[BCM] Group Stage Results - BLUE DIVISION

Users who are viewing this thread

imemine said:
Considering the multiple violations of the tournament rules by Back 2 Main Menu  (see post above) all rounds in which B2MM_Thomena played have been counted in favour of Friendship Ends Gardaşlık Never. Consequently, the final result of the match Friendship Ends Gardaşlık Never vs Back 2 Main Menu is adjusted to 12 - 1!

Back 2 Main Menu please contact an admin to clarify your roster issues before your next match!


So we won, why dont publish the match on forum?
 
Gibby Jr said:
Group: I
Round: 1
Date & Time: 21:00 BST
Server: BCMasters_DE_3
Teams involved: The Senate vs Highest Virtue
Result: Highest Virtue 12 - 1 The Senate

Screenshots:
Map A Set 1:
CAED548D5D5794E31BA8CCCAE9B3E1B2F5463221

Map A Set 2:
A65982D321057E1A7224227318865AB18E9B9DA1

Map B Set 1:
C590B9A65FA4CAA0143AEB5322C84E8227FC8336

Map B Set 2:
9F98CA9EC24AEA54512CAD890D0C4E0A798D9411


Printed IDs:
iA0FR6r.jpg

WeTheGod and zAnger are not on the HV roster but did not play and were given permission by Senate to spectate.


Player names and IDs verified.
Note: Players who are just spectating the match and are not on a team's roster, should not wear the tag of either team playing in the match to avoid any confusions.



Thorin said:
...
So we won, why dont publish the match on forum?

The result is final and will be added with the next update of the tables.
 
Demon's said:
Highest Virtue 12:1 Black Kingdoms
https://imgur.com/a/dX7tQdB
we played on De_3
Group: I
Round: III
Date & Time: 8.21.18 20.00 bst
Server: BCM_DE_3
Teams involved: Highest Virtue vs Black Kingdoms
Result: Highest Virtue 12:1 Black Kingdoms

Screenshots:
https://imgur.com/a/dX7tQdB

Approved spectator list: nop
 
Thorin said:
So we won, why dont publish the match on forum?
Because I had a lot of fires to put out yesterday. :razz: I'm doing a match results update for both divisions now.

Demon's said:
Highest Virtue 12:1 Black Kingdoms
https://imgur.com/a/dX7tQdB
we played on De_3
Unless you have a screenshot of all player IDs, we'll have to wait until we have access to server logs to verify your result.
 
Black Dead said:
Demon's said:
Highest Virtue 12:1 Black Kingdoms
https://imgur.com/a/dX7tQdB
we played on De_3
Group: I
Round: III
Date & Time: 8.21.18 20.00 bst
Server: BCM_DE_3
Teams involved: Highest Virtue vs Black Kingdoms
Result: Highest Virtue 12:1 Black Kingdoms

Screenshots:
https://imgur.com/a/dX7tQdB

Approved spectator list: nop

Player names and IDs verified.
Warnings:
Black_Ram is an unacceptable variation of the name Black_Trillram which is listed on the roster.
Black_CyltanCyleimanXan is an unacceptable variation of the name Black_SultanSuleimanHazretleri which is listed on the roster.
Black_Kappa  is an unacceptable variation of the name  Black_vladokalepaty which is listed on the roster.

Follow the guidelines here for acceptable variations of player names.

§ 13 Player Names, Tags, and IDs

(1) Players must play with the name they are signed up under in the team roster. This follows the three strike policy (warning, one-match ban, ejection).
 
Nevino said:
GARDAS 11-7 TCB

4HDeBBm.jpg

5Pta4CW.jpg

B17VtQF.jpg

pCVnmB2.jpg

QS93WUP.jpg

Ncep58I.jpg


(3) Matches should be played 8vs8. Teams must field 8 players before the match starts or forfeit the match. Teams are obligated to begin each round with the same number of players. If a player has crashed, a team is allowed to start a round with 7 players. In the event that a team has fewer than 7 players at the beginning of a round, they will forfeit the remainder of the set. If they cannot find a substitute within the minimum 5 minute wait time between sets, then they will forfeit the match.

According to this rule, the opposing party did not reduce the number to 7 in any way
We played about 1-2 sets of 7 people and the other side did not obey this rule, and what would happen in this case if we did not want to play the game in France?

And Im sry for google translate :razz:
 
Pretty sure that rule doesn't say the other team has to match your numbers. It says teams are obligated to play the same number at the beginning of the match, that number being 8.
 
Kiano said:
Pretty sure that rule doesn't say the other team has to match your numbers. It says teams are obligated to play the same number at the beginning of the match, that number being 8.

That is also how I understand it. Best is to wait for Orion/Imemine to clarify.
 
Kiano said:
Pretty sure that rule doesn't say the other team has to match your numbers. It says teams are obligated to play the same number at the beginning of the match, that number being 8.

That's actually just what it says.
Teams are obligated to begin each round with the same number of players.
Matches must start 8v8, but can continue & finish 7v7 if needed. Teams must match at the beginning of each round (i.e. you don't have to drop someone in the middle of a round because an opposing player crashed in that round).

See here: https://forums.taleworlds.com/index.php/topic,378869.0.html
 
Maybe I should rephrase. In Thorin's case, the other team is the team that had 8. If one team has 8 players, they shouldn't be obligated to match another which has 7 right?

If teams must mach at the beginning of each round, does that mean if a team drops a player, the other team isn't obligated to drop a player that round, but must drop a player the next round to ensure team numbers match at the beginning of the next round?
 
Group: ONE
Round: ONE
Date & Time: Began around 19:30bst 24.08.2018
Server: BCMastersOasisDE4
Teams involved: Knights of Malta vs Fallen Pride 2
Result: 12 - 0

Screenshots:
Map A Set 1:
42NMffR.jpg

Map A Set 2:
FYSfVS8.jpg

Map B Set 1:
bo6cDwq.jpg

Map B Set 2:
ajp6cCC.jpg


Printed IDs:
9uknZQ7.jpg

Approved spectator list:
Impheatus
Virus

PS:
Fixing the code would help, there are some rhombs missing and it just looks confusing when everything is bold :wink:
 
Kiano said:
Maybe I should rephrase. In Thorin's case, the other team is the team that had 8. If one team has 8 players, they shouldn't be obligated to match another which has 7 right?

If teams must mach at the beginning of each round, does that mean if a team drops a player, the other team isn't obligated to drop a player that round, but must drop a player the next round to ensure team numbers match at the beginning of the next round?
The rule of thumb is that teams must always start rounds, sets, and matches with the same number of players. If one team has 8, the other team should have 8. If one team has 7, then the other team should have 7.

Specifically, matches must start 8vs8. It's possible for a player to drop unexpectedly after a match has started, reducing a team to 7 players. If that player cannot rejoin before the start of the next round and the team doesn't have another player ready to take their place, then their opponent must sit a player to make the next round after the drop start 7vs7. A team with 6 or fewer players at the start of a round will forfeit the rest of the set, and gets a minimum of 5 minutes to find a 7th player to continue playing. If they can't get back to minimum 7 players, then the rest of the match can be claimed by their opponent as default.

The administration will consult with the referee who was present and review match logs to decide what will be done in the case of Gardas vs. TCB.


Habrak said:
PS:
Fixing the code would help, there are some rhombs missing and it just looks confusing when everything is bold :wink:
Thanks! Fixed in both division threads.

Verifying IDs for Friendship Ends Gardaşlık Never vs Polska Sila & Knights of Malta vs Fallen Pride 2, then updating the scores.
 
Habrak said:
Group: ONE
Round: ONE
Date & Time: Began around 19:30bst 24.08.2018
Server: BCMastersOasisDE4
Teams involved: Knights of Malta vs Fallen Pride 2
Result: 12 - 0

Screenshots:
Map A Set 1:
42NMffR.jpg

Map A Set 2:
FYSfVS8.jpg

Map B Set 1:
bo6cDwq.jpg

Map B Set 2:
ajp6cCC.jpg


Printed IDs:
9uknZQ7.jpg

Approved spectator list:
Impheatus
Virus
Player names and IDs verified.
Warnings:
FP2_MiStChEmFeN is an unacceptable variation of the name FP2_Moustache which is listed on the roster.
FP2_Feodras is an unacceptable variation of the name FP2_EnverPasa which is listed on the roster.



Thorin said:
Group:GROUP II
Round:ROUND II
Date & Time:24.08.2018  22.30-23.30
Server:BCM_DE1
Teams involved: Friendship Ends Gardaşlık Never vs Polska Sila
Result: GARDAS 8-7 KoH

Screenshots:
Map A Set 1:
r1v6rV.jpg

Map A Set 2:
k6RGoy.jpg

Map B Set 1:
vP7X1m.jpg

Map B Set 2:
WDRgMP.jpg


Printed IDs:
moZ4YY.jpg
I can't see your screenshots. Please host them on a different site. Thanks!



Regarding the Gardas vs. TCB incident, the administration has decided that the reported score is final. This decision was made after discussing the situation with the referee and reviewing the server logs, where we saw the referee asked Gardas if their 8th player would return & Gardas replied that they were ready to continue without him. It would seem from the logs that both teams were willing to play in this manner. The referee should have informed TCB to sit a player, but a misunderstanding of the rules led to the final set being played 8vs7. We are taking steps to ensure our referees properly enforce this rule in the future. It is recommended for all teams to be vigilant during their matches, and to immediately note suspected rule violations in the server during the match.
 
Orion said:
Habrak said:
Group: ONE
Round: ONE
Date & Time: Began around 19:30bst 24.08.2018
Server: BCMastersOasisDE4
Teams involved: Knights of Malta vs Fallen Pride 2
Result: 12 - 0

Screenshots:
Map A Set 1:
42NMffR.jpg

Map A Set 2:
FYSfVS8.jpg

Map B Set 1:
bo6cDwq.jpg

Map B Set 2:
ajp6cCC.jpg


Printed IDs:
9uknZQ7.jpg

Approved spectator list:
Impheatus
Virus
Player names and IDs verified.
Warnings:
FP2_MiStChEmFeN is an unacceptable variation of the name FP2_Moustache which is listed on the roster.
FP2_Feodras is an unacceptable variation of the name FP2_EnverPasa which is listed on the roster.

Flaviuss said:
TEAM: Fallen Pride 2
ADDITION:
Feodras2915278
REMOVAL:
AchillesID

We have not played yet, and this is the emergency sub
??
 
Back
Top Bottom