Yup, nice match but i couldnt play many rounds because my internet failed. 
EU Online Campaign I – Looking for an Adjudicator!
- Thread starter kingofnoobia
- Start date
Users who are viewing this thread
- Status
kingofnoobia
Master Knight
Shouldn't IFoR and 22nd still fight for Province 34, or did I just miss that? I've been skimming through the last few pages of posts and didn't see battle results.
kingofnoobia
Master Knight
Erm, the last PM I got from you (or any 22nd member) was with the move orders for this turn. Anyway, it doesn't matter, I'm doing the orders at the moment and I'll probably start a new topic for it.
edit: Only one army actually has to pick its retreat (the other ones are all defensive victories, meaning that the attacking army is automatically put back where it came from), which is the UK army in Province 37, and I'm afraid that one can't retreat anywhere and is disbanded (CB and IFoR armies block all neighboring provinces, the only free one is the one IFoR attacked from). The good news is that I won't be needing retreat orders and can just start the end of turn report
.
edit: Only one army actually has to pick its retreat (the other ones are all defensive victories, meaning that the attacking army is automatically put back where it came from), which is the UK army in Province 37, and I'm afraid that one can't retreat anywhere and is disbanded (CB and IFoR armies block all neighboring provinces, the only free one is the one IFoR attacked from). The good news is that I won't be needing retreat orders and can just start the end of turn report
.
kingofnoobia
Master Knight
Retreats Spring 1259 said:
The Illustrious Functionality of Reveran (Swadia)
Provinces (8 ): 16, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 39
Armies (4): 31, 37, 38, 16
Fleets (2): W7, W12
Supply Centers (6): 29, 30, 32, 28, 31, 27
The Empire of Istiniar (Rhodok)
Provinces (9): 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 11, 17
Armies (5): 11, 17, 3, 15, 7
Fleets (1): 1
Supply Centers (7): 1, 2, 6, 3, 5, 11, 17
The 22nd Imperium (Khergit)
Provinces (6): Y1, Y2, Y3, Y4, 34, 35
Armies (1): Y1
Fleets (4): 35, 34, W13, W17
Supply Centers (5): Y1, Y3, Y4, 34, 35
The United Kingdom (Nord)
Provinces (5): 37, 38, 42, 43, 44
Armies (2):37, 42, 43
Fleets (1): 44
Supply Centers (4): 42, 43, 44, 37
The Kingdom of Perkele (Vaegir)
Provinces (5): 10, 20, 21, 22, 33
Armies (2): 21, 33
Fleets (0):
Supply Centers (2): 20, 21
Caliphat Bohemius (Sarranid)
Provinces (5): 13, 24, 25, 36, 40, 41
Armies (3): 26, 36, 40, 41
Fleets (1): W4
Supply Centers (5): 24, 25, 36, 13, 41
Provinces (8 ): 16, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 39
Armies (4): 31, 37, 38, 16
Fleets (2): W7, W12
Supply Centers (6): 29, 30, 32, 28, 31, 27
The Empire of Istiniar (Rhodok)
Provinces (9): 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 11, 17
Armies (5): 11, 17, 3, 15, 7
Fleets (1): 1
Supply Centers (7): 1, 2, 6, 3, 5, 11, 17
The 22nd Imperium (Khergit)
Provinces (6): Y1, Y2, Y3, Y4, 34, 35
Armies (1): Y1
Fleets (4): 35, 34, W13, W17
Supply Centers (5): Y1, Y3, Y4, 34, 35
The United Kingdom (Nord)
Provinces (5): 37, 38, 42, 43, 44
Armies (2):
Fleets (1): 44
Supply Centers (4): 42, 43, 44, 37
The Kingdom of Perkele (Vaegir)
Provinces (5): 10, 20, 21, 22, 33
Armies (2): 21, 33
Fleets (0):
Supply Centers (2): 20, 21
Caliphat Bohemius (Sarranid)
Provinces (5): 13, 24, 25, 36, 40, 41
Armies (3): 26, 36, 40, 41
Fleets (1): W4
Supply Centers (5): 24, 25, 36, 13, 41
The new OP is ready to be posted, but I'll first ask okiN what he thinks about what would be the most practical way to migrate the thread. But first lunch, then studying, then this again
. Here's your stuff, copy-pasted from what should become the new topic.The order phase starts now, and I guess a deadline would be handy as well, so let's make that Tuesday, 16/11.
kingofnoobia
Master Knight
I'm on it right now, just a second.
Edit: Before publishing the next orders, I'll have to ask all participating factions a question. MaHuD brought up the suggestion, and I think it's fairly logical. You see, the 8-player guideline was originally meant merely as a solution when no agreement could be reached on the number of players. However, it seems to have become the standard number of players for the vast majority of matches. And that's fine by me, but it does mean that the 20% support rule doesn't really make sense if the default number of players is a number where the support calculation usually doesn't result in a natural number. So the idea was to increase the bonus to 25% per supporting army. I wouldn't say the advantage would become too substantial, because it's still way smaller than in actual Diplomacy (a larger chance of winning as opposed to a certain win).
I believe changing this rule would be logical and fair. Does anyone (any faction) object to that?
Edit: Before publishing the next orders, I'll have to ask all participating factions a question. MaHuD brought up the suggestion, and I think it's fairly logical. You see, the 8-player guideline was originally meant merely as a solution when no agreement could be reached on the number of players. However, it seems to have become the standard number of players for the vast majority of matches. And that's fine by me, but it does mean that the 20% support rule doesn't really make sense if the default number of players is a number where the support calculation usually doesn't result in a natural number. So the idea was to increase the bonus to 25% per supporting army. I wouldn't say the advantage would become too substantial, because it's still way smaller than in actual Diplomacy (a larger chance of winning as opposed to a certain win).
I believe changing this rule would be logical and fair. Does anyone (any faction) object to that?
kingofnoobia
Master Knight
Orders
Fall - 1259
The battle phase for Fall, 1259 starts now! Deadline: Saturday, 18/12.
Now, about that new topic/changed OP. I decided not to bother okiN with the question yet, because I honestly am not sure whether I can keep doing this. It's my first year (and hopefully not the last) at university, so I'm usually quite busy studying these days. Meaning that I don't have much spare time, and order processing is a bit of a burden at times.. I'm not quitting just yet, I believe I can handle it for now, but I might when things get even busier. Thanks for your understanding.
Oh yes, the rule is now officially changed to +25% players per supporting army.
Fall - 1259
The Illustrious Functionality of Reveran (Swadia)
16 Supporting 31
31 attacking 17 (with support from 16)
38 is supporting BoH's army at 41 (Thus attacking OL capital at 42)
37 is moving to 27
W12 is moving to W18
W7 is moving to 32
The Empire of Istiniar (Rhodok)
Army from Prov15 moves to Prov27
Army from Prov3 moves to Prov10
Army from Prov7 moves to Prov16
Army from Prov17 holds
Army from Prov11 holds
Fleet from Prov1 holds
The 22nd Imperium (Khergit)
34 Fleet attack 33.
W13 Fleet convoy Y1 army to 34.
W17 Fleet attack 44.
35 Fleet hold.
The United Kingdom (Nord)
42 supports 44
43 supports 42
44 supports 43
The Kingdom of Perkele (Vaegir)
trololololololololo
Caliphat Bohemius (Sarranid)
Army on 26 moves to 14.
Army on 40 attacks 43.
Army on 41 attacks 42.
Fleet on W4 moves to W10.
16 Supporting 31
31 attacking 17 (with support from 16)
38 is supporting BoH's army at 41 (Thus attacking OL capital at 42)
37 is moving to 27
W12 is moving to W18
W7 is moving to 32
The Empire of Istiniar (Rhodok)
Army from Prov15 moves to Prov27
Army from Prov3 moves to Prov10
Army from Prov7 moves to Prov16
Army from Prov17 holds
Army from Prov11 holds
Fleet from Prov1 holds
The 22nd Imperium (Khergit)
34 Fleet attack 33.
W13 Fleet convoy Y1 army to 34.
W17 Fleet attack 44.
35 Fleet hold.
The United Kingdom (Nord)
42 supports 44
43 supports 42
44 supports 43
The Kingdom of Perkele (Vaegir)
trololololololololo
Caliphat Bohemius (Sarranid)
Army on 26 moves to 14.
Army on 40 attacks 43.
Army on 41 attacks 42.
Fleet on W4 moves to W10.
Province 16
The Empire of Istiniar's army attacks the Illustrious Functionality of Reveran's army.
Neither side has support.
Province 17
The Illustrious Functionality of Reveran's army attacks the Empire of Istiniar's army.
Neither side has support (original IFoR support in P16 was cut).
Province 27
The Empire of Istiniar's army attacks the Illustrious Functionality of Reveran's army.
Neither side has support.
Province 33
The 22nd Imperium's fleet attacks the Kingdom of Perkele's army.
Neither side has support.
Province 42
Caliphat Bohemius' army attacks the United Kingdom's army.
Caliphat Bohemius has 1 support. IFoR players may participate on their side.
Province 43
Caliphat Bohemius' army attacks the United Kingdom's army.
Neither side has support.
Province 44
The 22nd Imperium's fleet attacks the United Kingdom's army.
Neither side has support.
The Empire of Istiniar's army attacks the Illustrious Functionality of Reveran's army.
Neither side has support.
Province 17
The Illustrious Functionality of Reveran's army attacks the Empire of Istiniar's army.
Neither side has support (original IFoR support in P16 was cut).
Province 27
The Empire of Istiniar's army attacks the Illustrious Functionality of Reveran's army.
Neither side has support.
Province 33
The 22nd Imperium's fleet attacks the Kingdom of Perkele's army.
Neither side has support.
Province 42
Caliphat Bohemius' army attacks the United Kingdom's army.
Caliphat Bohemius has 1 support. IFoR players may participate on their side.
Province 43
Caliphat Bohemius' army attacks the United Kingdom's army.
Neither side has support.
Province 44
The 22nd Imperium's fleet attacks the United Kingdom's army.
Neither side has support.
The Illustrious Functionality of Reveran (Swadia)
Provinces (10): 16, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 37, 38, 39
Armies (4): 17(attacking), 27(moving), 38(support42), 16(defending)
Fleets (2): 32(moving), W18(moving)
Supply Centers (7): 29, 30, 32, 28, 31, 27, 37
The Republic of Istiniar (Rhodok)
Provinces (9): 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 11, 17
Armies (5): 11(holding), 17(defending), 10(moving), 27(moving), 16(attacking)
Fleets (1): 1(holding)
Supply Centers (7): 1, 2, 6, 3, 5, 11, 17
The 22nd Imperium (Khergit)
Provinces (6): Y1, Y2, Y3, Y4, 34, 35
Armies (1): 34(moving,convoyed)
Fleets (4): 35(holding), 33(attacking), W13(convoy), 44(attacking)
Supply Centers (5): Y1, Y3, Y4, 34, 35
[/i]
The United Kingdom (Nord)
Provinces (3): 42, 43, 44
Armies (3): 43(defending), 42(defending), 44(defending)
Fleets (1): 44
Supply Centers (3): 42, 43, 44
The Kingdom of Perkele (Vaegir)
Provinces (5): 10, 20, 21, 22, 33,
Armies (2): 21, 33(defending)
Fleets (0):
Supply Centers (2): 20, 21,
Caliphat Bohemius (Sarranid)
Provinces (5): 13, 24, 25, 36, 40, 41
Armies (3): 14(moving), 36(holding), 43(attacking), 42(attacking,supported)
Fleets (1): W10(moving)
Supply Centers (5): 24, 25, 36, 13, 41
Provinces (10): 16, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 37, 38, 39
Armies (4): 17(attacking), 27(moving), 38(support42), 16(defending)
Fleets (2): 32(moving), W18(moving)
Supply Centers (7): 29, 30, 32, 28, 31, 27, 37
The Republic of Istiniar (Rhodok)
Provinces (9): 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 11, 17
Armies (5): 11(holding), 17(defending), 10(moving), 27(moving), 16(attacking)
Fleets (1): 1(holding)
Supply Centers (7): 1, 2, 6, 3, 5, 11, 17
The 22nd Imperium (Khergit)
Provinces (6): Y1, Y2, Y3, Y4, 34, 35
Armies (1): 34(moving,convoyed)
Fleets (4): 35(holding), 33(attacking), W13(convoy), 44(attacking)
Supply Centers (5): Y1, Y3, Y4, 34, 35
[/i]
The United Kingdom (Nord)
Provinces (3): 42, 43, 44
Armies (3): 43(defending), 42(defending), 44(defending)
Fleets (1): 44
Supply Centers (3): 42, 43, 44
The Kingdom of Perkele (Vaegir)
Provinces (5): 10, 20, 21, 22, 33,
Armies (2): 21, 33(defending)
Fleets (0):
Supply Centers (2): 20, 21,
Caliphat Bohemius (Sarranid)
Provinces (5): 13, 24, 25, 36, 40, 41
Armies (3): 14(moving), 36(holding), 43(attacking), 42(attacking,supported)
Fleets (1): W10(moving)
Supply Centers (5): 24, 25, 36, 13, 41
The battle phase for Fall, 1259 starts now! Deadline: Saturday, 18/12.
Now, about that new topic/changed OP. I decided not to bother okiN with the question yet, because I honestly am not sure whether I can keep doing this. It's my first year (and hopefully not the last) at university, so I'm usually quite busy studying these days. Meaning that I don't have much spare time, and order processing is a bit of a burden at times.. I'm not quitting just yet, I believe I can handle it for now, but I might when things get even busier. Thanks for your understanding.
Oh yes, the rule is now officially changed to +25% players per supporting army.
I suggest that the deadline be postponed a bit more due to the ENPL.
IG/EoI will have three matches in this turn of the EU campaign and we'll also have one match every 5 days in the ENPL. We'd need some more time, otherwise it'd be one match a day or something close to that.
IG/EoI will have three matches in this turn of the EU campaign and we'll also have one match every 5 days in the ENPL. We'd need some more time, otherwise it'd be one match a day or something close to that.
- Status
