The East Asian servers are hosted by a chinese forum, this forum is telling it's chinese users to report any anti-PRC discussion on EA servers.

正在查看此主题的用户

状态
不接受进一步回复。
This is the reporting thread:
1aPn4ie.png


Here's the screenshot they use to report and ban players. This player's gonna be banned for simply mentioning "coronavirus", which is outrageous. You can sign up and see for yourself. They've started to make new posts hidden btw.
2MoHCOH.jpg
Then don't say corona virus maybe? If I play a game I look forward to relaxing not being reminded of this stupid virus every time
 
Then don't say corona virus maybe? If I play a game I look forward to relaxing not being reminded of this stupid virus every time
ah yes, ban someone for talking about a global pandemic that affects everyone, classic and not unexpected from people that live in the 800s
edit: just to clarify, they dont care about you relaxing, they ban people because it brings "shame" on them for ****ing up so badly.
 
When said political concerns threaten your ability to play the game (Being banned or censored) that is a large large problem. Like banning people cause you don't like their name since it is against your (Or your Country) own political thought. See #HongKong as a name.

What does HongKong have anything to do with M&B Bannerlord?
 
BTW I fully support there should be a China server and an East Asia server, given the world nowadays is basically under a cold war, so they don't really have to put the two group of people under the same server...
 
Big if true, can already see the Chinese shills defending this on here. Just separate them so China have their own server they can support their own censorship
 
What does HongKong have anything to do with M&B Bannerlord?
People using it as a name? Also see any name with the word Taiwan. Which you should be 100% free to do. A few people have been unfairly banned for it in the Oceana Servers.

Then don't say corona virus maybe? If I play a game I look forward to relaxing not being reminded of this stupid virus every time
Yes because that deserves a ban ? Totalitarian much?
It's litteraly a virus that's affecting us all its a natural thing to talk and make jokes about. If that offends you oh boy life is gonna be one offended run for you
 
ah yes, ban someone for talking about a global pandemic that affects everyone, classic and not unexpected from people that live in the 800s
edit: just to clarify, they dont care about you relaxing, they ban people because it brings "shame" on them for ****ing up so badly.

Also, they didn't send any warnings before perma banning players. Players didn't even know talking about CCP or the virus would get them banned. They simply make their own rules.
 
Also, they didn't send any warnings before perma banning players. Players didn't even know talking about CCP or the virus would get them banned. They simply make their own rules.
It's worse than making their own rules, it's the proverbial 'moving the goalpost', basically if someone you don't like managed to follow the rules, the rulemaker would just have to interpret or change said rules with a different meaning so the latter can 'legally' say 'they are not following the rules', and so they can be banned. It's no different from a kangaroo court, and they certainly don't give a damn whether or not people are aware of the knowledge.

Then don't say corona virus maybe? If I play a game I look forward to relaxing not being reminded of this stupid virus every time
This is one example of how people who side with the shills thought this is a good argument to shut down criticism. Literal ignorant sounding, one-liners.
 
最后编辑:
so have you guys really read the thread on the Chinese forums?
i tried but I got no permission to view it.
so anybody tell me what exactly the content is?
I can read Chinese if you don't understand Chinese that's ok juts tell me the original texts.
check my comment
 
For people saying that "This is a gaming forum. Why would you bring up politics". People get banned for made up reasons - surely saying "corona" or
"Taiwan" can't be considered as a bannable offence by any reasonable human being. So people outside of China that have nothing to do with China get censored and punished for no reason. It is the same as an admin of any server was banning people for no reason abusing his power. Just give China their own server that will solve this problem.
 
Big if true, can already see the Chinese shills defending this on here. Just separate them so China have their own server they can support their own censorship

I feel like I am in a special position to weigh in on this topic, as the only person on this forum who is familiar with the player in the screenshot as well as a member of a Chinese clan and a West Australian player. I want to add a little bit of information to this.

The plurality but not outright majority of players in East Asia (a Singapore server) are Chinese. This means that proper moderation does require Chinese language skills. The english version of the game currently doesnt even have Chinese characters, so English speaking admins would have trouble even differentiating troublesome Chinese players from each other.

Chinese clans largely congregate in an equivalent of discord referred to as YY, which is extremely insular to the extent that it requires the use of a Chinese phone number to join. Despite this I did manage to get in, but predictably do not have speaking rights as my IP is not Chinese. The only reason that I bring this up is that the Chinese players in my clan were surprised that foreigners were so heavily blocked from using their platform. That is, there is a little bit of ignorance on the Chinese player's parts on how heavily locked down their part of the internet even is.

Chinese understanding of English is extremely poor, with only 1-2 members out of 20 even able to understand basic phrases, relying mainly on google translate (which is hard to do from ingame text in an alphabet you're unfamiliar with). This is relevant because the specific phrase screenshotted was likely just once sentence in an array of sentences, given my knowledge of the player involved.

Elements of the Australian community, including the person in the screenshot have in the past been deliberately antagonistic. This particular user deliberately trolled both the Australian Mordhau community, the European warband community (I believe, I have only heard second hand from Giru that someone from our community was talking ****), as well as deliberately tried to prevent battle servers from functioning by tking from multiple accounts. This doesn't mean that he was doing this in this instance, it just should be noted that you should use a better example for this topic than this specific player.

This does not mean that this is good in the slightest, it is terrible. But just try to understand that the single in-game screenshot is not the best example of admin-abuse.

I am still strongly opposed to this simply because my political views aren't exactly equivalent to the CCP, and if some Chinese admin really wanted to dig in to it, they might have motivation to get me banned purely because I have criticised China heavily in the past. Also being a person who is primarily playing on East Asia makes me at particular risk, especially as I am involved in the East Asian clan scene at the moment. If for example we get a suspected aimbotter from a clan (hint, there is one) to go under proper scrutiny, then it is possible that their clan will retaliate and get a player like me banned in response.

There's other aspects to this that are also awkward, like the low-level animosity that exists between Korean/Chinese and Japanese players, and how that is another potential boiling point.
 
最后编辑:
For people saying that "This is a gaming forum. Why would you bring up politics". People get banned for made up reasons - surely saying "corona" or
"Taiwan" can't be considered as a bannable offence by any reasonable human being. So people outside of China that have nothing to do with China get censored and punished for no reason. It is the same as an admin of any server was banning people for no reason abusing his power. Just give China their own server that will solve this problem.
It's legalese talk MrCookie, they think saying those lines will scare people into obeying them and the rules (according to their interpretation). It's the same basic talking point people like them use in other game communities.
 
Didn't CCP recently ban online gaming outside of china? Might need to split East Asian server into 2 before the game gets banned..
 
If there is admin abuse is a shame. Racism is a shame too. Be nice people, we all are here because have something in common: M&B LOVE
 
just set another server for other asian players. It's silly to ban players for talking about politics. I think it's a admin-abuse.

another question is: since other countries' players will be banned for talking politics, if chinese players play troll about other countries' politics, will they be banned? I don't think so because the rule relies on chinese players' report in the chinese forum. where can other countries' players to appeal? it's a totally double standard.
 
最后编辑:
I feel like I am in a special position to weigh in on this topic, as the only person on this forum who is familiar with the player in the screenshot as well as a member of a Chinese clan and a West Australian player. I want to add a little bit of information to this.

The plurality but not outright majority of players in East Asia (a Singapore server) are Chinese. This means that proper moderation does require Chinese language skills. The english version of the game currently doesnt even have Chinese characters, so English speaking admins would have trouble even differentiating troublesome Chinese players from each other.

Chinese clans largely congregate in an equivalent of discord referred to as YY, which is extremely insular to the extent that it requires the use of a Chinese phone number to join. Despite this I did manage to get in, but predictably do not have speaking rights as my IP is not Chinese. The only reason that I bring this up is that the Chinese players in my clan were surprised that foreigners were so heavily blocked from using their platform. That is, there is a little bit of ignorance on the Chinese player's parts on how heavily locked down their part of the internet even is.

Chinese understanding of English is extremely poor, with only 1-2 members out of 20 even able to understand basic phrases, relying mainly on google translate (which is hard to do from ingame text in an alphabet you're unfamiliar with). This is relevant because the specific phrase screenshotted was likely just once sentence in an array of sentences, given my knowledge of the player involved.

Elements of the Australian community, including the person in the screenshot have in the past been deliberately antagonistic. This particular user deliberately trolled both the Australian Mordhau community, the European warband community (I believe, I have only heard second hand from Giru that someone from our community was talking ****), as well as deliberately tried to prevent battle servers from functioning by tking from multiple accounts. This doesn't mean that he was doing this in this instance, it just should be noted that you should use a better example for this topic than this specific player.

This does not mean that this is good in the slightest, it is terrible. But just try to understand that the single in-game screenshot is not the best example of admin-abuse.

I am still strongly opposed to this simply because my political views aren't exactly equivalent to the CCP, and if some Chinese admin really wanted to dig in to it, they might have motivation to get me banned purely because I have criticised China heavily in the past. Also being a person who is primarily playing on East Asia makes me at particular risk, especially as I am involved in the East Asian clan scene at the moment. If for example we get a suspected aimbotter from a clan (hint, there is one) to go under proper scrutiny, then it is possible that their clan will retaliate and get a player like me banned in response.

There's other aspects to this that are also awkward, like the low-level animosity that exists between Korean/Chinese and Japanese players, and how that is another potential boiling point.

Thank you for your insights! While I knew that Chinese were restricted to their own version of social media, I did not expect this development to have gone that far into gameservers already.
 
状态
不接受进一步回复。
后退
顶部 底部