North American Player Ratings (New Fun Poll Up!)

What has been your favorite experience in NA history?

  • The United North American Championship tournaments? (God that name is terrible)

    Votes: 16 13.3%
  • The more serious Warband Pro League Tournaments?

    Votes: 20 16.7%
  • The semi successful and mostly failed Scramble and Draft League tournaments?

    Votes: 13 10.8%
  • POM, NA_Battlefield, tK_Battlefield pub battle servers?

    Votes: 27 22.5%
  • Pickup parties and the now three year running RaT Parties?

    Votes: 21 17.5%
  • Watching wK get knocked out of the playoffs by KoA who then proceeded to get demolished?

    Votes: 12 10.0%
  • Watching OE win a tournament and never being able to forget it because they mention it every other w

    Votes: 17 14.2%
  • Watching Gorlock run into a tree in a live stream in a final match?

    Votes: 26 21.7%
  • The previous 100+ page NA Hall of Fame thread drama?

    Votes: 14 11.7%
  • Bladecast TV bringing better quality streams to NA and then ditching us for EU?

    Votes: 14 11.7%
  • Sitting in teamspeak with the tK's while trying to play and not go deaf?

    Votes: 16 13.3%
  • KoB blowing an easy 3-0 set over wK by dying on the flag with seconds left?

    Votes: 9 7.5%
  • TMW never being able to win a tournament that they played wK in?

    Votes: 8 6.7%
  • Watching team NA get screwed by the NC staff every single NC tournament in some different way? (Blue

    Votes: 15 12.5%
  • Playing Grimsight's glitchy matchmaking service or that other foreign one?

    Votes: 13 10.8%
  • NA vs EU forum banter?

    Votes: 29 24.2%
  • Watching wK win every tournament and being smug about it?

    Votes: 10 8.3%
  • Listening to the Wappaws complain about medium speed?

    Votes: 12 10.0%
  • Listening to John's terrible taco references?

    Votes: 9 7.5%
  • Getting yelled at by Oodle for doing something wrong?

    Votes: 24 20.0%

  • Total voters
    120

Users who are viewing this thread

Roberta

Master Knight
Player Ratings



2013 (The Dawn)
First off, welcome to my list that I promised Marnid many many months ago. After much thought and consideration I decided to revamp my old list which still stands as one of the most debated creation's on the forums. This new list is pretty straight forward and easy to understand with the exception of the *'s. When you see these next to a player's name it means they were on the list the previous era. I started off with 2013 due to the low quality stat keeping and poor thread maintenance that prior tournaments utilized. The United North American Championship was the first massively organized tournament in North American history and it began a trend of seasonal tournaments for many years. It was considered the ultimate tournament victory until the creation of Warband Pro League much later in NA's history. This particular year lead to the decline of some of the older clans that had dominated the scene earlier and lead to the exit of Black Shields after their final loss to West Knights. With a victory over Black Shields in the finals of UNAC S1, West Knights would go on to establish a dominance over the NA scene that has never been seen since. This year also saw notable North American Hall of Fame player, Oodle, get his start. After a great performance that placed him in the upper tiers of infantry players in UNAC S1, Oodle would go on to become the most dominant player to ever play in North American history. Other notable things you will see here is that I decided to go with Leroux for the top archer spot. He dominated in UNAC S1 and while Lagstro is a household name now he was not yet the same ultimate force he is known to be today. Calamity also set the record for kills in this tournament; although it was also the longest tournament in NA history.​


Infantry
  • 591FOng.png
    Kherven
  • 591FOng.png
    Beer
  • 591FOng.png
    Joe
  • 591FOng.png
    Unicorn
  • 591FOng.png
    Tyrian
  • 591FOng.png
    PPK157
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Oodle
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Craven
  • United-Kingdom.png
    Deacon
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Cradoc
  • United-Kingdom.png
    Cleric
  • United-Kingdom.png
    M
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Juve
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Mok
  • 591FOng.png
    Mad Dawg


Archers
  • Belgium.png
    Leroux
  • 591FOng.png
    Achilles
  • FCHj1YJ.png
    Lagstro
  • 591FOng.png
    Rurin
  • 591FOng.png
    RobertBruce
  • 591FOng.png
    Clockwise
  • 591FOng.png
    Harn
  • 591FOng.png
    Fritigern
  • 591FOng.png
    Zero
  • 591FOng.png
    African
  • 591FOng.png
    Zacty
  • Finland.png
    SotaMursu
  • 591FOng.png
    Peasant
  • 591FOng.png
    John
  • 591FOng.png
    CheesePizza


Cavalry
  • 591FOng.png
    Calamity
  • 591FOng.png
    Redknight
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Gelden
  • United-Kingdom.png
    Blacktide
  • 591FOng.png
    Blade
  • Sweden.png
    Shemaforash
  • 591FOng.png
    ScottRay
  • 591FOng.png
    WilySly
  • 591FOng.png
    Ron Burgundy
  • 591FOng.png
    Blak
  • 591FOng.png
    Vanidar
  • 591FOng.png
    Rhade
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Greenknight
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Rallix
  • 591FOng.png
    Brave

5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png
5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png
5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png



2014 (The Rise)
2014 saw the continuance of West Knights dominance over the North American field. Outside of one fluke loss that left them squabbling in third place; they proved to be the top team once again in this era of play. The Midnight Watchmen, another one of the old guards, was the chief competitor to the West Knights but they did not offer much in terms of competition until UNAC S3 when they defeated KoA to claim the gold medal. 2014 also brought a new style of cavalry play to North America. Cavalry became the most dominant force in the game and future Hall of Famer, Cru, got his start in this time period. Other cavalry greats such as Vinnypooh and Can also made it to the top of the ratings for the first time as they made a name for themselves in the three UNAC tournaments that took place in 2014. 2014 was host to more tournaments than any other time period in NA history and the player base grew to a massive level for NA standards. Many of the famous "new" players also got their start this era. That list includes greats such as Tito, PolarBear, Dodge, Creed, and most importantly Cav Jeffrey.​


Infantry
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Oodle **
  • 591FOng.png
    PPK157 **
  • 591FOng.png
    Unicorn **
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Mok **
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Dman
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Ghaern
  • 591FOng.png
    Kelquethas
  • PsFDpYX.png
    PolarBear
  • 591FOng.png
    Troubadour
  • 591FOng.png
    Tito
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Cradoc **
  • 591FOng.png
    Dodge
  • 591FOng.png
    CheesePizza **
  • 591FOng.png
    Arys
  • 591FOng.png
    Creed


Archers
  • FCHj1YJ.png
    Lagstro **
  • 591FOng.png
    Achilles **
  • 591FOng.png
    John **
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Chewbacca
  • Finland.png
    SotaMursu **
  • 6hLMowf.png
    Rayden
  • 591FOng.png
    Rurin **
  • 591FOng.png
    Rhadagast
  • 591FOng.png
    PhoenixGold
  • 591FOng.png
    DeathAngel
  • 591FOng.png
    Clockwise **
  • 591FOng.png
    Peasant **
  • 591FOng.png
    Zero **
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Juve **
  • 591FOng.png
    Quantum Matrix


Cavalry
  • 591FOng.png
    Calamity **
  • 591FOng.png
    Vinnypooh
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Gelden **
  • 591FOng.png
    Cru
  • 6hLMowf.png
    Can
  • United-Kingdom.png
    Blacktide **
  • 6hLMowf.png
    Sikici
  • 591FOng.png
    Brave **
  • 591FOng.png
    Insane
  • 591FOng.png
    CheesePIzza **
  • 591FOng.png
    Mad Dawg **
  • Finland.png
    Varangian
  • 591FOng.png
    Hero
  • 591FOng.png
    WilySly **
  • 591FOng.png
    Clockwise

5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png
5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png
5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png



2015 (The Peak)
In terms of skill level, 2015 brought about the peak of North American players. While the peak of the top teams increased, the skill disparity between teams increased even more so. With 2015 also came the beginning of the super teams, an issue that would continue throughout the rest of NA history. The almighty Reign E-Sports was founded and unfounded after a disaterous attempt to combine great players from multiple teams together to win prize mousepads from Arys. On the opposite end of the spectrum, Kingdom of Blacktide formed and absolutely dominated all competition to the point of being unfun. UNAC S5 remained as competitive as ever but players were still wanting more. Arys took it upon himself to create a tournament that had never been attempted before. The Warband Pro League was the most important tournament in NA history. It catered to both EU and NA and had more teams entered than any previous NA attempt. Knights of the Bound attempted to unseat the mighty West Knights from their throne of winning but in the end the West Knights and all their rustiness took the title and established themselves once again the kings of North America. Most people can still remember the clutch shots of Achilles that sealed the deal.​


Infantry
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Oodle ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Tito **
  • Russian-Federation.png
    Arni
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Aporta
  • 591FOng.png
    Kelquethas **
  • Russian-Federation.png
    Rempica
  • 6hLMowf.png
    Napolean
  • 591FOng.png
    PPK157 ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Troubadour **
  • 591FOng.png
    Zaffa
  • 591FOng.png
    Arys **
  • Germany.png
    Scar
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Cradoc ***
  • France.png
    Brian
  • 591FOng.png
    Danate


Archers
  • 6hLMowf.png
    Menethil
  • Belgium.png
    Leroux **
  • 591FOng.png
    Achilles ***
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Chewbacca **
  • 591FOng.png
    Jeffrey9792
  • FCHj1YJ.png
    Lagstro ***
  • Russian-Federation.png
    Bendetto
  • 6hLMowf.png
    Rayden **
  • 591FOng.png
    John ***
  • Finland.png
    SotaMursu ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Chev
  • 591FOng.png
    RobertBruce **
  • 591FOng.png
    Clockwise ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Marquis
  • 591FOng.png
    Ebdanian


Cavalry
  • 6hLMowf.png
    Can **
  • 591FOng.png
    Vinnypooh **
  • 591FOng.png
    Cru **
  • United-Kingdom.png
    Blacktide ***
  • France.png
    Peter
  • 6hLMowf.png
    Sikici **
  • 591FOng.png
    Calamity ***
  • Czech-Republic.png
    Relaks
  • 591FOng.png
    Heat
  • 591FOng.png
    PPK157 ***
  • United-Kingdom.png
    Shingen
  • 591FOng.png
    Insane **
  • 591FOng.png
    Red
  • Germany.png
    Firunien
  • 591FOng.png
    CheesePizza***

5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png
5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png
5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png



2016-2017 (The Twilight)
As NA entered the 2016 season and 2017 seasons, the time of serious competitive play had began to fade. There were two major tournaments in these years, UNAC S6 and WPL S2. UNAC S6 saw the Turtle Knights win their first major after several years of attempts. They vanquished the mighty Septic Justice Warriors in the finals after a painstakingly long match with two overtimes. This was the only major tournament in which my own team placed with RaTs taking the bronze medal after an OE forfeit. After UNAC S6, pickup parties became the new primary form of practice and Guaccmoleboy handed the reigns over to myself and RaT parties were formed. In all we hosted over 300 different pickup parties in this two year span and recorded stats for fun from most of the matches. Jeffrey9792, Tito and Lagstro were the top performers. After a short hiatus, Arys announced the return of WPL and with it a whole new level of tournament play. He promised new prizes, a NA vs EU final bracket and many more things that never appeared as NA settled in for it's final tournament. After a very disapointing UNAC S6 appearance, One Eyed threw out it's old duel kids and replaced them with all star talent and won the major over wK. Turtle Knights claimed the bronze medal after defeating a bunch of old Balions rather handedly. With these results the final major tournament in NA was finished and the community would slowly begin to die down from here on out. This era should most be remembered by the intense rivalry matches between tK, wK and OE.​


Infantry
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Oodle ****
  • 591FOng.png
    Tito ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Vorn
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Aporta **
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Guaccmoleboy
  • 591FOng.png
    Kelquethas ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Danate **
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Cradoc ****
  • 591FOng.png
    PPK157 ****
  • 591FOng.png
    Arys ***
  • 591FOng.png
    CheesePizza ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Troubadour ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Creed **
  • 591FOng.png
    Tyrian **
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Magerick


Archers
  • FCHj1YJ.png
    Lagstro ****
  • 591FOng.png
    Jeffrey9792 **
  • 591FOng.png
    Achilles ****
  • 591FOng.png
    John ****
  • Finland.png
    SotaMursu ****
  • 591FOng.png
    DeathAngel
  • 6hLMowf.png
    Rayden ***
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Oodle ****
  • 591FOng.png
    Ebdanian **
  • 591FOng.png
    Matthew
  • 591FOng.png
    RobertBruce ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Rhadagast **
  • United-Kingdom.png
    Pepper
  • 591FOng.png
    Cru ***
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Juve ***


Cavalry
  • 591FOng.png
    Heat **
  • 6hLMowf.png
    Can ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Cru ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Insane ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Gorlock
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Thunderbeu
  • Sweden.png
    Shemaforash **
  • 591FOng.png
    Brave ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Tito ***
  • 591FOng.png
    PPK157 ****
  • 591FOng.png
    Calamity ****
  • United-Kingdom.png
    Blacktide ****
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Aporta **
  • 591FOng.png
    Alejanbro
  • 591FOng.png
    CheesePizza ****

5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png
5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png
5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png



2018-2019 (The Death)
There were no major tournaments held in 2018 or 2019 in North America. Several small tournaments were hosted such as Warband Fantasy League and other small multi week tournaments that usually failed to finish or had several teams drop out. Competitive play for the most part was left to pickup parties and matchmaking. While the overall skill level dropped drastically compared to latter years, there were several names that made note. Yoshie, Alyss and Easter Cow. Had they started their Warband careers earlier they may have made an impact on the scene but unfortunately for them they did not. Therefore despite their dominance the past year in the scene they will be left off the 'All Time' List until they can claim more fake internet points.​


Infantry
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Aporta ***
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Guaccmoleboy **
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Nikkle
  • Russian-Federation.png
    Rempica (USA) **
  • United-Kingdom.png
    Gibby
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Yoshie
  • 591FOng.png
    Abellard
  • 591FOng.png
    Vorn **
  • 591FOng.png
    PPK157 *****
  • 591FOng.png
    Kelquethas ****
  • 591FOng.png
    Danate ***
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Magerick **
  • France.png
    Alyss (USA)
  • 591FOng.png
    Daemon
  • 591FOng.png
    Marquis **


Archers
  • 6hLMowf.png
    Menethil (USA)
  • FCHj1YJ.png
    Lagstro *****
  • France.png
    Alyss (USA)
  • 591FOng.png
    Jeffrey9792 ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Ebdanian **
  • 591FOng.png
    Zacty **
  • Netherlands.png
    Kane
  • 591FOng.png
    John *****
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Aporta ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Achilles *****
  • United-Kingdom.png
    Jarvis
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Ummmmmmmidk
  • 591FOng.png
    Sitvek
  • 591FOng.png
    Kelquethas ****
  • 591FOng.png
    Marquis **


Cavalry
  • Netherlands.png
    Ciiges
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Aporta ***
  • 591FOng.png
    Easter Cow
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Yoshie
  • 591FOng.png
    Heat ***
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Thunderbeu **
  • United-Kingdom.png
    Gibby
  • 591FOng.png
    Serj
  • 591FOng.png
    Gorlock **
  • 591FOng.png
    PPK157 *****
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Nikkle
  • France.png
    Alyss (USA)
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Guaccmoleboy **
  • 591FOng.png
    Ron Burgundy **
  • 591FOng.png
    Danate***

5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png
5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png
5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png


National Dream Team's


Canada
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Oodle
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Guaccmoleboy
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Mok
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Craven
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Cradoc
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Aporta
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Gelden
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Yoshie
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Thunderbeu
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Chewbacca
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Juve
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Ummmmmmmidk


North America
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Oodle
  • 591FOng.png
    Tito
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Aporta
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Guaccmoleboy
  • 591FOng.png
    PPK157
  • 591FOng.png
    Vinnypooh
  • 591FOng.png
    Cru
  • 591FOng.png
    Can
  • 591FOng.png
    Heat
  • 591FOng.png
    Lagstro
  • 591FOng.png
    Achilles
  • 591FOng.png
    Jeffrey9792


United States of America
  • 591FOng.png
    Tito
  • 591FOng.png
    PPK157
  • 591FOng.png
    Vorn
  • 591FOng.png
    Kelquethas
  • 591FOng.png
    Unicorn
  • 591FOng.png
    Vinnypooh
  • 591FOng.png
    Cru
  • 591FOng.png
    Heat
  • 591FOng.png
    Calamity
  • 591FOng.png
    Achilles
  • 591FOng.png
    Jeffrey9792
  • 591FOng.png
    John

5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png
5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png
5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png



Top Players of All Time
Rating players is obviously a very subjective process. It's impossible to not show bias when compiling a list of players that have played for the past seven years. I first used stats and focused on the kill death ratio from past tournaments to get my list of players for each category. It took many hours to get the stats together and unfortunately most of them are incomplete due to user errors. Once I did that I tossed out the names that were obvious flukes (sorry) and then divided each era and assigned point values to each. Players that played from 2015 to 2017 were given the most value. This is due to the decreased level of play and competitiveness in the prior and following years. Another important factor was that NA changed fighting speed in 2015 and many previously great players hit a major cliff and fell down in the charts. Overall this is one of my first attempts at a list that truly combines stats with the "eye test". I decided to forego numbers and went for a more cleaner aesthetic.​


Infantry
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Oodle
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    Tito
    xpZG64X.png
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Aporta
    xpZG64X.png
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Guaccmoleboy
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    PPK157
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    Vorn
    xpZG64X.png
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Mok
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    Unicorn
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    Kherven
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    Kelquethas
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Nikkle
  • 591FOng.png
    Troubadour
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Cradoc
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    Tyrian
  • 591FOng.png
    Joe


Archers
  • FCHj1YJ.png
    Lagstro
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    Achilles
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    Jeffrey9792
    xpZG64X.png
  • 6hLMowf.png
    Menethil
    xpZG64X.png
  • Belgium.png
    Leroux
  • 591FOng.png
    John
  • France.png
    Alyss (USA)
  • 591FOng.png
    Ebdanian
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Chewbacca
  • Finland.png
    SotaMursu
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 6hLMowf.png
    Rayden
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    Rurin
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    RobertBruce
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    Clockwise
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    DeathAngel


Cavalry
  • 591FOng.png
    Vinnypooh
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    Cru
    xpZG64X.png
  • 6hLMowf.png
    Can
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    Heat
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    Calamity
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Aporta
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    PPK157
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    Insane
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • Netherlands.png
    Ciiges
    xpZG64X.png
  • Sweden.png
    Shemaforash
    xpZG64X.png
  • 591FOng.png
    Gorlock
    xpZG64X.png
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Gelden 
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • United-Kingdom.png
    Blacktide
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • 6hLMowf.png
    Sikici
    xpZG64X.png
    xpZG64X.png
  • PsFDpYX.png
    Thunderbeu
    xpZG64X.png

5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png
5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png
5621140148_36b6ed98d2_o.png

 
if unac s5 counts as a dub then NASS counts because unac5 was easily the least competitive tournament in NA and crb today was better than sjw in unac6

yeah the bottom tier teams dropped but the competition between gkoa, my team, and crb was definitely there
 
I feel like some the EUs shouldn't be on the list solely because they are more EU oriented than they ever were NA.

NA list should be only people from the North American continent, unless you played in a clan and in tournaments with them for more than year. Sota as an example.

Also this is possibly one of the best polls NA lol
 
Back
Top Bottom