[Werewolf] SMAC: Unity [Game ends!]

[Askthepizzaguy]

I think it's likely that Xardob is a wolf, and this makes me sad.

Why? Wouldn't you be happy about an exciting battle to get me lynched? Or is it that you know you'd have no hope of winning said battle? 

I had bolded your name and tried to post a lynch vote on you, but it said I had posted less than 20 seconds ago.

Impatiently waiting for the time to elapse, I had a better idea.

Do you think Magorian Aximand is a wolf?

 

[Troll]

Up to this current point in the thread? I'm struggling to really to get a read that puts him that much to any side, but I'm leaning furry.

Mmm.

Everyone who responded that I can recall read Eli wolf. Eli did not gain votes. Eli has done nothing villagery in the interim. I read him villager and he thinks I'm a wolf.

I don't see much in the way of wolf-hunting.

I am considering dropping my vote there. Still reading.

I have been observing the same thing for a while now. I'm just wondering if like me others are not feeling any hurry with their votes right now, or if it's another sign of him being scum.

I think it's likely that Xardob is a wolf, and this makes me sad.

Interesting. My town read on him has been getting stronger the more he's posted. Seems like he's got good and genuine reasoning in there. That's hardly conclusive when it comes to Xardob, but I don't see why you'd be getting the opposite read.

 

[Xardob]

Pizza, I think there's some miscommunication going on between us. I blame my poorly worded question.

I think we have three villains, but I'm comfortable working with four or five suspects, even though I know a couple of them must be innocents. What would be your upper number? At what point do you think that you have too many and need to go back on some of them? One suspect more than the number of wolves? Two?

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Pizza, I think there's some miscommunication going on between us. I blame my poorly worded question.

I think we have three villains, but I'm comfortable working with four or five suspects, even though I know a couple of them must be innocents. What would be your upper number? At what point do you think that you have too many and need to go back on some of them? One suspect more than the number of wolves? Two?

I begin with a neutral non-read on people, and mark them down as more villagery than rand if I see reasons to do so, and less villagery than rand if I see such.

Sometimes that's going to result in more wolf leans than are wolves. If I explain my suspicions on each, it doesn't matter that I have more suspects than wolves- I just need to resolve them as being less villagery rather than more villagery at that point.

I am not quite letting go of Phone, but... observe that after I went full pizza on him for most of today, he continued responding and gave reads on everyone in the game.

That's worth reconsidering his alignment. I hate to let him go completely, not because I'm afraid to admit my usually-poor day one reads are poor once again, I have no issues being wrong in a guessing game, but because if I was correct and let him go simply because he has WIM, it will piss me off to no end.

I proooooobably need to let that go, though. That's just fear and vanity.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Magorian is not demonstrating any sort of villagery process.

Magorian Aximand, why do you lean wolf on Xar-dog, and why do you lean villager on everyone I suspected at the start of the day?

You've gone from deep blue to basically neutral, in the span of a couple of pages, and I'm nearly ready to wolf read you.

Explain your reads with reasoning, if you would please.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

I think it's likely that Xardob is a wolf, and this makes me sad.

Good vibes from Soot, Vieira, and Phoney. They're not always right, but I do at least feel like they're genuine.

Wolf under zero pressure makes these sorts of explanation-free reads.

Explanations or a vote to follow, Mags.

 

[Magorian Aximand]

I think it's likely that Xardob is a wolf, and this makes me sad.

Why? Wouldn't you be happy about an exciting battle to get me lynched? Or is it that you know you'd have no hope of winning said battle? 

I thought this would finally be the game where you'd get to live and play for a while. It makes me sad that it's looking like I'm going to have to kill you. And don't kid yourself my man, we both know what happens when I put the hammer down.

Interesting. My town read on him has been getting stronger the more he's posted. Seems like he's got good and genuine reasoning in there. That's hardly conclusive when it comes to Xardob, but I don't see why you'd be getting the opposite read.

It definitely deserves explanation. I'm gonna have to wall of text some **** at some point, but I don't have the time now.

I think it's likely that Xardob is a wolf, and this makes me sad.

Good vibes from Soot, Vieira, and Phoney. They're not always right, but I do at least feel like they're genuine.

Wolf under zero pressure makes these sorts of explanation-free reads.

Explanations or a vote to follow, Mags.

Welcome to Neoxardobism, my cheesy friend.

 

[Adaham]

I think it's likely that Xardob is a wolf, and this makes me sad.

I'm listening. Please explain more, even if it's contrary to your new playing style.

---
1new post...Mag...gotta read

 

[Xardob]

Do you think Magorian Aximand is a wolf?

Good question. I don't know yet. I was sure he would understand my vote on him. The fact that he didn't, or he did and interpreted in a woof way, isn't reassuring.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Vote: Magorian Aximand

Welcome to Askthepizzaguyism, my wolfy friend. Nobody expects the pizzaguy reversal.

 

[Magorian Aximand]

Do you think Magorian Aximand is a wolf?

Good question. I don't know yet. I was sure he would understand my vote on him. The fact that he didn't, or he did and interpreted in a woof way, isn't reassuring.

Oh, it's not your vote that makes me think you're sprouting fangs. This ain't no OMGUS my furry friend.

Vote: Magorian Aximand

Welcome to Askthepizzaguyism, my wolfy friend. Nobody expects the pizzaguy reversal.

I kinda did.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

I kinda did.

I'm content to lynch you today, for the record. This ain't no pressure vote.

 

[Magorian Aximand]

That's fortunate, because pressure votes tend not to have much of an effect on me. I'm gonna hunt the way I hunt. I'd hate to leave you hanging if pressure was your goal.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Hawk reads not villagery, Eli as well, and Magorian now.

Phone I'm neutral-izing, Vieira soft villager lean. Soot, seems fine.

Xardog can be my new Dog. He can help me fetch a wolfy Mag-azine.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Magorian suddenly reading villager to me again would be a vote on Hawk.

Eli, I won't push today despite the consensus wolf read on him.

Neither Mags nor Hawk and I'll go Eli. So that's the length of the rope I'm offering.

 

[Xardob]

Mag, you're not going to try a meta read on me, are you?

Pizza, just point who and I'll help you hound them up.

 

[Phonemelter]

Magorian suddenly reading villager to me again would be a vote on Hawk.

Oh, directing your packie I see. 

 

[Troll]

I think he means that Hawk is next in line if he flips back to thinking Mag is innocent.

 

[Phonemelter]

Oh, well that wasn't very clear - interpreted it as "Magorian would be a villager read with a vote on Hawk."

 

[Magorian Aximand]

Mag, you're not going to try a meta read on me, are you?

... do you remember who you're talking to? Of course my case will involve at least some meta.