slings

Users who are viewing this thread

jellywerker

Recruit
Although falling out of use in the time m&b seems to be set, slings would make an interesting addition to the game, and would be a cool addition to roving bands of sea raiders and bandits. I guess the stats would be that of one of the lesser bows, as slings rivaled most bows until the 9th century.
 
add the sling it would be like a rock but more powerful, a simple animation could be done to put this in the game. And when up close it could have small mele damage, a little less than the club, so you could knock them out.
 
Prince: sorry, I should have searched.

Lord Jaden: slings would not work as a melee weapon, closest rang would probably be about 7-10 feet.
 
A sling would also not work like a rock in that it should not knock one unconscious; a sling was very deadly. Slings are also very accurate over a great distance. It's what kept them in use as long as they were. Even after they ceased to be used by most during war, they were still popular for bird and other small game hunting due to their accuracy.
 
I think that a sling bullet could kill or just make a guy think he has been killed, but in a game where you can use bows or crossbows why all the concern about slings? King David used a sword most of the time even after killing Goliath.
 
slings could be reloaded, aimed and shot far quicker than any other missile weapon, plus huge amounts of ammunition can be carried. historically, slings werent used as much after the dark ages because they lacked any kind of penetrating power against armour, however they were devestating against relatively unarmoured warriors such as the celts.
In M&B a sling should be brilliant to use versus river pirates and other low level brigands, but near useless versus knights. I also think it should use the throwing skill as with stones.
 
That's not true. A sling has quite an amount of penetrative power; it's one of the reasons it was used. The Romans hired Balaerics because of the ability of their sling bullets to punch holes in armor. It's a matter of the quality of the bullet one uses; experienced slingers used smoother bullets that would spiral and cut through armor rather easily.

As an aside, slings were rarely used against Celts, but Celts used them all the time, including against armored enemies, and with success. During the Galatian migration, slings were used against the royal army of Macedonia when it was destroyed, and numerous remains of helmets show clear, clean holes where bullets passed through. Slings were still in use during the dark ages in Britain and Ireland, but fell out of use in favor of bows as they were easier to train with and required less experience to be truly skilled at. Getting really good with a sling takes more experience than with a bow. Additionally, with the advent of longbows and crossbows, the range was outdone, and penetration could be achieved.

However, against plate armor, a sling would be relatively ineffective, but that's due to the curvuture of the armor, not a lack of penetrative power.
 
Sir Saladin: keep spamming, see what happens.

ssp7ik4rp.gif
 
Nairagorn said:
Sir Saladin: keep spamming, see what happens.

ssp7ik4rp.gif

Looks almost as if his account was cracked or stolen. Until recently his posts were pretty intelligent. In the last couple days, they degenerated SIGNIFICANTLY... IMHO

DE
 
jellywerker said:
Prince: sorry, I should have searched.

No need to apoligize, and the search feature sucks anyways.

Aslo, I accidently saved that pic Nair posted in my Civ2 graphics, oops. I hope his account is just hacked, as Sir Saladin has had lots of good posts.
 
Back
Top Bottom