[Resistance] Avalon: Minions of Mordred Win!

正在查看此主题的用户

Phonemelter 说:
No, I'm going to reject it because the only way there are going to be no spies on the team is if Twinkie, MaHuD, and Grimmend are the spies.
That's the way you can look at literally any team that doesn't have yourself in it. I know myself to not to be a spy, which automatically makes this team superior to any one not containing me in my opinion. Beyond that, I don't feel confident with guessing more than that there's probably at least one resistance member between you and Grimmend. That alone doesn't do much good, as I don't think either of you have given me enough on which to believe you to be honest. From there it just a guess at who's the most honest, and I'm leaning towards believing Aust and Xardob.


Austupaio 说:
MaHuD 说:
No 1 of them being good is enough. It is highly unlikely that they are both evil, but perhaps its a master strat of them.
You've said it twice but... I mean what are you basing this on? I think it's very possible.
If Grimm is a spy, I don't think there's much reason why he'd want to have a teammate on the mission, when it's just two of them. Not only he could sabotage the mission by himself if he wanted to, but the spies can't talk with each other. Thus there would just be confusion on which one of them should sabotage if either, and even if only one did it would put them both into question, making it a lot harder to get either of them on other mission teams. So yeah, I don't see both of them being spies, but as Xardob pointed out this doesn't mean that our proposed team would have a spy without the supposed information that MaHuD has of himself. Right now I'm actually more inclined to think he's a spy anyways. I don't see him arguing this way unless he's trying to keep a spy teammate on the mission team. I don't think he has anymore reason to believe myself or Xardob to be a spy than Face or Grimm, but he's leaning towards one of those without much explanation and also not concerning himself with trying to be on the team himself, as I'd think he would want to as resistance with the current information.



tl;dr; What Xardob said. :lol:
 
Xardob 说:
Do you have any reason believe they aren't? This argument could be used to reject any team you're not part of.

Yeah, I am Merlin and know everything.  :roll:

You are right, but the I am more willing to trust my gut than someone I am suspicious of. Either way, from the strategies I have been reading, it seems like keeping the first two people on for the second mission is generally the better option. Sure, you might not get as much information as quickly, but you could always do the same thing on the 3rd mission in the case the 2nd fails. The only difference is there is a chance of winning the game faster if the next mission passes.
 
Phonemelter 说:
That doesn't answer the question of what you think of his unofficial "Aust, Soot, Xardob" nomination.
Perhaps that is because I was never asked that? But I told you, I'm up for an Aust, you, and Grimmend. That's what I want to see, otherwise, the only other thing I'd like to see is a team with me in it.

~Twinkle, who doesn't understand how answering a totally different question should somehow redirect him to another
 
Still waiting for some more concrete thoughts but it seems that basically my team nomination would receive...

Grimmend - ?
Austupaio - Approval
MaHuD - ?
Twinkle - Rejection without himself on the team
Xardob - Approval
SootShade - Approval
Phonemelter - Rejection
 
Well, how about some actual posting here? I should have green-texted it already but activity is pretty minimal.
 
MaHuD 说:
Xardob 说:
I'm leaning towards me, Aust and Soot. I think it's a good idea to have different players in the team, so that we have information on everyone, come the end of the game.
It is good to get varied intel, but that mission team will certainly have at least 1 spy
 
If I have the correct read of the game right now, that post would make Face the fourth resistance member, along with the people in Aust's suggested team. That also means that the only person I would be willing to substitute in the team would be him.

I could also be entirely wrong about Aust or Xardob, but this is my best guess right now.
 
So we've got three who support my team, two who do not and two people who haven't really said.

Well, Grimmend and Twinkle, it comes down to you. I've given my reasoning, as has Xardob and Soot. Phonemelter gave his counter-part and MaHuD just kinda grumbled.

I want more discussion but this is just moving too slowly (three posts over the last 16 hours or so) and Llandy warned us about tarrying.

Officially nominating: Austupaio, Xardob and Sootshade. No more posting, please send your votes to Llandy.
 
Austupaio 说:
Still waiting for some more concrete thoughts but it seems that basically my team nomination would receive...

Grimmend - ?
Austupaio - Approval
MaHuD - ?
Twinkle - Rejection without himself on the team
Xardob - Approval
SootShade - Approval
Phonemelter - Rejection
Blatantly false. I specifically said I would accept a team with you, Gimmend, and Phone. Just because I'm not around doesn't mean I won't come back to defend myself adequately.  :wink:

~Twinkle, who voted Nay
 
Quest 2 - Team 1 Votes

Team Lineup:

Austupaio
SootShade
Xardob

Grimmend | | Reject
Austupaio | | Approve
MaHuD | | Reject
Twinkle | | Reject
Xardob | | Approve
SootShade | | Approve
Phonemelter | | Reject
             

Outcome
Quest team rejected!

The Quest team has been rejected. MaHuD will now suggest a new team and attempt to carry out the mission in a timely manner. Posting may begin again... for those who haven't already started :wink:

 
I told you it wouldn't fly. I find it extremely mordrish of you to even think it would pass. :/
 
Says the guy who offered no clear alternative team. You did say "either with Grimm and Phone or without," so I assume the one with Grimm on it would have passed with your vote, but if you didn't think Aust's proposed team that had neither Grimm nor myself on it would pass, why did you not suggest something different?
 
后退
顶部 底部