Spy Among Us Broken?

[Vekar]

Is it me or is the quest "Spy Among Us" broken? I get all the clues and track down the various possibilities but it always says I accused the wrong one no matter what it is I do. There are only three possibilities I can find and nothing works, it just auto-fails me after the duel. Is there a secret, hidden 4th contender somewhere or is it just bugged to being broken?

 

[czarny]

1.5.10 works fine. I'm always able to pick correct contender and complete quest.

 

[Vekar]

Sure aint working for me. Beard, sword, etc... Only one guy matches that, auto-fail. Only other beard carries an axe so not him and the final has no beard at all.

 

[czarny]

When I did this quest 1st time I got information that spy has no scars and didn't know that facial painting is considered scar.

Next time you can try save scum and check every option and maybe see if it's yours or game error.

 

[Vekar]

Was already doing a save-scum and it was a guy I challenged "wrongly," but turns out he was the one but it docked me for it last time. I have no idea but not doing that quest again.

 

[Balbor]

Was already doing a save-scum and it was a guy I challenged "wrongly," but turns out he was the one but it docked me for it last time. I have no idea but not doing that quest again.

I always try to get the Vlandian female compounds called (xxxx the Black) as she has the skills needed to do the quest.