Hey, hear me out.
Light cavalry is borderline useless in Captain. On paper they are meant to attack out-of-position archers, but in reality they can't do that. A completely isolated Light Archer is able to engage Light Cavalry in hand to hand combat and succeed reliably. Heavy Archers will
murder light cavalry dumb enough to engage them. A lot of this is just AI problems, but there's no real fix for that.
They are slightly effective when used as Mounted Infantry in very select situations.
- Ride to a strategic location, dismount, and fight.
- Ride up to reinforce archers being pushed (especially by enemy Cav), dismount and fight.
- Remount to capture flags, then come back to dismount and assist infantry
This is very fun, but it doesn't come up very often, and could do with being expanded. Choosing Lt Cav in order to do this is very suboptimal for your team's class makeup. We should encourage this a bit more.
Maybe a Perk in the second slot that functions like the "Medium Infantry" for Guards/Voulgiers, maybe called
"Mounted Infantry":
- +2 Troops.
- Replaces the long slow cavalry sword with a faster Axe or sword meant for foot combat.
- Increases foot speed by 10% or so (Cavalry Troops are insanely slow on foot, this just makes them same speed as normal Inf).
- Nukes their Riding skill down to 0 (comparable with normal Infantry). Not meant to be used for horseback fighting at all, just strategic movement.
This way if you take the Armor perk in the first slot, then the "
Mounted Infantry" slot in the second perk, you have a strategic fighting force that can't go toe-to-toe with Light Infantry or Heavy Infantry on their own, but could be used to deliver quick reinforcements to allies, capture Points, drive off Skirmishers/Archers, or put up a strategic Shieldwall somewhere. The drawback is you can't stand up to enemy cavalry on horseback at all, as your weapons are optimized for foot combat and they can outmaneuver you easily.
This would make them function kind of like historical Anglo-Saxon/Britton mounted infantry, who would ride to battle and dismount to fight.