I can´t start a garrison anymore. Bug?

[Pinto]

A few days ago after i conquer a castle/town alone or with other lords, i can´t start a garrison anymore, unless the king assign to me the fief.  This is really anoying and i don´t want to start all over again after so many hours played,  only because of this weird bug.

I couldn´t find here in the forum someone else with this same problem.

 

[Pinto]

I instaled the 1.113 patch and is still  the same thing.

 

[LOLLord Ben]

I had the same in 1.111, but only as a mercenary for another king. I think it's just because you can't "manage" the castle/town since the king has to decide who gets it. I left my castle and the enemy just captured it back, and then I got the Message "King has appointed the castle to...", lol. BUT IT'S NOT OURS ANYMORE! Just hold out in the castle/town till the King appoints a claimant. Or do like I do - don't be mercenary anymore and you can keep it 

 

[Pinto]

haha Thanks for the reply, but i am a vassal already.  from the Swadia

AI still can start a garrison soon they conquear. 

It´s ok to me to wait for few days until  the king gives me the fief so i can manage the garrison, but is really annoying when i get a lot of trouble to capture it and the new assigned lord by the king never apears to his castle/town to manage the garrison,  Garrison = 0, i had tried to wait for 2 weeks max, but i can´t stay there forever.    When i am a marshal or not this bug keeps happening.

The only thing i can do now is quit being a marshal or conquering places. 

 

[Pejot]

The stupid thing is that AI gives castles on the one side of the map to the lords that have their lands on the other side of the map so before they arrive to the castle it can be retaken.

 

[dzorro]

Talk to your minister and tell him to give the castle to you. That seems to do the trick now. At first when conquering the castle it ask you if you want the castle even if you say yes the castle still isn't given to you then i tried through the minister screen and the castle was granted to me.

 

[vc110388]

same here

I can't station garrison anymore on the castle I have just taken.

this mean that I have to wait after I have took down the castle for the king give that castle to me..

Is this problem solve when I restart a new game??

 

[killer1000fr]

same for me with that patch cant put soldiers on garnison :s

 

[Calogrenant]

Same here, and was about to ask.

It's quite silly that option was removed. Just think about it for a minute: Medieval times, no cell phones nor satellite communication, days of travelling to get a message, much longer to move troops, so why wouldn't a king allow a recently-conquered castle to have a garrison even before he decides who the castle goes to?

And regarding the game mechanics, I loved that option, knowing it existed allowed me to use those prisoners you wouldn't want to have in your party due to many different reasons (budget, morale), but wouldn't want to let go at the same time, making the garrison an amazing place to drop them at.

Cheers

 

[Pinto]

If they disabled it, they should do the same to the AI not to do it aswell,  or  to putting it back do the things be more fair and reallistic.  PLease, let us start the garrison again before the king gives the castle/town to someone.

Everytime their patches removes something annoying from the game, it appears much others things. 


I have the same doubt as the buddy above. Is this a bug where restarting  the game this go alway?  Or is intentionaly done by the devs?

 

[woofty]

It happened to me to.  Veluca had 150 defenders.  I asked that munch King Graveth why they didn't attack the town.  His reply, "It was considered to heavily defended."  So I grab my 80 band and we attack.  We take it after about 20 of my folks killed.  I didn't pay attention to the wounded, but it was full of prisoners.  I grab them to garrison the town.  No such luck.  I even asked to receive the town, which I got, but I couldn't garrison any one until I owned the town.

So, I go out to collect recruits to garrison the thing, while I'm gone, the Swadians come back and retake it.  They leave a 45 garrison group.  I retake the town and go and collect more people to place at Veluca.  Again though, I have to be alotted the town before I could garrison folks.

Again when I go to collect troops, the Swadians come back and retake the town, leaving 15 to garrison it.  This time, the entire Effing Rhodock army shows up.  I was torqued at the Swadians though so I was hunting and smashing their armies this time.  I put King Harlas's band to the sword.  Instead of helping more though, with the 5+ Swadian armies running around that I have to take on, the Marshal for the Rhoschmucks attacks the 15.  I finally get finished securing the area and get in on the siege.  Guess whom they gave the town to?  Yes, the Marshal.  Needless to say I left the Rhojerks and will never be another vassal again. 

 

[Pinto]

This problem happening to woofty is what annoys me.  The game became unplayable to me if we as a vassal, have  to conquer castle/towns to the kingdom.

 

[Pejot]

I have another problem i'm a vassal and every fief swadia conquer isn't given to anybody and no garrison appears and every 2 days the message about changing marshal appears and Harlaus always choose Ryis to be the marshal.

 

[Pinto]

I have another problem i'm a vassal and every fief swadia conquer isn't given to anybody and no garrison appears and every 2 days the message about changing marshal appears and Harlaus always choose Ryis to be the marshal.

This marshal problem happened to me also.  The developers have to change this,  with the king Harlaus also.  The problem is because the appointed lord is in prison somewhere. When this happened to me i had to wait the war ends to him be released, i tried to free him, but another bug annoyed me because i couldn´t talk to him behind the bars, i tried many angles.

 

[Pejot]

I can't even talk to any lord about who should get any fief. Checked again fiefs aren't granted if lord who becomes marshal is in prison.

 

[woofty]

I have another problem i'm a vassal and every fief swadia conquer isn't given to anybody and no garrison appears and every 2 days the message about changing marshal appears and Harlaus always choose Ryis to be the marshal.

This marshal problem happened to me also.  The developers have to change this,  with the king Harlaus also.  The problem is because the appointed lord is in prison somewhere. When this happened to me i had to wait the war ends to him be released, i tried to free him, but another bug annoyed me because i couldn´t talk to him behind the bars, i tried many angles.

You actually can talk to every that is placed behind bars.  One just has to play a very annoying game of movement and mouse look.  The distance to the bars can very as well as the angle you look.  I've had to look at ceiling and some times their boots or off center  to talk to them, but I have yet to fail any more at losing the talk ability.  Oh, and dont' foget the distance.  Moving back and forth as well as sideways is necessary.  Yeah, I'd call it a bug but one can do it.  It's just an excessive, royal pain.

 

[Goffik]

A few days ago after i conquer a castle/town alone or with other lords, i can´t start a garrison anymore, unless the king assign to me the fief.  This is really anoying and i don´t want to start all over again after so many hours played,  only because of this weird bug.

I couldn´t find here in the forum someone else with this same problem.

I asked about this garrison issue in this thread. The reply was that this ability was removed by the v1.105 patch. Whether its existence was a bug that has been fixed or an intended feature which has been broken, I don't know.

I'd like to see it re-enabled as its useful and removed the need to babysit every fief you take for days and days. I've compared Menu.txt from v1.100 which had the option to the same file from v1.113 which doesn't. The only difference for the garrison option is that v1.113 has an extra block of numbers, possibly instructions for when this option should be enabled (eg, only when you own the fief). I've never modded M&B but maybe the option could be re-enabled simply by deleting the extra block? I can't test this immediately, as I got rid of all my old saves...

 

[woofty]

It would be nice if the we could because the evil AI still can and does.

 

[Pinto]

A few days ago after i conquer a castle/town alone or with other lords, i can´t start a garrison anymore, unless the king assign to me the fief.  This is really anoying and i don´t want to start all over again after so many hours played,  only because of this weird bug.

I couldn´t find here in the forum someone else with this same problem.

I asked about this garrison issue in this thread. The reply was that this ability was removed by the v1.105 patch. Whether its existence was a bug that has been fixed or an intended feature which has been broken, I don't know.

I'd like to see it re-enabled as its useful and removed the need to babysit every fief you take for days and days. I've compared Menu.txt from v1.100 which had the option to the same file from v1.113 which doesn't. The only difference for the garrison option is that v1.113 has an extra block of numbers, possibly instructions for when this option should be enabled (eg, only when you own the fief). I've never modded M&B but maybe the option could be re-enabled simply by deleting the extra block? I can't test this immediately, as I got rid of all my old saves...

To make changes myself so i decided to be a king and now i can "station garrison" soon i get even if is not on my name, but i wasn´t ready to be king, very hard to defend my small kingdom almost by myself against 40 lords.  but my right to rule is 27, i predict soon i will have plus 20 or more lords attacking me.

 

[Goffik]

A few days ago after i conquer a castle/town alone or with other lords, i can´t start a garrison anymore, unless the king assign to me the fief.  This is really anoying and i don´t want to start all over again after so many hours played,  only because of this weird bug.

I couldn´t find here in the forum someone else with this same problem.

I asked about this garrison issue in this thread. The reply was that this ability was removed by the v1.105 patch. Whether its existence was a bug that has been fixed or an intended feature which has been broken, I don't know.

I'd like to see it re-enabled as its useful and removed the need to babysit every fief you take for days and days. I've compared Menu.txt from v1.100 which had the option to the same file from v1.113 which doesn't. The only difference for the garrison option is that v1.113 has an extra block of numbers, possibly instructions for when this option should be enabled (eg, only when you own the fief). I've never modded M&B but maybe the option could be re-enabled simply by deleting the extra block? I can't test this immediately, as I got rid of all my old saves...

To make changes myself so i decided to be a king and now i can "station garrison" soon i get even if is not on my name, but i wasn´t ready to be king, very hard to defend my small kingdom almost by myself against 40 lords.  but my right to rule is 27, i predict soon i will have plus 20 or more lords attacking me.

Er... come again?