Greece.

Do you support Greece's decision on the bailout plan?

  • Yes.

    选票: 4 18.2%
  • No.

    选票: 6 27.3%
  • Neutral.

    选票: 12 54.5%

  • 全部投票
    22

正在查看此主题的用户

It seems I got warned for that. Even though this whole thread is full of overstatements and generalizations about the worth of my country and other Greek people, it is my overstatement about the Germans that crossed the line.
Its still refreshing to see a Greek view on the subject. Its easy to generalize the Greek problem to nationalities and see who the 'good productive' or 'bad unproductive' groups are. Looking deeper to see how some people who had no say at all about what their country did suffer the consequences makes everything more complex. Nothing does this better then to see a personal example.
Your older generation really f*cked you up. But I still think it makes more sense for you to pay for that then for whoever gave out the loans.
 
MadocComadrin 说:
TheLoneWolf1 说:
Wellenbrecher 说:
About the picture, is that about to insinuate that she's a fascist or something? It's hard to follow your narrative here between all the superfluous insults.

No. It simply expressed my concern and mistrust about her policies, her tactics and the way she handles things.
No, your intent was exactly to insinuate that she is a fascist.

I can't make the conclusion or insinuate that Merkel is presently a fascist from some pictures that were taken back in 1992. Other than that I can still feel concerned because of them.

DeGoblin 说:
Its still refreshing to see a Greek view on the subject. Its easy to generalize the Greek problem to nationalities and see who the 'good productive' or 'bad unproductive' groups are. Looking deeper to see how some people who had no say at all about what their country did suffer the consequences makes everything more complex. Nothing does this better then to see a personal example.
Your older generation really f*cked you up. But I still think it makes more sense for you to pay for that then for whoever gave out the loans.

I never said that we should't pay what we owe. In my opinion it is wrong to see this as solely a Greek problem. It is a European problem if you think that in case Greece goes bankrupt and exits the E.U. the consequenses for the whole of Europe are quite unpredictable (maybe catastrophic if you think of other countries like Portugal and Italy that may follow). We try to explain that by forcing us to follow a program that has in fact weidened our dept while at the same time refusing to let us develop any kind of productive structures lessens the posibility of us actually making it. I mean like why do I have to bear with six to ten Greeks living below the relative poverty line, unemployment rate rising from 9,5% in 2009 to 26,6% in 2014 (young unemployment above 50%) when my ****ing depts are rising even more? :razz: This program has offered us nothing but more problems and when we try to negotiate this with the other countries in Europe we get a stern disapproval from the German government saying we expect Greece to keep on as planned. For what?
 
TheLoneWolf1 说:
I never said that we should't pay what we owe. In my opinion it is wrong to see this as solely a Greek problem. It is a European problem if you think that in case Greece goes bankrupt and exits the E.U. the consequenses for the whole of Europe are quite unpredictable (maybe catastrophic if you think of other countries like Portugal and Italy that may follow). We try to explain that by forcing us to follow a program that has in fact weidened our dept while at the same time refusing to let us develop any kind of productive structures lessens the posibility of us actually making it. I mean like why do I have to bear with six to ten Greeks living below the relative poverty line, unemployment rate rising from 9,5% in 2009 to 26,6% in 2014 (young unemployment above 50%) when my ******** depts are rising even more? :razz: This program has offered us nothing but more problems and when we try to negotiate this with the other countries in Europe we get a stern disapproval from the German government saying we expect Greece to keep on as planned. For what?

I'm no expert on the program but as long as Greece pays the debts with at least part of the interest I don't think anyone would mind. Problem is you can't rebuild an economy and get rid of the debt at the same time. By choosing the economy over the debt you will only pass it over to the next generation and in even larger proportions. Like I mentioned earlier, money loses its worth with time, hence planing on paying later would mean you need to pay more. Its natural that terms will be renegotiated to something Greece could afford or it will be a lose-lose situation, but postponing the payment even more is nuts.
In short, you say Greece should pay back the debt so you need to know that without giving back any profit you have to give part of the interest too , so the faster you do it the better it will be for everyone (aside from your government of course).

A simpler way to look at it is that their older generation worked harder so get their younger generation a better future when they gave away the loans. Your one did it the other way around. I think that is the ultimate form of corruption but you can't undo it.
 
Very nice. I almost shed a tear because of the unfair treatment of your valiant attempts to illuminate the masses.

But unfortunately you ignored the bit where your first post was a complete insult ridden polemic piece of crap which caused the replies you quoted there so nicely in the first place.
If that is your idea of
start a fruitfull conversation
then you seem to have misunderstood what the words "fruitful" and "discussion" actually mean.


Like I said, keep blaming Germany, maybe that will get you out of your hole at some point. I doubt it, but I have been known to be wrong in my time.
 
If Greece didn't want to pay back money, they shouldn't have taken it so lustily and misused it so drunkenly. :neutral:

I think the legitimate chance of absolving the debt is to have the government of the time prosecuted. =/
 
Wellenbrecher 说:
If that is your idea of
start a fruitfull conversation
then you seem to have misunderstood what the words "fruitful" and "discussion" actually mean.

Instead of quoting parts of my post and talking crap without sense, you may actually try to read it. Here is the post I directed to you in order to start a fruitfull conversation (because I actually understand the words) about the dept.

TheLoneWolf1 说:
@Wellen of course I have nothing against you taxpayers that righ now reinforce our economy (I don't know for how long still though) but the terms of the economic adjustment programme you government forces are really ****. We spent the last 5 years paying only for amortization while the actual dept kept augmenting and with plans of it actually starting to get paid off after 2020. They give us money to keep things running at the minimum cost possible with most people living at the edge of poverty to raise barely enough money to pay ridiculously high interest rates. I mean do you find that right? What my country needs from an economic adjustment programme is the ability to make some revenue and start developing productive structures in agriculture and other areas that we can be productive. This is the only way that we will start to be self-sufficient and thrive while paying off this enormous dept in time. What your government does is making us work to death just to keep living while taking anything you can for guarantee. Well exuce me if I don't like this idiocy of a plan that makes me feel like I am 40 years old already with all the **** I got to pay here and there.

You see I don't get your problem Wellen. My first post which you called a complete insult ridden polemic piece of crap, is simply a post where I talk about how life is in Greece presently, how hard is for me to study and work at two jobs at the same time while still being called lazy by many in Europe and how the European saviors that jumped to save us in our time of need actually made everything worse. You respond again and again to me in an insulting and ironic way without even trying to talk solutions about the matter. If you clearly don't care about the hardships in Greece and the whole matter then don't post about it. If you do post try to say something constructive about the subjects at hand.

EDIT. Here is my insulting first post if you want to freshen your memory
TheLoneWolf1 说:
It's really easy for people who live outside a country with problems to critisize it and propose simple (to their minds) solutions. In Greece right now there are people that live without electricity. People are killing themselves. Recently a police officer was diagnosed with cancer and when he thought what would that cost to his already indepted family he shot himself. The basic salary in Greece is 500 euros a month when just for renting an appartment to live and cover expenses (electricity) you need a minimum of 400 euros a month and I am talking about a serioucly small apartment.

Furthermore spare me the bull**** like " The Greeks should get their lazy ass back to work". I am 23 years old and I have to work on two part-time jobs in order to cover my expenses and be able to study in AUEB since my family lives in the countryside and they couldn't afford to cover my expences for me to go to univercity. I have never voted for these governments that got us to this place the last 40 years yet again I have the 22th highest dept in the world to pay. That's life for people in my age here and what I hear is people saying stuff like they shouldn't have free education. Almost nobody would afford to be educated if it wasn't free right now in Greece. Great Solution.

And yes we tried the ****ing economic adjustment programme for 5 years now. What did we get? Stability? Work?
No we got an even higher dept while paying of only the amortization of what we owe while germans were buying off ports and public services as guarantee for their money. I sure as hell don't want to live like that for another 30 years at the edge of poverty awaiting false stability and false development from ****ing European saviors.

Kobrag 说:
If Greece didn't want to pay back money, they shouldn't have taken it so lustily and misused it so drunkenly. :neutral:

I think the legitimate chance of absolving the debt is to have the government of the time prosecuted. =/

The current government has already formed a Committee of Inquiry to investigate how we got to this place and hopefully bring those who are responsible to justice. It could help us with the dept a bit but it won't absolve it.
 
Nobody cares if some Greek politicians get lifetime or are hanged in the streets. The Greek situation has consequences for the entire banking system in the Eurozone that won't go away no matter how many or which individuals are ritually assigned blame.
 
kurczak 说:
Nobody cares if some Greek politicians get lifetime or are hanged in the streets. The Greek situation has consequences for the entire banking system in the Eurozone that won't go away no matter how many or which individuals are ritually assigned blame.

The people who are to blame for this made millions of money out of it. Apart from justice served if their fortunes were to be seized and confiscated for the crimes they committed it could help with the repayment of out depts.
 
Your country currently owes 300+ billion euros and running annual deficit of another cool 20+ billion euros. Even if you can successfully convict a couple of dozens individuals (which, fat chance), how much can you nominally get from them? Maybe some tens, hundreds million, super tops. And do you think they have the money stashed under their beds? Best case scenario it's in some Dutch Antilles trusts (good luck with that), worst case scenario it was blown on coke, hookers, yachts and cars and other quickly depreciating, illiquid assets. The actual confiscation are going to be a drop in the ocean of the total debt, which your country is obviously never ever going to pay back. It's like asking a gender studies graduate to pay back a 100 million USD student loan. Is it absolutely technically impossible? No. But will I be holding my breath for it to happen? Also, no. The question is not will Greece default, but how and when will it default.
 
ByWZmCq.jpg
 
@kurczak I still find it better than let all those responsible walk and who knows, we are talking about 40 years of people stealing, there may be something that could be taken back. On the matter of dept repayment the greek government has already proposed two types of new bonds that could lessen our burden since the dept at this point is not viable and we are technically already bankrupt. http://rapidis.blogactiv.eu/2015/02/04/can-varoufakis-perpetual-bonds-be-a-smart-move/
It isn't going to be easy, we might not make it anyway but it is still better to look for alternatives than following a program that doesn't work and wait until they finally throw  you out.
 
Kobrag 说:
If Greece didn't want to pay back money, they shouldn't have taken it so lustily and misused it so drunkenly. :neutral:

I think the legitimate chance of absolving the debt is to have the government of the time prosecuted. =/

they weren't "lustily" taken. i have yet to meet a single person who has taken a loan
out of germany. these are generalities, that make people in greece really dislike
some foreigners and create a hostile climax, both in european countries of the north
and greece.

the problem has a lot to do with germany.

things that greece can be accused of:

1st: creating an army of public employers. they were originally created by some political parties,
in order to maintain a respectable voting base. the parties that are hugelly responsible for this, are
the "new democracy party", which is a right wing political partie (now going more and more to the
extreme right. and p.a.s.o.k (left wing socialist partie in the past, now going to the right).

2nd: Leaving corruption rule over everything in the state mechanism. not excluding private sector.

3rd: a mentality that sadly, in *some* percentage of the population, is explaines as
"let's save our ass, and let the others drawn. and also a sense of false superiority
that *some* people have over strangers.

Things that germany and some other countries/organizations/banks can be accused.

1st: lending *not* their money, but money from citizens through loans, that were given
to some people and banks here. this takes some analysis.
This money given through the e.u and the tro'i'ka, has never reached the people of greece.
the vast percentage of every dose of money that greece receives is gone to the debt. that means
that the money the e.u gives greece goes to repay the same loans that the e.u gives.
after that some money goes to help banks, owned by a very small elite.
and then the rest goes to thepensions and the health system.
the percentage that reaches actually the greek people is much smaller than 8%,
and the money which is given to pay the loans, through taxation ofthe
population is hugelly bigger than the percentage
that is taken for social issues.
the ammount of the debt is now something like 300 billions ( i think 320), this debt has already been paid
by the greeks. the debt doesn't go down to interest that is added every year for every separate loan.

2nd: the corruption is largelly due to foreign countries and the e.u.
i will give an example of how things work here. a few years back, the minister of defence made
a competition of buying submarines from germany. the germans made an offer, while
*bribering* several officials ansd ministers of that time. the order itself was hugelly overvalued for
what was offered.
and the submarines themselves were leaning on the sides! the sailors at the time used
to reffer to them as "moving coffins".

the result was that the country had taken things, that didn't need, in a debilitating price,
because of corruption. but the corruption wasn't single sided, it was a two-way thing.

imagine that mentality in every single transaction that greece has made.
Olympics 2004, the road of athens, the road of salonica, siemens, just
to mension a few.


the post is getting very long, so i stop. :smile:


*a small statistic thatwillclear a lot of things: the annual income (GDP),
of greece since 1990 is at average about 58 billions. from this annual income
about 30-40 billions each year goes to the repayment of debts.
if 1990 is considered as the starting year of the downfall,
greece has given about 750 to 1 trillion euros for this. yet
the debt is not shrinkig! it grows each year.
 
sifis172 说:
This money given through the e.u and the tro'i'ka, has never reached the people of greece.
the vast percentage of every dose of money that greece receives is gone to the debt. that means
that the money the e.u gives greece goes to repay the same loans that the e.u gives.
after that some money goes to help banks, owned by a very small elite.
and then the rest goes to thepensions and the health system.
the percentage that reaches actually the greek people is much smaller than 8%,
and the money which is given to pay the loans, through taxation ofthe
population is hugelly bigger than the percentage
that is taken for social issues.
the ammount of the debt is now something like 300 billions ( i think 320), this debt has already been paid
by the greeks. the debt doesn't go down to interest that is added every year for every separate loan.

This to me is the strongest point, and the one that people don't seem to get. At this point Greece's debt is so high that simply making interest payments is taking up a large portion of the budget. How can Greece be expected to get back on it's feet if that doesn't come to an end? Or, if they are not expected to get back on their feet, how are they going to keep making these interest payments without taking out new loans?

It's completely bonkers that Greece was given "bailout" loans in order to pay off interest on other loans, but now people are yelling at them for not being able to pay off these new loans quickly. If they could have done that, they wouldn't have needed the new loans in the first place!
 
This to me is the strongest point, and the one that people don't seem to get. At this point Greece's debt is so high that simply making interest payments is taking up a large portion of the budget. How can Greece be expected to get back on it's feet if that doesn't come to an end? Or, if they are not expected to get back on their feet, how are they going to keep making these interest payments without taking out new loans?

It's completely bonkers that Greece was given "bailout" loans in order to pay off interest on other loans, but now people are yelling at them for not being able to pay off these new loans quickly. If they could have done that, they wouldn't have needed the new loans in the first place!

this debt has grown beyond any salvation. this loan is given every
year from taxpayers to pay the international voltures. it's a win-win situation
for them. to put it simply, they take money from others to give it to someone
who will(?) give it back to them with inetrest.

i don't think that greece is expected to make it back in it's feet, i don't know
even if that's what they* want. the only solution that is sadly available,
is a complete default and denial to pay the debt.

that would be catastrophic, in my opinion, but if europe** doesn't consider negotiations
it will be the only viable solution.

*i'm not talking about citizens of course.
**that means germany.
 
the corruption is largelly due to foreign countries and the e.u.
Yes, blame the corruption on someone else.  :roll:  And do you know what? Even if your example is true, bribing is corrupt on both sides. The briber does not magically transform the bribee into a corrupt individual. Hell, quite often the bribee is fishing for the bribe.
 
Well put sifis but a few things bothered me:
the percentage that reaches actually the greek people is much smaller than 8%,
Its not correct to count money going off to pay the debts as money not reaching the people of Greece, because the debt they would otherwise be need to be payed from their own money. Its important to do that to try to reduce the interest its producing.
But it does raise questions, like why take a big second loan and use part of it to cover the first loan instead of taking a small loan and use it solemnly for the economic infrastructure? All these extra deals play to the hands of the rich few that actually make money out of all this.

and the submarines themselves were leaning on the sides! the sailors at the time used
to reffer to them as "moving coffins".
I don't think a gossip from a few sailor means anything, its very easy to find soldiers complaining about perfectly fine things in an army, especially in the lower ranks. Also, Germany has a good name for her subs and is a big exporter for it, I heard only good things about the ones Israel bought. Plus, they usually get bought empty - little more then moving fish. So if it malfunctions it doesn't necessarily mean it was Germany's fault rather then something non German added later.
 
TheLoneWolf1 说:
But in this case the bribee seems to be getting all the blame.
Really? No. The blame is being thrown back and forth (you don't think there haven't been non-Greek articles in major publications blaming Germany and such?); it just so happens that the more solid evidence and greater locality of fault lies with the bribee.
 
MadocComadrin 说:
it just so happens that the more solid evidence and greater locality of fault lies with the bribee.

I think you are generalizing. I fail to see how this is true in many cases.
 
后退
顶部 底部