[Werewolf] SMAC: Unity [Game ends!]

正在查看此主题的用户

Xardob 说:
Also, I followed Melter's link and came across a pretty convincing argument indicating that both Mag and Pizza are innocents. I'm surprised that didn't occur to me before.

So you understand the masterplan?
 
Magorian Aximand 说:
I gave you that reason. Give me that vote.
I'm not sure I like your reason too much. I think that's just his hunting style and him tunneling very hard.

I mean, it's not effective at all for a wolf to paint a villager that way. It's not believable and it doesn't make the case any stronger. The only thing he accomplishes with that is driving people away from the wagon he's trying to ride. Unless you're arguing that this is just a smokescreen for him to attack someone without having the risk of actually exposing his target role.

Phonemelter 说:
Xardob 说:
Also, I followed Melter's link and came across a pretty convincing argument indicating that both Mag and Pizza are innocents. I'm surprised that didn't occur to me before.

So you understand the masterplan?
I don't think I do. I'd be surprised if you saw the same thing I did.
 
Phonemelter 说:
Xardob 说:
Also, I followed Melter's link and came across a pretty convincing argument indicating that both Mag and Pizza are innocents. I'm surprised that didn't occur to me before.

So you understand the masterplan?

i don get it

Are you relating Mag/Pizza to Mag/Nomad? Or is this referencing self-vote frustration and the fact that I'd always rather get the wolf?

Xardob 说:
Magorian Aximand 说:
I gave you that reason. Give me that vote.
I'm not sure I like your reason too much. I think that's just his hunting style and him tunneling very hard.

I mean, it's not effective at all for a wolf to paint a villager that way. It's not believable and it doesn't make the case any stronger. The only thing he accomplishes with that is driving people away from the wagon he's trying to ride. Unless you're arguing that this is just a smokescreen for him to attack someone without having the risk of actually exposing his target role.

It's not effective here, but I think he comes from a meta where that works. How can that be a hunting style when it's not actually investigative? It's purely accusatory.
 
As I pointed out, I'd say it could work for both innocents and wolves. Part of the game is to bash people over the head with "LYNCH THIS GUY LYNCH THIS GUY LYNCH THIS GUY" because all you need to do get people to your side (which can be accomplished many ways).
 
Innocents have to campaign, but campaigning is in addition to hunting. This isn't just bad campaigning, it's not hunting. There's no attempt to find wolves, only to make people look like wolves.
 
Magorian Aximand 说:
There's no attempt to find wolves, only to make people look like wolves.

In Pizza's defence, this is actually inkeeping with what he said in a post I'm too lazy to find. That if he can't hunt wolves, he tries to identify innocents, so that he can rule them out and use a process-of-elimination method for then lynching the most wolfy of whoever remains.

It's a method I like, although Pizza seems to go about it in a very.... unique way.
 
Phonemelter 说:
Sometimes you need to make people look more wolfy than they actually are if people are to believe you.

You're missing the key part about not actually doing any hunting...

Pharaoh X Llandy 说:
Magorian Aximand 说:
There's no attempt to find wolves, only to make people look like wolves.

In Pizza's defence, this is actually inkeeping with what he said in a post I'm too lazy to find. That if he can't hunt wolves, he tries to identify innocents, so that he can rule them out and use a process-of-elimination method for then lynching the most wolfy of whoever remains.

It's a method I like, although Pizza seems to go about it in a very.... unique way.

That would be fine, but that's not what he's done.
 
I like where this is going. But we do need a couple more players over here. If Vieira, Hawk, Eli and Frisian got online, this would get very fun very quickly.

Pharaoh X Llandy 说:
Why does all the stuff happen when I'm about to go to bed? :sad:
Don't worry, I'm pretty sure we'll still be doing this tomorrow. The you can join us.
 
Xardob 说:
If Vieira, Hawk, Eli and Frisian got online, this would get very fun very quickly.

I doubt Eli's even still playing the game, and I've no idea what Hawk's doing. I hoped MaHuD would have said something by now.
 
Bed time for me. I'll check in a few times tomorrow when I'm not busy and respond to anything that needs my attention, but I don't envision having time for lengthy posts.
 
后退
顶部 底部