rgodfrey 说:
--snip--
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=03MZG9vK0W8&feature=player_embedded
What he's saying is that education is going to suffer from healthcare. There is a point there that he's made that should really stand out--higher education availability to the middle class is decreasing. This leads to a not only a shrinking middle class, a growing lower class, and a stagnant upper class, but also creates this sort of loop:
Spend more money on healthcare->raise education costs->less doctors, researchers, etc to innovate, make things more efficient/cost-effective/cheaper, to create competition, to increase the supply of services->higher price of healthcare->spend more on healthcare->raise education cost...
But if you prefer a warmer argument (as I do):
And what of the people around Granny? Does she have no one around her to help her? Are her family, friends and fellow townspeople cold, greedy jerks? Why are they not jumping to help her themselves? I've seen extremely successful local volunteerism/donation efforts to help people out when they needed, is there nothing like that for her? What ever happened to supporting yourselves and the ones you loved? What happened to helping the community you lived in? Can the fed really do better? Hell no, she'd probably die before the the money got through the red-tape anyway!
I have my own problems, and my family have their own problems, and my town has it's own problems. I'm not going to pay for someone else's dying granny 100 miles away when my granny might not be doing so well either (which she isn't, however she's not dying). Perhaps we should focus on fixing the startling inflation of indifference to others in society before we throw in the "pay off our problems" solution.
And what of the teachers that got laid off? How will they pay their medical expenses without a job? What happens if them or one of their family members get sick? I doubt that any healthcare plan the government could provide would be quick enough handle the smaller problems. Maybe that teacher's child's strep throat that he/she didn't have the money to treat turns into rheumatic fever? That's really serious.
And let us not forget the reasons I mentioned earlier that has contributed to rising health costs. Maybe we can fix those first?