CTCCoco said:
What? troubles? You can do it, obviously... it's only a mod. There are million of illegal game servers, like these "Habbo Retros" and they are still online without any problem.
In fact, do a Module based on the idea of a game can't be illegal... it's stupid.
Well, things like "Fire and Sword" are based off a book, so obviously you'd have to have an agreement with copyright holder. Historic mods are different - you can't copyright history, the same way you cannot "own" air. Public domain.
My concern is mostly with models and story - its obvious that they are owned by Bethesda. Its mostly the frustration of doing a lot of work to find that your work is illegal (even in the format of this forum). So to rephrase:
Will a mod based on Morrowind be possible to develop (using mostly models and story from the game) on this forum, keeping in mind that the final goal is not in any way commercial.
As for stupid ideas... just like a statue is 3D and you'd have to look at it form different angles to understand its beauty, a universe shown in a game has just as many points of view as there are different platforms. I'm sure a good Warband-style hack-n-slash in Morrowind universe will be appealing to many people. Its how you do it
EDIT:
Belendor Torheal Artendor said:
It is if you use any sort of content from the game itself instead of making them yourself with references which are not illegal at all.
Well if I make the same models as there are in the game their similarity could be already grounds for ... trouble
My idea was to combine the visuals and story of Morrowind with the "Pirates!"like nature of Warband. I guess all the visuals will be considered "illegal".
MadVader said:
Making a mod based on copyrighted intellectual property is not illegal, but distributing is - when the relevant lawyers notice it. Ever wonder why TLD (LoTR-based) and SWC (Star Wars based) are not hosted on the TW forums? Exiled by lawyers contacting Taleworlds (though I'm not familiar with the details).
Practically, you can do it, but be prepared to move to an external forum if your mod's profile gets too high (if you ever get that far...
).
Right, that was the answer I was looking for! Thanks
True, its a lot of very hard work and I doubt I'll even start it, but if I did I could produce pages of ideas how to combine Warband and Morrowind. It think it would be cool. Either way I think I know what the situation is.