forced not to kill generals

[sirano]

about update 1.1.0 they made executing a lord make u lose relation with basically everyone
this is the worst addition for me it really turned my game to **** im playing with the southern empire and the stupid ai made war with every one i was just starting to catch there lords and execute them but now i updated the game and if i lose too much relation the lords in my faction wont be cheap to form an army with them and i cant make anything at least they should give us an option to disable this or at least to balance it make it so that imprisoned lords dont run away after 1 minute give us something in return at least because in most games were facing allot of enemy lords

 

[drallim33]

Yes this was a dumb change, knee-jerk reaction to players executing every lord. If they would just fix the game so lords don't escape from prison in under 30 seconds, and implement proper ransom negotiation, then we wouldn't need to execute them in the first place and this poorly conceived change would be redundant.

 

[Azhael]

I agree. It's not a bad idea that honorable lords don't like executions, but 10 points for each is ridiculously high. I mean we're Vlandians and I'm executing aserai lords, how could they care so much? Btw, I recommend the mods Prevent escape that makes escaping lords way less frequent and adds ransom options tweakable in game.

 

[dannazgu]

Because killing a prisioner who surrended is not honorable, if they surrender they admit defeat and is your prisoner. Only ruthless and untrustworthy lords kill prisoners, unless is retaliation.

 

[hruza]

So you complain that devs have removed what was basically an exploit from the game?

 

[sirano]

Because killing a prisioner who surrended is not honorable, if they surrender they admit defeat and is your prisoner. Only ruthless and untrustworthy lords kill prisoners, unless is retaliation.

true but if u see the lords they did not surrender they are wounded i catched them he did not dismount his horse and say ok i give up + when i tell him yield or die he dosent surrender if he say i surender from the start i would make him sit with me in the castle too

 

[sirano]

So you complain that devs have removed what was basically an exploit from the game?

it's not an exploit it was an option came with the game

 

[sirano]

I agree. It's not a bad idea that honorable lords don't like executions, but 10 points for each is ridiculously high. I mean we're Vlandians and I'm executing aserai lords, how could they care so much? Btw, I recommend the mods Prevent escape that makes escaping lords way less frequent and adds ransom options tweakable in game.

yeah well i did download bannerlord tweaks mod but game kept crashing when i enable the mod i would say best thing is if they just make imprisoned lords almost never escape but u get a juicy offer from his clan to make people set them free balance it in a sweet way i dont like also killing lords but because they keep escaping me i have to make me not have to but in a soft way

 

[Jarl Malcolm]

What I really don't understand is why you loose reputation with Minor Factions hired by the faction too? Losing with Lords is okay, losing with the person clan is mandatory, but being at -100 with Minor Factions that I release constantly is just weird

 

[hruza]

it's not an exploit it was an option came with the game

All exploits come with the games.

 

[Kangamangus]

Eh, I'm not big on executions myself...unless they REALLY deserve it. ...but the options should be there for the player to choose.

 

[hruza]

Eh, I'm not big on executions myself...unless they REALLY deserve it. ...but the options should be there for the player to choose.

It's still there. They did not remove it.

 

[sirano]

Eh, I'm not big on executions myself...unless they REALLY deserve it. ...but the options should be there for the player to choose.

yeah but the consequences of executing now effects your relations with your own faction that dosent really make sence i dont give a damn about an enemy lords faction lol make it -million relation but why my own clan and faction thats the annoying part any feature in game most have pros and cons but they made execution have only cons

 

[Azhael]

Yeah, you might maybe think lords on your own faction wouldn't like you executing enemy lords, since that could make it more likely they get executed if they are captured or one of their relatives, but still. 10 relation points for each execution is ridiculous.

 

[sirano]

All exploits come with the games.

what is the exploit in it tho there is consequences to use this option but they made it affect the game way to much i agree they should balance the options in the game but this is not really a balance just i dare u to execute them anymore maybe let the faction of a lord u executed send assassins or mercinary's to attack u that would make us execute less lords fearing retaliation but decreasing my faction's relation is annoying

 

[Kangamangus]

Yeah, you might maybe think lords on your own faction wouldn't like you executing enemy lords, since that could make it more likely they get executed if they are captured or one of their relatives, but still. 10 relation points for each execution is ridiculous.

Right...escalating the violence and vitriol and what not.

 

[Kangamangus]

what is the exploit in it tho there is consequences to use this option but they made it affect the game way to much i agree they should balance the options in the game but this is not really a balance just i dare u to execute them anymore maybe let the faction of a lord u executed send assassins or mercinary's to attack u that would make us execute less lords fearing retaliation but decreasing my faction's relation is annoying

I do like that assassin idea. Could add more unpredictability to the game.

 

[sirano]

Yeah, you might maybe think lords on your own faction wouldn't like you executing enemy lords, since that could make it more likely they get executed if they are captured or one of their relatives, but still. 10 relation points for each execution is ridiculous.

what sucks with me is im protecting the last city of the southern empire i like a challenge but if the lord of the last city hates me and dosent allow me to enter im screwed lol
i dont like the entire idea because the enemy faction alrady instantly have -100 relations with u so it was alrady balanced tbh

 

[Maximum997]

Guys, we need to make a list with every useless mechanics in the game.

the most funny thing that we are geting more and more of them.

 

[spartanlemur]

Yes, it's really stupid and was better when there was no relations penalty.

You should only lose relations with the clan of the person you killed, and their personal friends. No one else would really care all that much. Even within their own faction, they have enemies who benefit from their demise.