Money is pain on 1.011

正在查看此主题的用户

Zhaker

Sergeant
So I tried a few things in version 1.011

1. Merchant Run Made about 10k Denar a week if lucky with the abundance of spice. Otherwise its about 5-8k depending on what I can scrounge up.
2. Got Narra ( Very Rich with its influence on 10 ) but I make about 1.5k Denars per week :\.
3. I have 2 Villages ( both Rich and its influence on 100 ) and I make about 1k Denars per week give or take. They are not close either mind you so doh.
4. I own also a Keep but that was because I needed to store some troops at the start.
5. Fighting lords and looting all their loot with only 70-100 men yields roughly 500-1000 denars depending on how much loot I get as well as the quality ( it seems the bigger the lords the better ).
6. Arena wise is 2k - 4k denars but they come in few and between and sometimes they are too far from where I am :sad:.
7. Siege wise, if I dont initiate it I get squat if I help, and if I do it alone I dont get much either, even cities where I thought I'd get like 10k per siege or something with all them loots :sad:.

The timeline was something like this:

Do Arenas -> Got enough renown to Join Swadia -> War with Kerghit and hit them hard -> Capture a few towns and also a close by Keep -> Captured all Khergit Cities and asked for Narra ( Which I got ) -> Attacking Rhodoks (STUCK)

My situation:

When I had the keep I had to do an upkeep of about 3k Denar for about 200 troops ( Mostly Kerghits Veteran Soldiers and also Swadian Knights ). And that was cool because I was actually making money. By killin

I got Narra, and I found myself with an upkeep of 10k Denar with about 300 troops extra ( Mostly again Kerhigts Soldiers and Knights ). And right now I'm forced to do more merchant runs than ever before. I actually now finding the game more irritating because I'm scrounging up money to make ends meet. And the last time I had 200 troops at Narra I had barrages from the damn Nords with 800 troops and the Rhodoks constantly at my doorstep. When I had about 300 they stopped coming over lolz.

I wished I never gotten Narra as a city as its actually now not worthwhile in the first place to get. Whats the deal with having a city with very rich getting only as much as a Village, I always thought that it'd be worth 3 Villages or more or something :\. Its turning me off and I wanted to control many cities but now I'm very close to stopping play altogether.

I did some cheating and examples and gotten some militias and what not, and it costs me about 2k less but its still hectic as it is keeping this town as its costing me too much.

I do remember however that on Betas and what not this wasn't as difficult. Hell I remember having 3 towns with 300 troops and also 1 City with 200 troops and the upkeep was the same, but the trade was alot more profitable and fighting lords was alot more profitable, nowadays the scraps I get from the lords isnt worth the grain in salt, hell even raiding caravans is a bore, as it yields very little reward.

My only guess is that:

a. City money is alot less than beta, hell I get more when I was asked to get money off Praven, Suno, and villages too :\.
b. Rewards for taking out lords with high numbers yields very little rewards, remember that taking out lords I could just make 2k to 3k denars on gear alone. And I make about 1k to 2k denars on Caravans...
c. Upkeep is more costly than before ( though I didnt think so originally either, ahvent got the beta as I removed it but I can find out in a moment I guess ).

I dont know how people who play M&B 1.011 go by with upkeep of 10k get it so easily, I dont capture all the time and I dont exactly have the patience to keep retrying to ensure I capture a lord. And yes if I captured a lord this probably wont be a problem but the time for the ransom to come up is also less :\.

Is there anything else I can try ( and no I wont stoop myself in ransacking villages because it'd make too little difference anyway, and yes I tried it and it works but its only temporary and works well only on Average+ Villages, which unfortunately for me isn't many at the moment ).

I dont want to resort to ctrl-x spamming so I can get by... or edit my denars... I feel jealous that most of the lords can field 500+ troops ( well ok 350 troops in a town and 150 on foot ). and raid and I'm stuck on a merchant run to get by :sad:.

EDIT:

I loaded up my old game 0.960 save, and just so I have about 120k denars on that game. I have like 500 troops in 2 cities and 200 troops in one keep. I think I break even if I do my rounds and get my tax. I admit the last game was a too easy with the money but the new Money on 1.011 is so pain train :sad:. I woulda been content if the city taxes I get was about 3k to 4k on very rich. But I'm curious to ask people who has this 10k upkeep and still pay it off what you're doing to make ends meet, I dont think that your towns would break even would they, and how many troops do you folks have?
 
10k upkeep?

You´re definetly using the wrong troops as garrison. Use a lot of cheap ones instead of a couple of hundred high end ones.

Cut down the troop strengths in pacified areas, keep those at the frontline at a moderate level. At least, thats where the fighting takes part and thus, close to you. Apart from that there should be plenty of time if anyone sieges one of your holdings to arrive in time to beat the attacker off the field and send him running.

Raise your looter skill. Once you start looting decent gear, it will become a lot easier. I havent had any money problems so far in 1.001, but on the other hand, I´v never had 10k upkeep before. Most I had was in Native Expansive 8,5k just the other day. But that was with 150 high end troops caught in the field.

So get more Leadership, lowers upkeep as well.

And a average city usually gives to three to four times the money than a village - only your villages are unhealthily rich.
 
Nooser: How much denars do you get for very rich city? and how much money do you get for a very rich city.

Funnily enough ( The last time I got my taxes from my rich village was 1k, and also in my poor village that recently got raided and was also once rich ) I get 1k ). And I get 1k also in towns. :\.

 
I haven´t played Vanilla for quite some time since I enjoyed HYW and am currently occupied with Native Expanded. My lousy villages usually get me something between 250-800 denars and towns something between 1k-2k, depending on trade.
 
Well the first thing is, you need to get rid of this peaceful aspect of yours. Your not going to get anywhere making money trading or from collecting taxes, you need to raid villages and sell what they drop, and steal cattle and sell them.
 
Lord_Adam 说:
Well the first thing is, you need to get rid of this peaceful aspect of yours. Your not going to get anywhere making money trading or from collecting taxes, you need to raid villages and sell what they drop, and steal cattle and sell them.

war=profit
 
Like noosers said, your weekly upkeep is way too high.

Take some men out of your garrison and attack the enemy. (and hopefully lose plenty of men)

If you have to, disband some men. (not recommended unless you are really desperate)
 
1. Get high leadership to lower upkeep. This can become very significant.
2. Do not garrison mounted units - They cost more and have no advantage in a siege anyway.
 
My guess is that if he runs with 100-200 troops in his own army then he already has high charisma and leadership. I haven't played 1.011 extensively to reach that point but from what I'm reading money seems to be an issue, and I experience that in some instances even with a small army of 40-50 good units I have almost 1k of upkeep to pay. It would make sense that towns would bring in MORE money than villages. It makes no sense otherwise and this issue should be addressed, not making up ways of avoiding what seems to be an obvious problem just because we don't want to spot an impurity in the game.
 
If his army is truly worth 10k, why hasn't he done any warring? Conquer, attack, and win. If you can carry around 200 troops, carry your high leveled ones and keep lower leveled ones in your castles and towns. Siege and keep going until you lose about 100 of your solid units, and by that time you could have conquered the entire Rhodok race if you use 200 high tier troops.

Get your pay to around 6.5k. You'll still have strong troops, well guarded estates and a good army, and won't be losing as much. Also, if you have to disband, do so. But you can not stop attacking and conquering, otherwise your money will deplete.

Raid. Whether they are rich or poor, raid villages, I always get at least 4 - 5k per raid, and if you lower your army numbers to about 5 - 6k, you'll have no problem evening it out.

I have 29k in my main Nordic game. I've been able to maintain it pretty well. I've captured all of Vaegir and Rhodok, and am letting the Swadians drench out the Khergits in there war before I start looking for it. I own two towns, three castles and 6 villages. Each has a garrison of about 140 well crafted men. I walk around with about 50 - 80 depending on whether I'm attacking or not. I've been raiding Khergits in my own personal war for money. My plan is to assist the Swadians in defeating the Khergits, and I hope to score at least one castle down there. Then with the Swadians completely surrounded, we Nords can come in and strike.

 
My main ways of income are village raids and cattle steals.


you can steal 2 cattle and get 2k on my game (fresh beef goes for 533 a peice)

another thing i do is keep lots of prisoners instead of immediatly selling them lik ei used to i just keep them in curin castle i got somehting like 200 prisoners there now this helps when you come down to a hard time and need to make money quick you got like 10k denars right there


but the best way to go about it is just raid villiges instead of doing trade runs i dont got much time to do that anymore though as im marshall and the khergit are ****ing bastards especially when the veagir already own every nord castle and they want it back but i remembermaking 10k in 4 days sometimes and that would definately start to get you ahead
 
Kinda Learn to Play-issue.

I've never seen money as a problem.

Everytime you visit a town, buy and sell. Everytime you meet a tournamet, win it. That's how easy it's actually, of course slay Sea Raiders and so on..

And, stupid ****, don't ****ing join those ****ing armoured tanks - play as Nords!

"The defenders are weak in this brutal war
The northmen have power and guts
A bloodshed like no one has seen here before
None can escape their cuts"
 
Definitely the wrong garrison troops.  In my current game (successfully rebelled vs Nords with the claimant) I have 3 towns - Tihr, Wercheg, and Reyvadin - and my weekly upkeep is around 4-5k, and it's far too high.  With 2 towns it was around 2k including my moving army (usually around 90ish troops, mostly top tier Huscarl/Marksman/Horse Archer types) and garrisons of about 200 in each town.  The reason my upkeep is so high now is that I went a little training crazy and now have over 120 Huscarls, like 90 Marksmen, and a bunch of other guys I don't really need.  Worse, every time I beat another Vaegir lord I get all sentimental and wind up trucking all of their imprisoned Nord warriors/veterans/etc. back to Reyvadin rather than sending them to the unemployment office.  I've really tried to get a bunch of them killed but it doesn't seem to do any good.  :razz:

Still with that kind of upkeep I have no real cash problems.  I'm just running low once in a while since I'm trying to get all 8 followers in plate with thick extremity parts, which run over 10k per.  If I ever get below say 20k I just go capture a ton of Sea Raiders (still GREAT for cash loot) and visit all towns a few times for taxes.

Your town garrisons should consist mostly of tier 1-2 troops with a few tier 3 for color if you like.  When I take a town, I stash my army inside to hold it just in case, and immediately dash around recruiting lots of villagers, then return them to the city right away.  Usually a little more than half of them have gone to tier 2 at this point.  Look at the difference in weekly pay you need for a recruit/footman/even say a Vaegir skirmisher vs those Swadian Knights you've been holing up behind walls where they don't do you any good.  It's MASSIVE.
 
I suggest you use recruits to replace those massive garrisons and go around pillaging land and stealing gold.
 
I decided to use my 500 combined T4 troops to siege Rhodok territory, flush out the remaining Khergits, and take out the nords.

Unfortunately, I lost so far about 100 troops after taking out the 5 cities, 8 castles and retaken 3 times of Veluca to flush out the Khergits.

And to make matters worse I blame the huscarls I got 10 of them and they keep getting bigger and bigger........ up to 30. So are the Knights, I had about 40, now I have about 80 ROFL.

I still have to take out 80 Knights and its 9k upkeep but because I captured about 8 lords I should be ok.

I also got Narra and use that as my staging operations for Nord and then work out what next. I should probably rotate my troops around when I get a chance.

Nords I think are a bit overpowered, with the amount of HP and damage they can take they pretty much pushed back the entire Rhodok army in sieges.....

Oh, the only problem was taking one of the castles in Rhodok territoy near Jelkalla or something, it was something where I needed to hit it twice to take the castle down.

I never knew 1.011 meant Foot & Large Shield. I'm impressed that the Crossbow is alot better than previous versions too. Feels like a totally new game from Beta.
 
Well, if you got too many high end troops, feed your fellow Lords or Caravans/Farmer parties with a few of them to raise their self defence abilities. Just join a battle and release a few dozen troopers. Im usually pepping up infantry/archer/low tier heavy Lords or whacked Caravans of my Nation that way, providing them with a couple of Knights/TopTierTroopers.
 
Here is the interesting thing however that I have found which is really wierd, and also strange.

After taking Yalen, I have had twice in a row when I need to get taxes 4k, whereas Narra only yields 1.5k, and both towns are Very Rich :\. So how does that work I'm confused.

 
CountArtha 说:
CTRL+X is the solution. :wink:

i think we are talking about ''legit'' playing, alot of threads wouldnt exist if they didnt want to cheat.
 
-get an enemy that your nation rarely wars with. they will attack you a lot and you get to make money.
-get loot skill up
-cattle = about 1k each
-good trade run, buy furs in vaegir lands, buy spice in kergit lands, sell furs and buy velvet in veluca, buy velvet in jelkala, sell all in tihr.
-keep crap forces in castles/towns. i'm pretty sure the AI will wait to begin attack if you have more, not better. if you have to few they will try to take castle as soon as they can get ladders/siege tower up
-when i'm not doing trade runs or cattle i do a little better than even. i keep 80+k and still buy equipment for champs.
-swadian knights are strongest unit on field.
-horses in inventory make you move faster, no infantry make you move faster = faster trade runs, more battles = more loot
move quick and get more.

really isn't a problem, just make money
i don't think cheats work in 1.011. such as ctrl-x, ctrl-F4, at least not for me
fought 47 kergit with three, including me. Victory​
 
后退
顶部 底部