P.O.G.A.A.H propositions and suggestions list to improve infantry ✂

[Fietta]

No one is defending Taleworlds' capabilities, just stating facts on how it is; there is a dedicated team for testing and that's that, regardless of competency.

 

[HugoTheFrenchMan]

I would assume the lack of hair is made up by a larger brain

 

[mrArgentum]

Hello another list of good changes that developers don't care about. Mb I'll surprise you but this is not the first and even not the second list of community's suggestions. And in some of these lists were exactly the same suggestions.

 

[MArdA TaleWorlds]

Thanks for taking the time and writing your thoughts about this. Forwarded to the team!

 

[ParzivaI]

I didn't read but i'll give a +1 just because of Ryuuko

 

[Silvernj]

bump so this thread doesn't fall into oblivion
@AVRC @NIN3

 

[Nalgasucia507]

Interesting choice of layout and asthetics to present your ideas, but those seem fairly decent. A playtest would certainly be needed, but capable volunteers are not hard to find.
My only note is to keep animations crisp and functional, so we don't get the twisty cluster**** of feint spam that was the pinnacle of warband melee (apart from near-infinite chamber chains of course)

+1 to your second sentence. But little by little it is becoming that.

 

[jon01]

IceNoVa said:
Interesting choice of layout and asthetics to present your ideas, but those seem fairly decent. A playtest would certainly be needed, but capable volunteers are not hard to find.
My only note is to keep animations crisp and functional, so we don't get the twisty cluster**** of feint spam that was the pinnacle of warband melee (apart from near-infinite chamber chains of course)

+1 to your second sentence. But little by little it is becoming that.

April 2020 in Bannerlord:

 

[Younes]

April 2020 in Bannerlord:

that hit at 11:50 is what we need for all hits

 

[Hans 77]

April 2020 in Bannerlord:

that hit at 11:50 is what we need for all hits

11:50 is a feint where the initial swing animation simply continued until conclusion and the sword swung through his character -even though the first attack had been "cancelled". I see this happen all the time and it drives me crazy.

Logically, you would think that if a swing completed its full arc then it was a genuine attack, but nope, that's just the feint animation being super sloppy.

I would love for the devs to take a look at that 11:50 clip and understand why people are so frustrated with Bannerlord's combat mechanics.

People can say what they want about some of Warband's jankier attack angles, but it never had the sheer sloppiness of Bannerlord's animations.

 

[OurGloriousLeader]

People can say what they want about some of Warband's jankier attack angles, but it never had the sheer sloppiness of Bannerlord's animations.

+

Would never claim Warband had perfect animations and combat, but if the goal was to get rid of that confusing and awkward looking melee that many disliked about Warband, Bannerlord has it more-so with the feints and spinning combined with fast movement.

 

[Terco_Viejo]

Thanks for taking the time and writing your thoughts about this. Forwarded to the team!

Left me no choice but to update this old meme . You know we love you, but that sentence comes with a TM by default. -Forwarded to the team!™... sure ?

 

[MArdA TaleWorlds]

I must confess I missed the memes

 

[Kunshiro]

And we are missing a good game

 

[Forsee]

11:50 is a feint where the initial swing animation simply continued until conclusion and the sword swung through his character -even though the first attack had been "cancelled". I see this happen all the time and it drives me crazy.

Logically, you would think that if a swing completed its full arc then it was a genuine attack, but nope, that's just the feint animation being super sloppy.

I would love for the devs to take a look at that 11:50 clip and understand why people are so frustrated with Bannerlord's combat mechanics.

People can say what they want about some of Warband's jankier attack angles, but it never had the sheer sloppiness of Bannerlord's animations.

It seems like a default ping issue. BL animations are clear once you get used to them and it never happens in sp. Ping makes combat jumpy and unclear, in mp sometimes you can figure out what attack you just died to only after it hits you. If players with lower ping experience this as well, it's either netcode or serverhost problem

 

[AVRC]

bump so this thread doesn't fall into oblivion
@AVRC @NIN3

We read it when it was posted.
No response does not mean it is being ignored.

 

[Silvernj]

No response does not mean it is being ignored.

We can only be sure we are not being ignored if we see changes in-game or you share your thoughts on the topic

 

[sleepy dragon]

We read it when it was posted.
No response does not mean it is being ignored.

Might want to communicate it's not being ignored earlier then, like a decent company would.

 

[KSHMR]

We read it when it was posted.
No response does not mean it is being ignored.

Doesn't change the fact that most feedback is discarded or disregarded anyways.

 

[Nalgasucia507]

Doesn't change the fact that most feedback is discarded or disregarded anyways.

A lot of feedback is trying to turn BL into the twerkfest that is Warband. They just don't fundamentally agree with it.