Is Mythology the turth disguised as a Tale? or a Tale to disguise a Turth?

Users who are viewing this thread

http://karabakh-doc.azerall.info/ru/turkologiya/trk17eng.htm
How hays became 'Armenians'
(on the problem of adoption of the Turkic ethnonym)

The problem is who gave them a Turkic name? And why?

Russians?  http://karabakh-doc.azerall.info/ru/turkologiya/trk003eng.htm
http://karabakh-doc.azerall.info/ru/turkologiya/trk004eng.htm
 
Demonwolf said:
I just realized that the OP is true...  :shock:




APRIL FOOLS!

Don't feed the troll. He posts only when you keep his thread alive  :mad: So let's allow this thread to die peacefully  :mrgreen:
 
ancalimon said:
http://karabakh-doc.azerall.info/ru/turkologiya/trk17eng.htm
How hays became 'Armenians'
(on the problem of adoption of the Turkic ethnonym)

The problem is who gave them a Turkic name? And why?

Russians?  http://karabakh-doc.azerall.info/ru/turkologiya/trk003eng.htm
http://karabakh-doc.azerall.info/ru/turkologiya/trk004eng.htm

I find it highly amusing that the author of this drivel accuses russian historians of being butthurt and nationalistic, looking for ways to present the Slavs as having ancient history. Another pot calling the kettle black.

Hey, I'm perfectly fine with Slavs emerging in the 6th century. :wink:

(of course, do I need to point out the "articles" are just rubbish nonsense?)
 
What do you think about the crazy man's text about Hebrew and Ancient Indian ?
http://www.viewzone.com/matlock.html
http://www.hermetics.org/ibranice.html (Turkish translation (not an attack site))
 
Ancalimon, has it ever occurred to you that these "odd similarities" you see between the words of different languages are because there is a sort of "soft cap" to words. The possible combination of letters and pronunciations that make up words isn't endless, and people tend to use whatever is more comfortable to pronounce.

Like it has been said a dozen times before, 2 different cultures can come up with the same idea independent of each other.
 
ancalimon said:
What do you think about the crazy man's text about Hebrew and Ancient Indian ?
http://www.viewzone.com/matlock.html
http://www.hermetics.org/ibranice.html (Turkish translation (not an attack site))

I don't know about Indian or Hebrew culture. Even their history. So I can't speak or incline reasonably.
 
Amagic said:
Ancalimon, has it ever occurred to you that these "odd similarities" you see between the words of different languages are because there is a sort of "soft cap" to words. The possible combination of letters and pronunciations that make up words isn't endless, and people tend to use whatever is more comfortable to pronounce.

Like it has been said a dozen times before, 2 different cultures can come up with the same idea independent of each other.

You mean that Mayas could have made up a religion named Christianutu and build temples called churchtepec, their prophet-God named Shesus Curist and their religious leader could have been called Bob all by coincidence?
 
Amagic said:
Ancalimon, has it ever occurred to you that these "odd similarities" you see between the words of different languages are because there is a sort of "soft cap" to words. The possible combination of letters and pronunciations that make up words isn't endless, and people tend to use whatever is more comfortable to pronounce.

Just to expand on this a little:

Ancalimon, try looking up something called the "strong law of small numbers." It basically says that “there aren’t enough small numbers to meet the many demands made of them”, or, as is relevent here, if the field of posibilities is small enough, patterns seem to turn up without actually existing.

Compared to the set of all possible meanings, the set of all possible words, whilst massive, is still ridiculously small. Therefore it would be shocking, from a mathematical perspective, NOT to see patterns. Assuming these patterns always have to mean something is about as scientific as stabbing someone to see if their dead. Sure you'll get results, just don't expect them to be at all helpfull.
 
Why did ancient Turks defined Tengri as a swan swimming in the sky?

Here's a theory I found while Googling:

http://saturniancosmology.org/arch.php

http://forum.davidicke.com/showthread.php?t=36484&highlight=tengri&page=2

Tengri is a pure, white goose that flies constantly over an endless expanse of water, which represents time. Beneath this water, Ak Ana ("White Mother") calls out to him saying "Create".

Tengri: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tengri


Here is your goose/duck/swan aka sheldrake:

duckman1po3.jpg
 
duckman2ac1.jpg
 
duckman3mu0.jpg
 

And this is a mason sheldrake:

masonsheldrakefo7.jpg


Stickman and duck/goose man go together and it has all to do with the eightspoke it is the tric of EL:
default.jpg
  http://www.youtube.com/v/Wnv7v_c3l2c

So goose and create go together:

After about 5800 BC the Earth fell into an orbit below Saturn and seemed to have moved closer. This in effect obliterated the figure in the sky, replacing it by the swirling cloud, which eventually formed into a giant egg standing above the horizon in the north. Because Uranus did not line up with Saturn, it was seen past the edge of Saturn as the head of a bird, and the whole was recalled, in the artifacts and pottery decorations of some people, in this foreshortened form, as the image of a bird in the sky or as the Goose of Creation. http://saturniancosmology.org/arch.php


The eight spoke in the bell.The bell shape is a mode of them gods.

....

Cuneiform_sumer_dingir.jpg
  Sumerian Dingir

If this is true, the Turks simply observed the sky and made it sound romantic. If these things happened a lot, we can actually decipher mythologies with some thought.
 
That somehow manages to make even less sense than you normally do.

A giant egg in the sky? Ducks? Earth moving towards saturn? Your anus is a birds head?

Well done, you've got one thing right. Thus making this post stand out even more.

You really should meet rgodfrey, that would keep us entertained for decades. Or possibly drive us to mass suicide.
 
ancalimon said:
What do you think about the crazy man's text about Hebrew and Ancient Indian ?
http://www.viewzone.com/matlock.html
http://www.hermetics.org/ibranice.html (Turkish translation (not an attack site))

Crazy, crazy man. Nothing like you, of course.

In fact, there may be some connection between IE and Semitic languages. Some few words such as "six" and "seven" may have Semitic origins. This borrowing would of course have happaned thousands of years ago.
Still, it would be later than your World-Spanning Turkish Empire.
 
Figured I would swing by this morning to get my daily lulz from Ancalimon.

I am presented with some whack-nut theory about duck eggs.

I laugh and I leave.
 
Here is a video about Celebration OF Nature among Turks in English.

http://www.facebook.com/video/video.php?v=114869875259015&oid=128458183861372&comments

It means daylight and was about the mythology in which Turks got out of the Iron mountain by melting it and reaching daylight.

Unfortunately Newruz is known in Turkey as the day PKK breaks windows of shops, terrorize people, etc.. It has become a day of terror in Turkey. Parents don't allow children to go out or even go to school on Newruz celebrations.
 
ancalimon said:
Amagic said:
Jesus... was Turkish?

Oh for crying out loud...

No that's not what I think.

I think Jesus was created during the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Council_of_Nicaea by Konstantin.

His true name was not Christ, he was a Turk and a believer in Tengri-Eternal Blue Sky.

His deeds were taken, combined with Tengri and was shaped into a human God.

This secret should be hidden inside Neo-Greek culture. There must be some kind of joke in which they say "Jesus is a Turk" to make fun of this. Any Greek know of such a joke?

Read these book for an insight:

http://www.adji.ru/book10_3.html (Tengri-Khan and Christ, His Foster Son)

http://www.adji.ru/book11_1.html  (search for the part: The Turkis and Christianity)

:roll: :idea: :!: :!: :!: Found something about a joke about Christ being a Turk in Neo-Greek culture :smile:

http://foodforthethoughtless.com/2008/02/the-easter-egg/

Easter(n) Style

The traditions involving the Greek Easter egg are much different from our own, and much more no-nonsense than, say, the Russians’. The Russian Easter egg is far too expensive to be produced yearly, but they are a good investment if you have the money. The Greeks don’t bother to hide their eggs. Why hide food you know you’re going to eat later? Unless, of course, one is re-enacting an historical event and therefore hiding it from the Turks or the Germans. No, they just dye them blood red and put them in the middle of their dinner table. There’s more to it than that, of course. There’s a power game involved.

What it all means.

The red coloring of the eggs represents the Blood of Christ to the Greeks. It is a fortunate coincidence that they are also highly attractive.

The cracking of the egg is meant to symbolize Christ breaking out of his tomb as he rises from the dead. If this is true, it remains to me uncertain why the person with the uncracked egg is favored. If there is a crack anywhere, it is in the logic of this game. Perhaps the others are simply masking their grief for the damned soul of someone who is now certain never rise to heaven.

If you decide to play the game but are somewhat uncomfortable with so much Jesus talk, you might try substituting your own ritual call-and-response during the game. Something non-religious, yet still meaningful. One person shouting out a love for corduroy while his challenger announces his preference for suede is one such suggestion. I find the Greek tradition of being in such strong verbal agreement with each other while engaging in such aggressive behavior unconvincing and lacking in any real dramatic tension. I suppose if the first person shouted out the usual “Christ is risen!” and the second person responded, “No, I think he’s still napping” or “Christ was a Turk”, there might be some real tension. It is undoubtedly to my own advantage that I don’t know how to say those things in Greek. It might be exciting to witness, nevertheless.

Surprise? Unless, of course, one is re-enacting an historical event and therefore hiding it from the Turks or the Germans.

What does he mean by saying the usual “Christ was a Turk” ?  Is this a common joke among Christians?

These are all ancient Turkic mythology combined with weird stuff and converted into a stupid game. Life started from an egg according to these ancient myths. These are pseudo-scientific (but still existing) stuff about Atlantis, Mu, etc.. Earth was of endless waters inside en egg. From the waters, Ak Ana (White Mother) ordered Ülgen to create and Tengri created life. The egg broke and Earth came to existence. This is what the Egyptians, Uyghur, Chinese, Ogurs call the Cosmic Egg. According to pseudoscientific theories about Mu and Atlantis, Uyghurs and some of the Native Americans were the only surviving people. Uyghurs being the main people and Uyghurs recreated civilization. That's why Egyptians (in Africa) and Uyghur and Ogurs (Uyghurs that migrated North also connected to old Bulgars) have the same mythologies. The Oghuz converted to Islam and made some kind of Iconoclasm on their own mythology. They converted their remaining mythologies into Islamised versions.

AK ANA (WHITE MOTHER)  BAY ÜLGEN (MR. CREATOR?) (really lol)      OD ANA (MOTHER OF HOLY FIRE)
akana_copy.jpg
                 
ulgen_cop...jpg
                   
od_copy.jpg


semr%C3%BCk.jpg

SEMRUK and BÜRKÜT symbolized Sun and Moon, Masculine and Feminine. Upwards pointing triangle (üç(3), kuş(bird)) was the male and downwards pointing triangle was the female. These were the first Ying Yang in the world. They are all over rocks together with other Turkic tamgas.

Tengri orders to burn 3 fires in the human soul and Od Ana buries and puts out three fires to Earth.  Today we call this "Cemre" the fire falls to Air, Earth and Water every year. (this entered Egyptians via Turks not Islam! why am I the first person telling you these? Because these things are taboo in most of Turkic culture that's open the the rest of the world.)
The ÖKSÖKÖ bird brings down lightning from the Heavens and this lightning carries human soul in OZ (unshaped energy with a purpose and desire carrying the will of Tengri) form to Earth with rain which in return creates human bodies and humans themselves.


did anyone read these books? "Black Athena" & "Black Athena Writes Back: Martin Bernal Responds to Critics"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Athena
 
ancalimon said:
These are all ancient Turkic mythology combined with weird stuff and converted into a stupid game. Life started from an egg according to these ancient myths. These are pseudo-scientific (but still existing) stuff about Atlantis, Mu, etc.. Earth was of endless waters inside en egg. From the waters, Ak Ana (White Mother) ordered Ülgen to create and Tengri created life. The egg broke and Earth came to existence. This is what the Egyptians, Uyghur, Chinese, Ogurs call the Cosmic Egg. According to pseudoscientific theories about Mu and Atlantis, Uyghurs and some of the Native Americans were the only surviving people. Uyghurs being the main people and Uyghurs recreated civilization. That's why Egyptians (in Africa) and Uyghur and Ogurs (Uyghurs that migrated North also connected to old Bulgars) have the same mythologies. The Oghuz converted to Islam and made some kind of Iconoclasm on their own mythology. They converted their remaining mythologies into Islamised versions.

Ok all of your other stuff was utter nonsense so I shall cut it till here. So if life started from an egg, does that mean that humans are reptiles? And if the egg broke and all the water came out, what did all the water land on? And you just created that part of the Oghuz right after I mentioned them?

And no, the Oghuz couldn't bring their mythology to Islam. Everyone in the Middle-East followed the Sunni Islam way. If you were to bring your mythology into the religion, you would have to influence its powerbase and make it reeducate EVERYONE, which is just impossible. And implementing mythologies into the religion is heretical, and you'd be everyone's target in no time.

Also, the Turks came to Anatolia way after Islam, so it's impossible that they had influenced Islam.
 
Back
Top Bottom