AI units should keep guard up when fighting, never put hands down.

Users who are viewing this thread


This is for AI in general really, but I notice it most in Captain mode. Also tournaments when AI fight each other looks wonky the way they just stand planted in one spot and put their hands down. Holding up a block in any direction makes them at least 25% more ready for whatever their opponent might do.

By holding block they start from a position of being ready to block 1/4 to 1/2, depending on the enemy weapon, of the attacks the enemy can make. If the enemy has a spear, holding block down means you start from a position of blocking half their potential attacks by default. From there they simply have to move it up when needed.

The direction they choose to hold block could depend on the enemy's weapon. Say the enemy has a sword that can attack from all directions. The defending AI will have a 25% of automatically holding up a block in any direction and adjusting as needed. Say the attacking enemy has a two handed ax, the defending AI will have a 66% chance to auto hold side block (33% each side) and 34% chance to hold up block. If enemy has spear, 50/50 chance for defender to hold up or down block.

This will look more natural, and be more functional. Either be attacking, or be blocking. Hands should never go down in combat.
Last edited:


Its pretty silly, yeah.

No matter how untrained you are, you know not to just stand there while people try to kill you.

AI with higher "skills" seem to block faster/more often, but I think this could just be modified to changing their block to the proper direction more often. Unskilled Looters/Farmers will block in the wrong direction and not update it frequently enough to stop you from attacking the other direction, but even a chimpanzee would make an attempt to not be killed with a sword.

hell,I would argue that unskilled fighters should spend proportionately more time blocking than skilled ones. Blocking is fairly instinctive, attacking other people correctly is difficult.


Spanish Gifquisition
Grandmaster Knight
For me this is a +1.

In this thread I wrote about this, however there was a significant polarisation of opinion. Here is a test from that thread, where with a "animation magic trick :iamamoron: " as a conceptual simulation, the bots keep the guard position at all times.

Top Bottom