Have Tale Worlds ever taken a creative idea directly from the forums and implemented it into the game?

正在查看此主题的用户

当前在线： 3 （会员： 0, 游客： 3）
Dr-Shinobi 说:
Dont think you understand how it is to really have responsibility over an production line. Its not just that easy to do this and that because of many factors and there is also alot of ideas out there that havent been thought thru.
点击展开...
No I get you, there is that. But there are really simple features that is asked, yes they need work too but its not an excuse. Like add preset tournament armors when joining a tournament. What does this effect? And this is an important thing because when you are poor and dont have a proper armor you are doomed to lose basically. More complicated but still not that much features are, manhunters, patrols. Nobody expects them to do this in a month or two but its been 7 months but there are several tiny tiny new features. But I must add, they might be busy with optimization and QoL and maybe they will start adding new features soon, who knows.
 
Memoefe 说:
No I get you, there is that. But there are really simple features that is asked, yes they need work too but its not an excuse. Like add preset tournament armors when joining a tournament. What does this effect? And this is an important thing because when you are poor and dont have a proper armor you are doomed to lose basically. More complicated but still not that much features are, manhunters, patrols. Nobody expects them to do this in a month or two but its been 7 months but there are several tiny tiny new features. But I must add, they might be busy with optimization and QoL and maybe they will start adding new features soon, who knows.
点击展开...
Absolutely agree with the suggestion. But honestly, if they would make that change with the next update nobody would see it as a milestone. It would be welcome, but it would just be another QOL improvement / balancing change which is exactly what some people are complaining about...

Almost all missing features in Bannerlord are rather minor in my opinion. If we look at some of the missing stuff from Warband (poems, feasts, romance, books) they all sound great on paper but they are so simple that their addition probably wouldn't impress anyone. Which is kinda paradox because the lack of these features is one of the most common complaints.

Books:
Just an item that gives you a passive buff as long as it's in your inventory.

Poems:
Just a few lines of text that you can learn from some guy in a tavern. There are like 9 different poems and each lady likes 3 of them.

Romance:
Tell her a poem. If you win a tournament you get +1 relation when you talk to a lady.

Feasts:
All lords of a faction gather in a castle.


I would love to see these things in game, but it would be exactly what they've been doing so far (assuming the fidelity of these features would be similar to the implementation in Warband). Actually, adding a spear bracing mechanic or giving us the choice to pick troops for hideouts is probably way more complicated than adding a few books to the vendors.
 
This forum have a million great, both relatively easy and hard to implement suggestions.
Have I seen any of these taken up into development? I can't remember a single one.

And back at every Paradox game ever: Literally almost every patch note is user/player influenced.
Where I have been apart of influencing several patches just by doing simple forum posts and giving ideas.

This forum might be the old paradox layout.. But the spirit of Paradox is far away.
 
Cri11e 说:
This forum have a million great, both relatively easy and hard to implement suggestions.
Have I seen any of these taken up into development? I can't remember a single one.

And back at every Paradox game ever: Literally almost every patch note is user/player influenced.
Where I have been apart of influencing several patches just by doing simple forum posts and giving ideas.

This forum might be the old paradox layout.. But the spirit of Paradox is far away.
点击展开...
I suggest you read the thread, some people already named a few additions / changes suggested by the community.
 
They do implement player suggestions, but it tends to be simpler things that they can do without too much extra effort. I don't think they're looking to implement major gameplay ideas or entirely new mechanics that would take a ton of work and affect different systems. I can understand that, since they've got a lot on their plates already and probably aren't too eager to take on big new projects in the middle of it.
 
Memoefe 说:
No I get you, there is that. But there are really simple features that is asked, yes they need work too but its not an excuse. Like add preset tournament armors when joining a tournament. What does this effect? And this is an important thing because when you are poor and dont have a proper armor you are doomed to lose basically. More complicated but still not that much features are, manhunters, patrols. Nobody expects them to do this in a month or two but its been 7 months but there are several tiny tiny new features. But I must add, they might be busy with optimization and QoL and maybe they will start adding new features soon, who knows.
点击展开...

LOL Dude. Its been 7 months with no major content added to the game. What makes you think anything else is coming?
 
Dreed89 说:
Maybe unit selection for hideouts. Or maybe it was in their roadmap and was already going to be implemented some time. I am not sure.
点击展开...
That can hardly be counted as an Idea from a player, since that one was almost a no brainer in my opinion. On the other hand tho there are a lot of things that could be considered a no brainer and yet TW doesn't do **** about it.

Dr-Shinobi 说:
I mean if we take an random example as bringing in boats to the game which sounds cool and all. Do you know how much extra work that would bring right now, to just get in that function in to the game and at the same time keeping up with the other things towards an solid platform
点击展开...
I would agree, if Modders, who mostly consist of just 1 person maybe 2 or 3 (waaaay less manpower than TW has), wouldn't be able to do so much more than TW does.
To put it best, this game is made purely for Money, there is literally 0 soul or Love in this game. And you can feel it. The first Mount & Blade was a Lovechild, Bannerlord is a money printing scam so far, idk what they did in the past few years but most certainely not develop this game.

Everyone can see it, everyone can feel it. The Game lost 95% of its playerbase in just 7 months. That is something incredible that not even Twitchs flavor of the month games can achieve. Not a single major thing got added during this "early acess" they are still trying to fix bugs that are there since release. Just pointing out again, bugs that got fixed within 4 days by modders. There is no excuse to this anymore.
They have 0 clue how to develop a game apparently, there seems to be no leadership in the office. And/Or the money went into something completely different than the game.
 
cyresdog 说:
That can hardly be counted as an Idea from a player, since that one was almost a no brainer in my opinion. On the other hand tho there are a lot of things that could be considered a no brainer and yet TW doesn't do **** about it.


I would agree, if Modders, who mostly consist of just 1 person maybe 2 or 3 (waaaay less manpower than TW has), wouldn't be able to do so much more than TW does.
To put it best, this game is made purely for Money, there is literally 0 soul or Love in this game. And you can feel it. The first Mount & Blade was a Lovechild, Bannerlord is a money printing scam so far, idk what they did in the past few years but most certainely not develop this game.

Everyone can see it, everyone can feel it. The Game lost 95% of its playerbase in just 7 months. That is something incredible that not even Twitchs flavor of the month games can achieve. Not a single major thing got added during this "early acess" they are still trying to fix bugs that are there since release. Just pointing out again, bugs that got fixed within 4 days by modders. There is no excuse to this anymore.
They have 0 clue how to develop a game apparently, there seems to be no leadership in the office. And/Or the money went into something completely different than the game.
点击展开...

Stop being full of **** ^^. If this game was as you said, i would most def not be spending 1.5k hours in it xD or maybe they came at night and hypnotized me as im now part of an Sleeper cell ? Damn it im calling Alex Bones

Here have some Circle of life and contemplate some Mofasa Spirit
 
最后编辑:
Medivhtratos 说:
And now the Question @Dr-Shinobi , "Do YoU UsE Mods?" XD
点击展开...
Nope. I tried one or two out for short time just to see how they where but that was just for 1 hour. Im saving all the mods til release since i want to help give my 5 cents on this game and try to direct it to be really good...But its hard ^^ Especially with all the whiny half asses barely running the game without cheats or mods, and want everything on an silver platter :wink:
 
I've said this before, I dont know why TW doesn't create a forum just for ideas on the game, no discussion to clog it up just create a post with your idea. The community can come up with so many amazing ideas, just look at what modders can do, some are so brilliant, why not implement them into the game, why should we have resort to mods to get great features. Doesn't mean you have to do it, but alteast hear them out and I am sure there are some that will be great.
I actually made a post about children getting stats as they age, and can almost see the new system for children getting skills i the development video sort of reflective of what my post said. I don't care about credit if they did take my idea, I am just happy they did something. So let's hear from the community and get some great ideas to put into the game.
 
Dr-Shinobi 说:
Nope. I tried one or two out for short time just to see how they where but that was just for 1 hour. Im saving all the mods til release since i want to help give my 5 cents on this game and try to direct it to be really good...But its hard ^^ Especially with all the whiny half asses barely running the game without cheats or mods, and want everything on an silver platter :wink:
点击展开...
Just because you have 1.5k hours doesn't mean its any good. Steamcharts back me up, the forum numbers back me up. The threads on this forum back me up. That is not just a personal view i share, that is just dumb facts.
But with your statement you clearly shown what is wrong with the game industry nowadays, whoever criticizes a game (and i've done constructively enough) is automatically a hater. Either you full on love the game and defend against every tiny atom of dirt, or you are garbage.
You know that a company can only grow when they admit their mistakes, work on them and try to make it better? You can't tell me that Taleworlds is actually doing any of that.
Their communication non existant.
The work on the game seems more destructive so far than what they added to it.
Collecting feedback, haven't seen that anywhere.
Taleworlds as a developer went from amazing to horrible in just 1 release.
But you just show me what i have said months ago, the vast majority of the people who defend this game are newcomers.
 
最后编辑:
cyresdog 说:
Just because you have 1.5k hours doesn't mean its any good. Steamcharts back me up, the forum numbers back me up. The threads on this forum back me up. That is not just a personal view i share, that is just dumb facts.
But with your statement you clearly shown what is wrong with the game industry nowadays, whoever criticizes a game (and i've done constructively enough) is automatically a hater. Either you full on love the game and defend against every tiny atom of dirt, or you are garbage.
You know that a company can only grow when they admit their mistakes, work on them and try to make it better? You can't tell me that Taleworlds is actually doing any of that.
Their communication non existant.
The work on the game seems more destructive so far than what they added to it.
Collecting feedback, haven't seen that anywhere.
Taleworlds as a developer went from amazing to horrible in just 1 release.
But you just show me what i have said months ago, the vast majority of the people who defend this game are newcomers.
点击展开...
Not really.... but there is a lot of people whining just for the sake of it and especially when something is successful. Even if i can share some concerns (i had my fair share of frustrations to), but others are just here to **** on things when you can clearly see that they arent even barely playing the game so theres two camps and some in between. I mean take you as an good example...All you have done is spewed **** and not even trying to give constructive feedback since day one...tells something along with others here what they really want :wink: Others opinions i can respect though since i can see that they are being objective about the situation. I mean for someone **** talking constantly for 7 months not wanting to change when they could just have dropped out and played something else indicates on something else to me dont you think ? I would most definitely went on to my other games and gave a rat ass on the forums if i felt this way...especially if i cant say something constructive ^^ but hey thats just an personality check i guess

 
最后编辑:
Dr-Shinobi 说:
All you have done is spewed **** and not even trying to give constructive feedback since day one..
点击展开...
Research on point. Dude looking for that takes 2 minutes. If you wanna go deeper start looking through forum posts in other peoples threads. I have clearly given more than enough constructive criticism.

So instead of looking on my Profile, you started profiling me. You just did it horribly, ironic.
Just strengthens my point that you don't care about facts, or fact checking, you just look at the game through rose-tinted glasses.
 
cyresdog 说:
Research on point. Dude looking for that takes 2 minutes. If you wanna go deeper start looking through forum posts in other peoples threads. I have clearly given more than enough constructive criticism.

So instead of looking on my Profile, you started profiling me. You just did it horribly, ironic.
Just strengthens my point that you don't care about facts, or fact checking, you just look at the game through rose-tinted glasses.
点击展开...
Looking at Profile only ? no not really.... but ive seen you more then enough in many comments and discussions to give an pretty clear profile of you. Which reminds me of that Wolf guy who likes to message me now and then because of his fetish for griefs ^^ Opinions are healthy and i like them but constantly hearing **** when **** is not due then i have to say a thing or two because its tiresome...But hey its a free world right
 
Dr-Shinobi 说:
Nope. I tried one or two out for short time just to see how they where but that was just for 1 hour. Im saving all the mods til release since i want to help give my 5 cents on this game and try to direct it to be really good...But its hard ^^ Especially with all the whiny half asses barely running the game without cheats or mods, and want everything on an silver platter :wink:
点击展开...
So there is another one that's not using mods and enjoying the game
Good stuff
 
您必须登录或注册才可回复。

类似的主题

a message to the community and developers(From reddit)
2
回复
27
查看
1K
Yoshioki Ouchi
Yoshioki Ouchi
Jozzzza
Siege needs to be updated!
回复
0
查看
273
Jozzzza
Jozzzza
flashn00b
Euthanize the multiplayer dog
回复
7
查看
842
Onikami78
Onikami78
后退
顶部 底部