@Xardob
Xardob 说:
To partially answer your question, I don't share your read of Soot playing both sides when it comes to the melted pizza argument. I detect no hint of him waiting to just jump on the most convenient wagon.
Then I will convince you otherwise. All I ask in the meantime is that you keep an open mind and do not preclude Soot from your lynch list just yet.
At the very least, the impression he is giving is that he genuinely thinks both are innocent, and any sudden change in this interpretation is grounds for hanging.
Ugh, this sentence hurts my brain. Do you mean that any change in YOUR interpretation of Soot's play should be grounds for hanging YOU, or that any interpretation by Soot of the Pizza/Melter innocent interaction is grounds for hanging HIM? I'm guessing the latter but want it clarified.
You talked about Soot's interactions with Mag. What do you think of a possible Soot-Mag pack?
Lemme re-read their interactions today with this in mind and get back to you tonight; I only have 40 mins left to get ready for work and I still have a couple of responses to make to other people.
@Pizzaguy
Askthepizzaguy 说:
That would all depend on who is lynched today and how they flip. Someone else flips wolf unexpectedly would make my first priority to examine the thread for their wolf buddies.
AORN there's nothing persuading me off of Magorian or Hawk for today as my top 2.
Eli I would push to mid-game or later, regardless of the flips. I have no intention to lynch Eli presently for the reasons I've stated a couple times.
Unfortunately, this wasn't the answer I was hoping for, because it means I really was over-thinking something I thought I saw in your masterplan^tm, that is, a plan behind a plan. If you're interested enough in what I thought I saw, and you remember later on, ask me after the game end. Now I will have to go through your masterplan^tm wall and give you my verdict, I would normally do that at lunchtime at work but I gotta go out at lunch so it might be tomorrow night before I get this done.
@SootShade
[quote author=SootShade]
LoS on Adaham
[/quote]
I'm struggling to believe that you actually believe this yourself. The main difference between Adaham's play in this game and his play in the last game is his more casual banter, especially @ Pizzaguy, and the fact that he has a couple of times interjected in Pizzawars in an attempt to stop them from completely taking over the thread, something which you yourself thought was an innocent action.
You claim he's done very little actual hunting. He did very little actual hunting on Day 1 in the last game, too, mostly riding off the information other people generated without making a concerted effort to get deeply involved. So that you are calling scum now what you called innocent in the last game, and basing the majority of your opinion on it, just comes across as extremely selective interpretation.
