[Werewolf] SMAC: Unity [Game ends!]

[Magorian Aximand]

You know I'm a fan of that vote, but lets pretend that you can't get that wagon rolling. Can you dip down to 4th best?

 

[Xardob]

What's the price to put that thing on Pizza?

Admit that you lost our little quote war. (I mean, your lack of answer is enough, but a public admission would be the icing on the cake.)

If not this, what else are you willing to offer?

 

[Magorian Aximand]

It's not a quote war until I reply. And I haven't even dug into reading and considering it yet. The fact that there's no way I'll vote for you today renders it rather not time sensitive.

What could I even offer? I'm a campaigner, not a bargainer. You know this.

 

[Xardob]

You could promise to convince you packmates to target someone else tonight. Wait, scratch that, last time I made this deal I got horribly backstabbed. I even think it was you.

But if you want to convince me, make a short case on him based on a single point. If I can't justify that behaviour from an innocent, my vote is yours.

 

[Pharaoh Llandy]

Well then here's a more important question for you: I'm willing to compromise and vote for Soot if my Pizza lynch (or Kronic, situation depending) isn't going to happen. Are you willing to vote for Pizza if the Sootwagon doesn't pan out?

No, I'd not vote for Pizza if I can't get enough votes on Soot; Pizza has given an indication that he's willing to compromise too, and players who can compromise have the foundations of forming a consensus. I wouldn't be willing to compromise any lower down than Eli, and that includes not compromising by lynching you.

Well, if anyone is interested, I do have a vote I probably won't be using, so...

Five dollah?

 

[Troll]

You know I'm a fan of that vote, but lets pretend that you can't get that wagon rolling. Can you dip down to 4th best?

I'll take it under consideration if that's the only way to stop the day from resulting in a no lynch.

 

[Magorian Aximand]

You could promise to convince you packmates to target someone else tonight. Wait, scratch that, last time I made this deal I got horribly backstabbed. I even think it was you.

If Shatari were playing I'd help you lynch him. You could settle for Soot though. He ended up agreeing.

But if you want to convince me, make a short case on him based on a single point. If I can't justify that behaviour from an innocent, my vote is yours.

I think, from the multitude of problems, the one that best fits the bill here is the manner in which he makes such an effort to spin everything his targets do as wolfy, no matter what it is. Once he chooses a target, his process becomes only about tearing them down and down and down. There's no investigative quality to that. Everything they do and everything they have done has to be wolfy, period, end of story. His attacks boil down to purely the attempt to paint an image of a wolf, rather than attempting to determine if the target is a wolf. You can see this in his conversation with Phone, you can see this in his attack on me, and you can see it most recently as he shifts to Soot. Whoever his target is, there's no attempt at investigation. It's purely a spin campaign.

I could understand arguing for an interpretation found to be more likely, or trying to make sense of a person's behavior should they be a wolf, but Pizza tries to force every post and every argument and every question and every joke to be something only a wolf could ever do. I simply can't justify that behavior from an innocent.

You know I'm a fan of that vote, but lets pretend that you can't get that wagon rolling. Can you dip down to 4th best?

I'll take it under consideration if that's the only way to stop the day from resulting in a no lynch.

Good to know.

 

[Phonemelter]

Adaham, Kronic, Hawk, in that order. Also, I did unvote earlier from Frisian, but I guess I might as well place my vote where it's going to be at the end of the day. I would love to go for Adaham, but seeing the reactions I'll have to go for a more realistic lynch.

Vote: Kronic

Well sorry I missed the vote that was not on its own line or LIMEGREEN'D. 

Voting for Kronic is rather safe, especially when it doesn't seem like there are enough people to vote for a lurker right now, don't you think? Are you sure you aren't just placing your vote somewhere else because you do not want to be the player that "tipped the tides?"

 

[Xardob]

Lynching Eli today makes perfect sense, meta wise.

 

[Magorian Aximand]

Adaham, Kronic, Hawk, in that order. Also, I did unvote earlier from Frisian, but I guess I might as well place my vote where it's going to be at the end of the day. I would love to go for Adaham, but seeing the reactions I'll have to go for a more realistic lynch.

Vote: Kronic

Well sorry I missed the vote that was not on its own line or LIMEGREEN'D. 

Voting for Kronic is rather safe, especially when it doesn't seem like there are enough people to vote for a lurker right now, don't you think? Are you sure you aren't just placing your vote somewhere else because you do not want to be the player that "tipped the tides?"

Says the guy who won't switch back to his top target and create a clear #1.

 

[Phonemelter]

All part of my WHOOPIN MASTERPLAN STRATEGY.

 

[Magorian Aximand]

It took me a second to realize that was from a different game.

Any more info you can give on that plan?

 

[Xardob]

Melter, who do you want me to vote for? With my vote and yours, you could basically decide this lynch.

 

[Phonemelter]

Any more info you can give on that plan?

Yup - it will end with someone's death.

Melter, who do you want me to vote for? With my vote and yours, you could basically decide this lynch.

How about you? 

 

[Pharaoh Llandy]

Melter, who do you want me to vote for? With my vote and yours, you could basically decide this lynch.

He wants you to give your vote to me. He knows how much I covet them. Like snowglobes. So pretty and captivating when you shake them.

 

[Phonemelter]

But you aren't going to use it - you're just going to put in it your snow globe vote collection with all the other old, dusty votes. 

 

[Magorian Aximand]

Melter, who do you want me to vote for? With my vote and yours, you could basically decide this lynch.

His #1 suspect is Pizza. I'll sub in that request for him.

I gave you that reason. Give me that vote.

 

[Phonemelter]

But is he really my #1 choice at the momemt? Maybe I am just toying with you all to see what happens? 

 

[Xardob]

Unvote, Vote Llandy

There, Llandy, it's yours.

Also, I followed Melter's link and came across a pretty convincing argument indicating that both Mag and Pizza are innocents. I'm surprised that didn't occur to me before.

 

[Pharaoh Llandy]

But you aren't going to use it - you're just going to put in it your snow globe vote collection with all the other old, dusty votes. 

Of course I'd use it. Watch:

Adaham
Llandy
Pizza
Magorian
Vieira
Xardob

That's a lynch. And it's a sensible lynch, because we don't know for sure that Adaham will be online and able to change his vote over the weekend, and I've already said I won't be able to recast my vote once we reach t-minus 18 hours due to the time at which the deadline falls. That's two potentially dead votes if it gets to late on Sunday.

Unvote, Vote Llandy

There, Llandy, it's yours.

Woo!

Xardob vote: SootShade