chainsawpunisher的最近内容

Guaccmoleboy 说:

While this thread has served it purpose to bring attention of developers and community to this DDoS attack, I feel as of now it only serves as a goldmine for any attention whore like Daniel Tosh. I'd suggest instead doing things now through private TS conversations and PM's on the forums/steam, and locking/deleting this so Tosh doesn't know about our plans and can't get the attention he so longingly wants.

点击展开...

Aura (Zaffa) 说:

Previous Tournament Questions​

General Tournament Questions

隐藏

1. My expectations going into the last tournament (UNAC 2), was that it was going to be:
                        A horrible experience
                        A worse than average experience
                        An average experience
                        A better than average experience
                        A great experience

2. In actuality, the last tournament (UNAC 2), was:
                        A horrible experience
                        A worse than average experience
                        An average experience
                        A better than average experience
                        A great experience

3. I think the last tournament (UNAC 2), was harmed by (choose any/all that apply):
                        The attitudes of the community
                        The teams participating in the tournament
                        The admin team (Be Specific)
                        The rule set (Be Specific)
                        Other (Be specific)

4. I think the last tournament (UNAC 2), was benefitted by (choose any/all that apply):
                        The attitudes of the community
                        The teams participating in the tournament
                        The admin team (Be Specific) Kherven seemed to me to do a solid job.
                        The rule set (Be Specific)
                        Other (Be specific)

5. To the question of whether I think someone else could have done a better job adminning the last tournament (UNAC 2), my answer is:
                      Yes (Be Specific)
                        No

No idea.

Current Tournament Questions​

General Tournament Questions

隐藏

6. My expectations going into this tournament (UNAC 3), was that it was going to be:
                        A horrible experience
                        A worse than average experience
                        An average experience
                        A better than average experience
                        A great experience

7. In actuality, this tournament (UNAC 3), was:
                        A horrible experience
                        A worse than average experience
                        An average experience
                        A better than average experience
                        A great experience

8. I think this tournament (UNAC 3), was harmed by (choose any/all that apply):
                        The attitudes of the community
                        The teams participating in the tournament
                        The admin team (Be Specific)
                        The rule set (Be Specific)
                        Other (Be specific)

The attitude of several of the teams we scrimmed was poor. We've got better things to do than be trolled on the duel to delay its beginning by non-duellists riding horses into the ring. And certainly better things to do than wait 10 minutes and then have our opponent "fail" to get their full 7 players in on the swap. As happened REPEATEDLY, against one of our opponents. A team lead by a tourney admin, no less. Disgraceful.

The unwillingness of the admin team to enforce rules was a huge problem. This flies in the face of what some others have posted, but the facts are really that the admins stopped doing their jobs to a large extent. Rules about player addition and eligibility were ignored, admins' teams personally benefited from decisions, and the whole thing became a joke. This point really would've been driven home if KoF had pulled a Deathwatch and dissolved, then all joined DoG, instead of just kidding each other about doing so. I realize the tourney admins probably would've endeavored to stop that, but that would've shown a wholly different problem. Selective enforcement is little different than non-enforcement. There must be rules of some kind, or there is chaos. And the people in authority must have the integrity to enforce them, along with the willingness to say no to participants. These qualities were lacking. UNAC 4, if there is one, will need more leadership than this.

9. I think this tournament (UNAC 3), was benefited by (choose any/all that apply):
                        The attitudes of the community
                        The teams participating in the tournament TMW, Wappaw, and GK each contributing 2 teams really helped the tournament.
                        The admin team (Be Specific)
                        The rule set (Be Specific)
                        Other (Be specific)

10. To the question of whether I think someone else could have done a better job adminning this tournament (UNAC 3), my answer is:
                      Yes (Be Specific)
                        No

I did not see anyone besides Zaffa with the fortitude and willingness to put in the time and effort required. Doesn't mean they weren't there (for instance, I do not know Eternal), but it sure seemed like the tourney was in bad shape even before it began, when William had to resign. However, Zaffa lacked the respect of a significant segment of the constituent community, and was effectively undermined due to this by mid tournament. Ultimately, this meant the job wasn't fully done. Anyone in authority needs both competence and respect to accomplish objectives. Could someone else have done a better job? I am unaware of a feasible person who could've combined both competence and respect. Doesn't mean they weren't there. So, the answer is, your guess is as good as mine.

Future Tournament Questions​

Specific, Rule Related Questions

隐藏

11. Tournament matches should be played between:
                        Monday to Sunday
                        Wednesday to Tuesday
                        Some other time (Be Specific)

Don't care, weekends have almost always worked best.

12. If future tournaments keep the round robin -> single elimination system, teams should be able to add players to their team (who haven't already been on a team) until:
                        Two weeks into the tournament
                        The round robin is over
                        Some other time (Be specific)
                       

13. If future tournaments keep the round robin -> single elimination system, teams should be able to trade players to their team (who have already been on a team) until:
                        Two weeks into the tournament
                        The round robin is over
                        Some other time (Be specific)

14. In the case of spectators, they should be:
                        Locked to team member
                        Locked to team member view
                        Free

Up to the captains involved.
                                                 
15. As to who should be able to spectate a match,:
                      Everyone should be allowed.
                        Only streamers and participants should be allowed.
                        Only participants should be allowed.
                        Other

Up to the captains involved.

16. The next tournament should have:
                      Random Divisions
                        Divisions based off seeding (UNAC 2)
                        Divisions divided equally based off seeding (UNAC 3)
                        No Divisions
                        Other (Be specific)

17. The format of the next tournament should be:
                      Pure Round Robin
                        Round Robin - > Single Elimination (UNAC 1/2/3)
                        Single Elimination
                        Double Elimination
                        Ladder / Swiss system
                        Other (Be specific)

18. The person(s) that should determine the map pool for the next tournament should be:
                      The admin team
                        Team captains
                        Other (Be specific)

As fun as multiple multi-hour meetings which may or may not decide anything in the end are, I'd just like those in charge to have a firm grip. This would require the captains to choose someone competent and respected.

19. The maps for each week should be chosen by:
                      Pre-set fixtures (UNAC 3)
                        Weekly Map Pools (UNAC 1/2)
                        Elimination-Map-Pool*                              *A team can only pick the same map so many times
                        Other (Be specific)

20. The factions for each week should be chosen by:
                      Pre-set fixtures
                        Free selection
                        Other (Be specific)

点击展开...