Have my comments as I re-read the thread.
Up to page 10:
I have very strong innocent vibes from SootShade and Dago. They're sparring but I think it is two innocents wasting their time on each other.
@Soot comment on me being a lurker wolf:
I lurked last game I played in and I was innocent. I am lurking now. My lurking behavior has everything to do with how much time I have and nothing to do with my alignment. I love Werewolf. If I'm an innocent, I like thinking of what packs exist and how dynamics between players can give away who is evil. If I'm a wolf, I like to pretend to do the same. I'm sure there's things that give me away as a wolf in the games where I am a wolf, but lurkishness is not one of them.
Boo Soot and archer, you both know nothing and one of you is probably a wolf. I’d bet archer.
Scummy post. Setting up dichotomies makes it very easy for wolves to narrow down two innocents to lynch. Especially when there is no sensible reason for them.
Soot why don’t we compromise and lynch Brutus?
Moose! wolf confirmed. Thanks for sticking up for me on my birthday, but it makes you no less hairy.
Alright, I'll bite. Soot calls me out for wanting to wait to hear from the lurkers, Daho calls me out for not doing any hunting. I provide a basic los, and some ideas as to where the wolves might be, and yet I'm the wolf? My votes, other than my joke vote on jock, were for Marowit (which I screwed up), Xardob, and Doge, who have all been lurking, in an attempt to draw them into the game.
I said that I don't yet have a read on any of the vocal players besides moose, whom I still have as innocent, but I know y'all will give me more to go on in the later game than a lurker will. It's easier for a vocal wolf to get away if there's a bunch of lurkers in late game, or at least that's how I see it.
Other than me, which non-lurkers do you have a read on? If you answer none, than I'm going o have to move you (soot) up my list.
Trademark wolf post - "I am voting on pointless people who are barely reading the thread so they play" makes ****all sense but at the same time I'm getting serious innocent vibes.
@Soot on lynching lurkers:
Stop making so much sense.
Vieira's post on page 14 is scummy as hell, but I think Vieira is a wolf every game and I'm always wrong.
Xardob's post on page 15 is so flimsy... So is Jock's...
Bunch of "do we vote lurkers or not" discussion. I think it's an interesting talk; I think trying to draw allegiances based on where people fall on this argument is useless. Sootshade and I seem to be in agreement here.
Rocco is giving me villainous vibes. Nonsense posts with low-effort hunting when the pressure is on is not an indicator of being innocent.
Moose!'s LoS makes no sense. Would vote Brutus for being scummy? For what? Roleplaying? The arguments just don't make sense at any point. It feels like he's pretending so hard.
Crassius's post is even worse. Xardob as the most likely spy? Based on what evidence? The fact Rocco agrees with it does not help the point at all..
Eternal blatantly lying about posting an LoS is terrible.
Dago *****ing about nobody hunting makes me fairly certain he's an innocent. Arch3r makes some very strange accusations against him.
Brutus dives on Xardob. Again, none of these anti-Xardob posts make sense to me. He's made one post where he seemed worn out. Really not worth the lynch. Brutus then dives on me, despite the fact he seemed to approve of the one post I've made up to this point. What the hell?
Rocco thinks Dago is a good "compromise vote".... aghhh! He's trying the hardest in the entire game! Why would wolves stick their necks out when nothing is going on?
Rocco posts an LoS and I think I have the exact opposite read on every single player.
Jock posts some wishy-washy garbage.
Haha what the **** did Xardob do? Why shoot Brutus of all people? I guess it makes sense - I would've done the same since I have no read on Brutus at all. But ballsy.
Moose! and Dago start to lock horns, interesting.
Arch3r thinking everyone is a special is BIG. Means he's a special.
Bunch of stats talk. I can only get so aroused.
Rocco really wants me dead, alright alright.
Moose! wanting Arch3r dead... ugh...
Rocco and Jock jumping on that wagon makes me suspicious too.
Holy **** that Crassius low-effort "I agree with Moose" bandwagon vote.
Soot reluctantly dove on it..
**** I feel so bad for not existing last turn. There's no chance I would have voted for Arch3r after his "I think everyone is a special" comment. Goddamnit. I know it sounds like horse**** since I'm posting day 2 after knowing the outcome, but gah.
People seem to want to lynch me day 2. I don't even blame you.
Vieira is a strange night kill. There's no information there. Vieira just kind of did ****all.
Moose! turns on Soot, interesting.
Crassius's "I told you so" after jumping on the wagon... ooooof. So scummy.
Bunch of meaningless Brutus back-and-forth.
Mostly nonsense speculation after that. Arch3r already gave away the 'everyone is specials' top secret. No point in going on about it.
Good post by Sootshade with a bizarre conclusion. You can't make up logic to support your gut feeling of wanting to lynch me lol.