TL
R - (Props to making the game, no props for how they plan on finishing it/addressing our concerns)
I am extremely happy that we don't have to 'wait' for the game any longer, and am super happy that they released it in EA so we could try it.
I am super unhappy about how they said the game would be, how they said they would approach the EA development, and how they actually delivered on these things.
The game in 2016 looked better than the state of what it is right now (unfortunately).
Honestly, your post is fair - but its unfair to forget the whole spectrum of events that relate to it. Props to TW for trying to do something 'good', but no props for not seeking help / addressing these major concerns (both from a development & communications point of view). I just think this has been disastrous.
I dont want to give blind optimism/congratulations to TW for clearly NOT addressing the community's concerns.