Gunnar11 说:
We've already lost quite a few. I'd rather them possibly come back for good melee, then never see them again.
Skipping reading the entire thread to +1 this.
And now for my two cents.
Unfortunately, the old system wont be brought back for one simple reason: Money. However derpy Napoleonic Wars' melee system is, it is also very easy for the average noob to pick up and get a couple kills with, therefore the game sells more easily. Which raises the question: What kind of community do you want for your game? A solid community of dedicated people, much like the one in Mount and Musket? Or a group of disloyal randoms who play a couple times a week for line battles and do nothing but drag their regiment down with their lack of discipline and ability? Just something to think about. I wont go on anymore however I'll simply state that I have stopped playing entirely because of the melee system in Napoleonic Wars.
Mount and Musket was the most balanced and required the most skill out of any melee system in any mod for this game, in my opinion. It also, was the most fun, even with the jump-crouch-spinning and whatnot.

I'm not sure if anyone really cares, but that's my view on the matter.
(This is also why the Marins now host an MM server.

)
Time to save up my rage for another post 3 months down the road.
Edit: Dunno if I restated anything anyone else said, as I said above I skipped reading the entire thread. If so, disregard.
