I actually prefer spear duels in Sturgia. Because alternative is an axe that will in the hands of a lord or Veteran Warrior break your shield in no time and then it's just you and your axe against armored tank. Such axe fights in Sturgia feel like battles against the time. Very short time.
Spears on the other hand will not damage shields that fast, piercing damage is better against armor then cutting damage and you can stab those guys in to their only weak spot: their legs.
Also once you get used to it, spear fights are not all that difficult and tedious as is suggested.