is a proof that it kinda works for him.
More confusion, more wolfish behavior.Vieira 说:
On an unrealted note...how come that the fact that I said I was burned out let to basically everybody else (except for Xardob, the old WW-junkie) disappearing? Yes, I know Vieira and Frisian are also around, but man...
Is MaHuD prodding anybody? Like Pizza for instance? Or himself?
