So, I had these 2 quests active (gang in Charas and troops for Vesin) and I went to fight the gang in the city. At that time I had 8 of those village troops + 2 upgraded ones (I also had some of my own troops). During the fight I chose to fight for the other gang for the money, and so we fought my men. Out of those 10 village troops there was only 1 upgraded guy there, and I wounded him. After the fight the game had me choose to either keep or return those men, so I chose to return them and the quest log said I that most of the men died even though they were all alive. I only got +1 relation with the quest giver.
P.S. First time I loaded into the city fight it spawned me outside the city, forcing me to quit. The second time was fine.
P.S. First time I loaded into the city fight it spawned me outside the city, forcing me to quit. The second time was fine.

