JuJu70 said:
What is you archery proficiency? Damage 19 is Ok you should use 2-3 arrows to kill them.
Regardless of what real life outcome would be, we don't want it to be 1 body shot=1 killed at any level. Aim for the head, then you'll get 2x damage.
My archery proficiency is 100 . This is enough to hit then.
The problem is: the speed rating of the bows now are about 65 and the accuracy is 95 the max, so score a head shoot isn't a easy thing to achieve, but thats isn't the problem. The real problem is:
Historic accuracy: The arrows fired from a longbow(not the modern version) can hit a target from 250 yards with sufficient force to penetretate the body of someone.(I know that about the bows/arrows the initial worry is balancing, but I will just leave it here in the case someone else starts to question it.)
- Balancing: The same unity that I made the test can be killed with only one bent javelin throwed by a char with the same 7 points in the skill, but this time, in power throw.
- Logic: Doesn't makes sense a arrow cut the target when it should penetrate it. In the M&B system the best type of attack against armored enemies are: Piercing, blunt and so cutting. Thats the whole problem of the bows in this DLC, as cutting attack with high damage they are a regular/acceptable weapon against unarmored enemies and useless against enemies with a decent armor.
- Clarification: My intention with this commentary about the low damage output of the bow isn't about:"I like bow, so I want to kill everybody in one body shoot" or "I don't like throwing weapons, so I think all throwing weapons now must have 12c of Damage". My real intention is: The bow isn't created in the original MB as cutting damage because is very hard to balance it for unarmored and armored targets at the same time.
Just to remind, the majority infantry and skirmisher unities in this DLC uses shields, so you don't need to worry about get your whole troop killed by archers. Another argument is:Not even in the original Warband how the bows are strong ranged weapons you can get killed by one arrow when using heavy armors.