PC WORKSHOP

Here creates the best computers in Calradia! You can ask for help with any PC related issues, learn about at the new builds and read our articles.

Quick Overview

Category
Miscellaneous
Language
English (US)
Total members
32
Total events
0
Total discussions
20

Publication №9: How to choose RAM

Users who are viewing this thread

Publication №9: How to choose RAM

At first glance, choosing a memory may not seem as complicated as choosing all the other components, but in fact there are a lot of subtleties. For fans of Mount & Blade 2: Bannerlord - this will be especially important, I will explain why later.

Which brand should be trusted
The brand does not really matter, since everyone mainly uses their own stickers, and there are only three true manufacturers of memory chips - these are Samsung, Hynix and Micron. The most preferable of them is Samsung, and more specifically, the type of microcircuit is B-die. This type of chip is one of the most advanced. The memory on these microcircuits has tremendous frequency potential. But at the moment, Samsung stopped their production and replaced them with a new one called A-die, which in theory should be even better. But there is one thing but, before the purchase, you will not be able to know for sure which chips are installed in your modules. There are many sources on the Internet where the memory models and the chips installed in it are indicated, but there are often cases when the manufacturer runs out of chips and he begins to install others. In general, this is a lottery, so try to pay less attention to this. Those who still want to try their luck and find specific chips, I left overclocking tables that will help you understand which chips are better. But before you start the search, read the issue to the end, it is quite possible you will abandon this venture.

Bad 2933MHz or less
Normal 3000 -3333 MHz
Good 3466 MHz or more

f880344db98eed9eb82bce5725c4c4e4.png
5deff1524d61b5bb45b5d2219a80bc0a.png
a4ea3843ce8205ff93a5ff8575f5731a.png

Volume and number of bars

To answer this question, let's take the average motherboard, which has four slots for RAM. A powerful gaming PC should haveon board 16 GB of memory, but in general you can start with 8 GB, later buying more.
Buy memory modules of the same size and one model - this will minimize rare compatibility problems, and can also help a lot if you want to overclock your memory.
The volume of 16 GB can be typed in different combinations: 4 + 4 + 4 + 4, 8 + 8, 16, 8 + 4 + 4 and so on. In order to understand that it’s better to tell a little about the operating modes of the memory.

If we talk about motherboards of a non-server segment, memory can work in three modes:
two-channel 4 + 4 + 4 + 4, 8 + 8;
single channel 16;
flex 8 + 4 + 4.

Regarding the first two modes, I think everything is clear, but flex is a mixed mode of operation of the first two. That is, taking the configuration of 8 + 4 + 4 (flex), 8 GB of memory will work in dual-channel mode, and the other 8 in single-channel mode. Below you can see the video for performance comparison. Video flex mode is not included.
Intel

AMD

As you can see, the performance gain is very scattered and can reach impressive values depending on the specific project and considered values. But remember, the activation of the two-channel mode will not make a rocket out of your computer, since the increase in the frame rate is most noticeable when the processor is the narrow neck of the system. To activate two-channel mode, the memory must be installed in channel A1, B1 or A2, B2. In the new boards 1 and 3 slot or 2 and 4 as in the image below.
adcf67f6ad73bd7a7198f91c3a4cdf7d.jpg
With the operating modes of the memory, everything is clear, but an open question remains regarding the volume and number of modules 4 + 4 + 4 + 4 or 8 + 8. Damn it gets fun!) Tests come to the rescue. To make it clear where to look, I’ll explain what is what.

DDR4 2400 - type and frequency of memory
X2 - number of modules
8700K 4500 - processor model and its frequency
CL 16-16-16-39 - timings the

AMD

b114c70e9a84d9474e42b3f7400c803b.png
Intel
e9c6dba00a472b7c6874948f518e09f2.png
The best result achieve 4 memory modules, while for the system to work, you have to lower the frequency and apply higher timings.
To build a long-term gaming system, do not use 4 modules of 4 GB, you will fill in all the slots and thereby deprive yourself of the possible upgrade in the future.
We have come close to timings and memory frequency, but let's talk before that about memory rank.

Basically, there arein the home computer market peer and peer memory. Many people make the mistake of assuming that the ranking of the memory depends on the number of chips on the memory module. Suggest that if all microcircuits are on the one hand, then this is a peer-to-peer module, and if on two, it is a then a 2-rank module. In fact, this is not always the case. If there are 8 8-bit chips on the board, then we get a peer-to-peer module, if 16 8-bit ones, then a 2-rank one. In order to accurately determine the memory rank, it is better to go to the manufacturer's website. Well, now let's see the tests.

AMD Ryzen Zen 1-2
737553aee2196989617d9d13e849f7fd.png
Intel i7 2600k
bcdbe5f124f00f1cc3517bc31f44d32c.png
From the above it becomes obvious that 2-rank memory is more productive than peer-to-peer memory, unfortunately I could not find a more recent test with Intel coffe lake / coffe lake v2 processors. And we came to the conclusion that four peer-to-peer modules are almost equal in performance to two two-peer modules, and also have the same problems with overclocking. They are not easy to find on sale and often they are significantly more expensive than peer-to-peer ones, which makes them not the most attractive to buy.
I highly recommend not using four two-rank modules. This creates a large load on the memory controller, which entails problems with stability, as well as huge difficulties with overclocking.
Frequency and timings

When choosing a memory, the next thing to pay attention to is frequency and timings. These two characteristics are very interconnected and the best performance when overclocking memory is achieved due to their correct combination. Now we will see tests of the influence of timings and frequencies.

Intel i7-8700k timings
6f3148941da206aca47147abc1bf2103.png
a6c38ee7d046ca28e4e2010950b93eb0.png
cf07fdc3bf4fec0c7771f7ca8a86d889.png
c7859089e1fd14cb16db43fb7e647466.png
8c03bbbda56ae4b1a25b18ad63af1623.png

AMD ryzen 7 2700x timings
ea41dccd86610c5718cc99ecde11bb3e.png
8e6f2df8c4cd0acefc6ee38fd79e0739.png
778f1d76721d70d53a2758a9ecca3985.png
8b5f9a9d7364448f6b96463699487e98.png
f42e96f7472d5b92f9892f9d78cfc6b9.png

Intel frequency
1fe50b5bfe15e9bbe6da58bd3b2bad14.png
3954f36771a1a31371e0585f12b10a78.png
78c9d3b4e4be656e14cbebca5e705d3b.png
cbf41fbbe0bdd7dec393d6d5bea61477.png

AMD Ryzen 7 2700x frequency
b01024c99ab9f55adfa3bf28ef9c7909.png
6b41bf30a80e8a4ed6e8c8e0d23824e0.png
e9db7e1243846011eb701547ea8aff01.png
bc7818f1e8744c75acb499e4c4825bf9.png
1cd55b0604b7ef27bbdd844a2a31201e.png

Looking at the tests, we can say with certainty that timings do not affect performance as much as frequency, but you definitely should not neglect them much, otherwise the memory will have big delays and this will lead to friezes and slowdowns in games. Some will notice that there is no memory with a frequency higher than 3400 in our tests, and all because modules with a higher frequency will cost much more, and performance in games will not only not increase, but may become lower. The recommended frequency threshold for Intel is 3200, and for AMD - 3400.
Owners of Intel motherboards with H310, B360 / 365, H370 chipsets should remember that their motherboards do not support a memory frequency above 2666 mhz.
Briefly about the main

1) Do not look at the manufacturer, for you the main thing is the frequency of the memory and its timings. You can overclock to 3000-3400 many modules, this is proved by the tables at the beginning of the release, so whoever takes the time to overclock will be able to save by buying modules with a low frequency, but good microcircuits. If you are not one of those who use overclocking, pay attention to the modules with XMP, where the manufacturer has saved a predefined settings profile, which guarantees memory operation at the indicated frequencies. In order for the memory to work at the indicated frequencies, this profile must be activated in the BIOS.

2) Choose a peer memory with a module capacity of 8 GB, because if you buy two 8-gig dual-rank modules, later you maybe want to buy two more 8 gb modules, your computer may not work with four dual rank modules, and even if it works, there may be stability problems work. Buying two slats of dual rank memory will be good ideas only if your PC is not long-term and you are sure that you will not buy more memory. And change the platform within a couple of years.

3) Do not buy too expensive memory, everything has its reasonable limit, it is best to invest free funds in a video card or processor.

4) As for radiators in memory, this is more of an excess than a necessity. See that they are not too high, otherwise you may have problems installing large-sized cooling systems for the CPU.

5) The performance gain from high-frequency memory, dual-rank or installation of 4 strips is best seen when the processor is the narrow neck of the system. In the event that everything rests on the video card, the gain may not be noticeable at all. Since there will be battles in Bannerlord involving up to 1000 units, your processor will most likely be very busy and correctly selected memory installed in dual-channel mode will help it a lot at times of 100% load.[/spoiler]

Friends, we really need help with the correct translation! If it's not difficult for you, please suggest corrections.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom