[Werewolf] SMAC: Unity [Game ends!]

正在查看此主题的用户

Pharaoh X Llandy 说:
Askthepizzaguy 说:
I can't offer you advice on how to help me read you villager, it defeats the purpose.

Askthepizzaguy 说:
Magorian suddenly reading villager to me again would be a vote on Hawk.

I find it odd how you randomly say to me that you can't offer me advice on how to help you read me as a villager (which I never even asked or implied, so I don't know why you even mentioned it) and the next day prompt Magorian on what will make him appear more villagery to you.

I cannot do anything to make you understand where I was coming from, because you are reading into a process of my brain at a magnification of one million, that has basically nothing to do with anything at all.

It was not the point of my post, point blank- it was a statement made as part of a free-flowing process, an offhand comment. You interpreted it as meaningful.

It is my way of saying "I am looking for villager tells- I can't explain to anyone what they are, or it defeats the purpose."

You read it as me commanding you to be a villager or something, your brain wave functioning at a very different wavelength than mine.

There's just no possible way I can make you understand how I think. You're looking at nothing here, and examining it with a microscope. That's just how my brain is. It's just who I am. That's all.
 
Magorian Aximand 说:
Llandy: My main problem with Llandy so far came in her recent conversation with Soot. How can he be playing both sides in an argument where he thinks both players are innocent and both are mistaken in their arguments? That's not a variation on a theme because it doesn't end with anybody dying or any arguments getting advanced. Then she even tries to "gotcha" him. I'm just not buying it. I know Hawk started it, but come on Llandy.

I had a similar problem getting my point across like this in the last game too. Basically, some things Soot is doing (pointless pack-hunting being the strongest of them now) strongly remind me of his play in the last game. I've played a whole lot of games with Soot recently, and one thing I've noticed is that as an innocent, even when he's wading through quote wars and inventing fanciful pack theories, he does it with an open mind. Perhaps he has an open mind on the Pizza/Melter thing, I can't tell. But on his random pack creation? Lumping one player in with two people he thinks are scummy just because that person was in his mind purely for the first post, and then afterwards attempting to justify that action through what appears to be solely OMGUS? That is not what I expect from an innocent Soot. But if your expectations are fine, and you're not seeing what I'm seeing, then fine. We'll agree to disagree on this.

Also, "I know Hawk started it, but come on Llandy?" I'm sorry, but you're just being childish now, and I expected better from you. I know you and Hawk have History, but putting down his contributions "just because it is Hawk" is below the belt. If I agree with a player about something I'm going to voice that agreement regardless of who that player is. I really do hope this doesn't mean you take my opinion any less seriously, just because I agree with Hawk on something he said.
 
Whoopin 说:
I understand how you think - but Im just a spectator that shouldnt even post this.

Worf.png


Size 50 text: "The Cha'Dich will be silent!"

:razz:

Whoopin' obviously my Cha'Dich. But right now he truly is AskinforaWhoopin.  :mrgreen:
 
OK kids, LoS time:

Xardob and Soot are wolves.

Mag, too, if there's a third one.

Llandy, Pizza, Phoney, Vieira are good guys.

Hawk is doing ok. Kronic is just probably a scapegoat.

Frisian is a dirty lurker with a good excuse for it this day.

Feel free to mail me the MVP trophy.

tumblr_ldbbp09XYx1qdezf9o1_400.gif


Thought it was best to get this out of my system before I miss something important tomorrow.
 
Askthepizzaguy 说:
You're looking at nothing here, and examining it with a microscope.

And that is how my brain functions. I pick at everything. Every word and every nuance and I dissect it and look for anything at all which strikes me as odd. I can tell you now, this is nothing. If you think I'm dissecting you closely, then you should go take a look at my thousand-page essays in the Black Death thread on each and every player. One Day 1.

I'm sure Whoopin will be able to provide you with links, my essays were his favourite part of the whole game  :mrgreen:

Semi-joking aside, please don't take this personally. Other than Eli, I have played at least one or more games with all these guys. As a result, I have picked up some meta, and learnt what counts as "offhand comments" for most of them, learnt what to pick up on and what to let slide, such as Melter's sarcasm and the Adaham/Xardob banter. But I don't have anything like that for you yet. So yes, I'm going to stick you under a giant microscope and pick at things that seem odd to me, because that is how I learn. Sorry if you don't like it, but after a game or two with you I won't have to be as picky. If you can survive my learning process, that is.
 
Most Valuable Player. Interestingly enough I recently came across another instance when a couple people I was conversing with had no idea what that particular acronym meant, and they happened to be European. Maybe it's more of a North American thing?
 
Time to pick on Pizzadude some more.

Askthepizzaguy 说:
I never wait for the wolves to accidentally out themselves. You stir the pot to generate such developments and interactions.

I assume the only way the wolves will seem so wolfy I can convince others they are, is to press them and corner them and ask them questions until their answers hang them.

Question to everyone - How much of this has he done since he gave up on me?


Adaham 说:
Feel free to mail me the MVP trophy.

If we learned anything from last game, it's that this LoS is going to be completely wrong.  :iamamoron:
 
Most valuable player.

Another acronym for Adaham, basically...

Vermillion_Hawk 说:
Most Valuable Player. Interestingly enough I recently came across another instance when a couple people I was conversing with had no idea what that particular acronym meant, and they happened to be European. Maybe it's more of a North American thing?
I'm European. And I even know what GOAT means...  :cool:

(it's another acronym...)

Phonemelter 说:
If we learned anything from last game, it's that this LoS is going to be completely wrong.  :iamamoron:
So that means based on previous experience, you assume I'm the seer again? Neat.
 
While I do feel that Hawk was just making **** up, Llandy's at least approaching the situation from an understandable angle, even if it's a very heavily meta reliant one. The comparisons regarding my play she's making are bad, but I don't think she would be trying to make misleading comparisons to try to put suspicion on me deliberately as a wolf. Her paranoia about me and the fairly defensive response to my initial questioning on her are almost villager tells for me on her at this point, granted that that is also very meta.

Nothing really standing out in Magorian's LoS to me as of yet. I agree with a good part, disagree on some things, but nothing very conclusive to change my read on him.

Still liking my initial suspects, which isn't something I expected to last even this long, but then two of them have barely posted for a while and Adaham's not been very impressive either.
 
Taunting's not gonna do the job. Especially you know what they say about people in glasshouses. And stones. And throwing them. Bad idea.
 
All you need to do to get a better read on Adaham is to keep pissing him off and see what happens - that has helped the past few games. If he explodes, he is innocent. If he remains calm enough, he is a wolf.  :razz:


Adaham's response is mild. Probably a wolf.
 
Pharaoh X Llandy 说:
Also, "I know Hawk started it, but come on Llandy?" I'm sorry, but you're just being childish now, and I expected better from you. I know you and Hawk have History, but putting down his contributions "just because it is Hawk" is below the belt. If I agree with a player about something I'm going to voice that agreement regardless of who that player is. I really do hope this doesn't mean you take my opinion any less seriously, just because I agree with Hawk on something he said.

I want to be clear here, I'm not critical of the idea because it was Hawk's and I'm not critical of you because you agreed with Hawk. You did notice that I said I agreed with Hawk about Pizza, right? I'm critical of the idea as you put it, for your reasons, because I don't agree with you. I added that comment so it would be clear that I knew the context and payed attention to the conversation, rather than laying blame on only you for an idea that was not uniquely yours.
 
Phonemelter 说:
All you need to do to get a better read on Adaham is to keep pissing him off and see what happens - that has helped the past few games. If he explodes, he is innocent. If he remains calm enough, he is a wolf.  :razz:


Adaham's response is mild. Probably a wolf.
Good hunting there. But the meta betrays you. Since my return, I've always been innocent, but I haven't always gotten pissed off (especially not early on day 1).

Also, nobody has really pissed me off yet, so it's hard for me to explode. But I can try, if it soothes (pun intended) your mind...

F**K, S**T, C**T, M**********N P***E OF P**E A** D**K S****R

And for a proper AVGN reference:

D******A

Happy now?
 
Pharaoh X Llandy 说:
Askthepizzaguy 说:
You're looking at nothing here, and examining it with a microscope.

And that is how my brain functions. I pick at everything. Every word and every nuance and I dissect it and look for anything at all which strikes me as odd. I can tell you now, this is nothing. If you think I'm dissecting you closely, then you should go take a look at my thousand-page essays in the Black Death thread on each and every player. One Day 1.

Oh hell no. This is a refreshing change from 2+2 where people reading my posts is like asking them to invent a fusion reactor using only a toothbrush and a roll of duct tape.

I encourage you to dissect me into a million pieces, hopefully my reaction to your interest in that one piece of that one post will have revealed something about me to you.

It's like... I said I'll met you at your place for dinner, and you thought I meant I'm going to eat your house, for dinner, and thought I was weird as hell for saying so.

Semi-joking aside, please don't take this personally.

You could read me wolf, incorrectly, and tunnel me all game long, and I wouldn't take it personally.

All you gotta do is not call me a moron and I'll be good with you regardless. It's just a game, suspicion is just business.

Like, I'm well past the point of frustration with Phone, in-game. Out of game I'm sure he's amazing. No issues with him personally.

Just.... can't get over the.... nevermind. I read him villager, I'm just going to shut up now. My irritation over the way the game has unfolded and what just took place, I gotta swallow. It's not going to solve the game so I gotta deal.

Unless something changes, though, I'm not even responding to his posts. If someone else wants to know the answers to questions Phone asked, ask away, I guess.

Other than Eli, I have played at least one or more games with all these guys. As a result, I have picked up some meta, and learnt what counts as "offhand comments" for most of them, learnt what to pick up on and what to let slide, such as Melter's sarcasm and the Adaham/Xardob banter. But I don't have anything like that for you yet. So yes, I'm going to stick you under a giant microscope and pick at things that seem odd to me, because that is how I learn. Sorry if you don't like it, but after a game or two with you I won't have to be as picky. If you can survive my learning process, that is.

No, I think it's great, and villagery. I'm irritated about other stuff and still trying to suck it up and deal with it.
 
Adaham 说:
OK kids, LoS time:

Xardob and Soot are wolves.

Probably not going to vote there.

Mag, too, if there's a third one.

I'm there. Hi-five.

Llandy, Pizza, Phoney, Vieira are good guys.

Agreed.

Hawk is doing ok.

Meh.

Kronic is just probably a scapegoat.

Fingers crossed on that one.

Frisian is a dirty lurker with a good excuse for it this day.

I might give Frisian a free pass to lurk assuming he votes every day. I don't think the wolf is doing it.
 
后退
顶部 底部