A woman in the US introduces a Bill to ban 'High Capacity Magazines'.

正在查看此主题的用户

No links etc, because I'm in a hurry.

Basically, a politician is introducing a state bill that will ban high capacity magazines, due to the recent shooting in Arizona, the one with Giffords. She said that 'There's no reason for people to have high capacity magazines, and they are only for killing innocent people'

Why I think it's bull****:

Loads of pistols (Most in 9mm, .45 etc) have standard magazines designed for more than ten rounds, the limit she's proposing.

She's heavily biased - Her husband was killed ten years ago by someone with a pistol loaded with a hi-cap. He was shot with like, the first few rounds, but since it was loaded with a hi-cap, it's terrible and must be banned omg.

In, say, a home defence situation, you might not have access to other magazines, or the time to reload. Extra shots might very well be needed.

Statistically speaking, misuse is in the *extreme* minority.

"If you're an anti-gunner and you say you're only trying to re-write the Constitution in order to save lives why don't you go after something like cigarettes or car safety regulations, things that will actually yield statistically significant results, saving lives and not infringing on the rights of law abiding citizens. More people will die from drowning at public pools in a few weeks in the summer than they will all year in shooting massacres but you never see the gun grabbers shouting for more lifeguards or pool safety regulations."

Many case-studies show that you will need a lot of rounds to put down a drugged up junkie robbing you, etc.

For example:

http://www.lawofficer.com/article/training/officer-down-peter-soulis-inci - 22 bullets hit him before he went down.

http://www.theshootist.net/2009/01/one-man-got-involved-perry_12.html - This guy continues to beat someone despite being shot 4 times. And when he's SHOT IN THE HEAD, he gets up and turns to attack the other officer.

http://www.lawofficer.com/article/training/officer-down-warriors-sacrific - A man gets his foot literally shot off, continues going.





****ty post, but meh. Thoughts?
 
... if high capacity really only means that they've got room for more then it sounds utter baloney, really.
 
I thought this was going to be a thread about the papery type of magazines, so I spent 30 seconds very confused.

[me=Pharaoh Llandy]flees[/me]
 
Tape 2 together, I've done that before, bit fidley, make sure you tape it right.
 
Alex_Augmented 说:
In, say, a home defence situation, you might not have access to other magazines, or the time to reload. Extra shots might very well be needed.
In say that situation, if you've failed to hit with ten ****ing bullets then the guy who kills you deserves a medal for services to the gene pool.
 
Stupid, I think people should have access to whatever they want, porn, pudding, and rocket launchers for instance.

Seriously, how am I going to have a proper rampage if my magazine is limited to only ten rounds?
 
Tibertus 说:
Stupid, I think people should have access to whatever they want, porn, pudding, and rocket launchers for instance.

Seriously, how am I going to have a proper rampage if my magazine is limited to only ten rounds?

I'm going to install the barrel from a Challenger 2 in my sitting room right now, pointing at the door.
 
I'm going to build a bunker and mount multiple 50 cal Browning Machine Guns in it, and then stockade it with all the magazines I can find that hold more then ten rounds, and then when the freedom takers come to take my freedom to have hi-cap magazines, I'll blast them into oblivion, and then they'll wish they had hi cap magazines.
 
I've had a better idea, a slingshot, and fire the hi-cap mags at them.
 
Well, I shoot the freedom takers anyways.

Burgass 说:
I've had a better idea, a slingshot, and fire the hi-cap mags at them.

Slingshots are illegal in NJ, isn't that funny? Didn't stop us from getting the really powerful ones though, sitting in trees and shooting cop cars.
 
AHH **** YOU *****! I SWEAR TO GOD THAT IF YOU BAN GUNS, I"M JUST GOING TO MAKE BOMBS! C4 +Homemade claymores+ home trained attack dog strapped with explosives = MORE DEAD THEN I CAN DO WITH A ****ING HI-CAP MAG!

seriously.
Archonsod 说:
Alex_Augmented 说:
In, say, a home defence situation, you might not have access to other magazines, or the time to reload. Extra shots might very well be needed.
In say that situation, if you've failed to hit with ten ****ing bullets then the guy who kills you deserves a medal for services to the gene pool.
Depends on range. Plus, you might be high. plus, you might be a poor shot. A person's worth is more then his competency with small-arms.
Burgass 说:
Tibertus 说:
Stupid, I think people should have access to whatever they want, porn, pudding, and rocket launchers for instance.

Seriously, how am I going to have a proper rampage if my magazine is limited to only ten rounds?

I'm going to install the barrel from a Challenger 2 in my sitting room right now, pointing at the door.
YES
Tibertus 说:
I'm going to build a bunker and mount multiple 50 cal Browning Machine Guns in it, and then stockade it with all the magazines I can find that hold more then ten rounds, and then when the freedom takers come to take my freedom to have hi-cap magazines, I'll blast them into oblivion, and then they'll wish they had hi cap magazines.
This is actually my dream-house/ retirement plan, except the M2s with be CORWS.
Alex_Augmented 说:
Grandfather clause - people who have them already are allowed to keep them. Which is another reason why this makes no sense at all.
Yeah! "I bought like 16 20-round mags for my M14 before i got the gun so it is legal. "

If this goes into effect, that's what i'm gonna do. for real.
 
Alex_Augmented 说:
Yes, because everyone's going to remain perfectly calm in an unknown situation :roll:

Because if they panic they deserve to be shot less? :roll:
 
Trevty 说:
Those who want a high capacity will still be able to get 'em.  It's called the black market.  Really it only hurts those who refuse to do something illegal.


dat b ilagl.
 
Burgass 说:
Trevty 说:
Those who want a high capacity will still be able to get 'em.  It's called the black market.  Really it only hurts those who refuse to do something illegal.


dat b ilagl.
It's not wrong to disobey immoral laws.  :roll:
 
Drop the weapons, get cake instead. We can all live in harmony and rape eachother peacefully. No need for no violence no more!(No no no)
SPREAD THE MESSAGE OF PEACE
 
Trevty 说:
Those who want a high capacity will still be able to get 'em.  It's called the black market.  Really it only hurts those who refuse to do something illegal.
 
后退
顶部 底部