I like the feel of this mod -a lot-. I was very pleasantly surprised by how clean and organized the screens were, and even more pleased to have bumped into a fresh quest that actually had more to it than "Hey you, go kill this dude in that one village. Nobody will care."
But there were some things that took me aback.
1. Where are my female troops?
Apparently, removing the native troops also meant removing swordsisters and village women. As a female player, one of my favorite challenges (and it was a challenge, given how much weaker these troops were compared to others) was building an all-female army. You know, because crushing stuffy, chauvenistic man-pig lords with a lady army is just how I get my kicks.
If recommendations are being considered, I'd like to suggest some ideas in this regard --
Of all the 'cultures' presented in the game, the Nords seem the most likely to have female troops given that viking and nordic folklore are full of tales about shieldmaidens and Valkyries -- all of whom kick major butt or were actually leading heros. Native's "swordsisters" always felt like Swadian-styled outcasts, practically on the verge of bandit-hood (particularly given that their culture seems very masculine).
2. The treeless troop system seems far too incomplete to have been released, even for testing.
I have two primary complaints here -- and be gentle if you respond, keeping in mind I'm extremely new and I haven't found much documentation on this system besides the dev posts.
What am I supposed to use 'training' for except when buying new troops? I always used this skill, stacked with companions' use of it, to bolster my small armies and get lower-mid tier troops without having to grind. If now none of the troops learn or get better, there doesn't seem to be any reason to put points in this skill, or go out of my way to make Lezalit happy, since his [roleplaying] purpose is as a trainer and all-around whip-lasher -- if I don't intend to make him a lord, all of his points in this are just uselessness since it appears only MY training skill counts. A 2% discount per rank doesn't seem like a proper offset for the loss of this skill, nor a proper way to handle Lezalit's newfound crappiness.
I was looking through the trees and noticed that the Rhodoks and Swadians not only have the only upgrading troops, but they are also all extremely high-level troops. I'm a newbie and haven't played this mod for long, but how in the world does that pan out balance-wise in NPC-to-NPC battles? At the very least, every troop save special ones should probably have 2 or 3 tiers, to show experience. They don't have to branch or change out their equipment (unless you want to pay extra to buy all that new equipment and then maintain it), but they should be getting better.
3. I have a recommendation for an alternative way to prevent enemies from recruiting too many troops besides simply razing villages.
This might require a bit too much work, but what about the option of spreading dissension?
You could send a companion with high persuasion out on missions to a particular kingdom and they would go off and just spread ugly little rumors and encourage troublesome events like peasant and slave revolts that may prevent enemy lords from recruiting so quickly, or even may have more complex reactions like severely dropping production in towns, castles, and villages for a while, increase bandits/defecting civilians (who are aggressive to those factions, not just you), and an uptick in town patrols (taking away resources in order to deal with the unrest). Sending a companion with low persuasion will have less effect and there should always be a chance that they will get caught, earning you a loss in reputation and requiring you to go pay a ransom.
Or, you could just do it yourself, by visiting individual villages. Rather than razing them, you can camp outside the village and devote a number of days to spreading rumors. Doing so will attract the attention of the lord who owns the village though, or there's a chance that the village elder doesn't appreciate what you're trying to do and tells you to GTFO.
Edit:
Addressed here. -
Windyplains