Largest Stable Companion parties chart please?

Users who are viewing this thread

Many thanks both!

Great news on the code release and that there is another companion I can recruit :smile:
 
Relationships based on first released Source Code:

CharacterLikeDislikeDislike
AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBeda
AilchuAgathinosCeawlinBrunhild
AsbjornBodoAgathinosReginhard
BedaAgathinosSolveigEgil
BodoBedaHelgiSolveig
BrunhildClovisReginhardAilchu
CaioEgilBedaDwywei
CeawlinSolveigAilchuDonnchadh
ClovisBrunhildEgilHelgi
DonnchadhMorgantDwyweiCeawlin
DwyweiBedaDonnchadhCaio
EgilReginhardClovisMorgant
HelgiReginhardEgilClovis
MorgantDonnchadhSolveigEgil
ReginhardHelgiBrunhildAsbjorn
SolveigBrunhildReginhardEgil
 
Ivan Khan said:
Relationships based on first released Source Code:

this information is not savegame compatible, which means that it may vary depending on which version you started your current savegame (1.0, 1.04, 2.0, etc). Just in case someone sees weird interactions on their game :wink:
 
Also, from the First source Code, there Right to Rule Opponent:

SupporterObjects
-
AsbjornBeda
BedaAsbjorn
-
CaioClovis
ClovisCaio
-
MorgantBrunhild
ReginhardMorgant
BrunhildReginhard
-
BodoEgil
SolveigBodo
AilchuSolveig
EgilAilchu
-
DwyweiDonnchadh
AgathinosDwywei
CeawlinAghatinos
HelgiCeawlin
DonnchadhHelgi


Note that the circle of Native is broken into five smaller circles (2 to 5 Companions).
 
Ivan Khan said:
Relationships based on first released Source Code:

CharacterLikeDislikeDislike
AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBeda
AilchuAgathinosCeawlinBrunhild
AsbjornBodoAgathinosReginhard
BedaAgathinosSolveigEgil
BodoBedaHelgiSolveig
BrunhildClovisReginhardAilchu
CaioEgilBedaDwywei
CeawlinSolveigAilchuDonnchadh
ClovisBrunhildEgilHelgi
DonnchadhMorgantDwyweiCeawlin
DwyweiBedaDonnchadhCaio
EgilReginhardClovisMorgant
HelgiReginhardEgilClovis
MorgantDonnchadhSolveigEgil
ReginhardHelgiBrunhildAsbjorn
SolveigBrunhildReginhardEgil

Thank you Ivan Khan for digging that up!

Here are the corresponding strictly stable parties (8 members):

1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.extra moralemorale penalty
Party_#1AsbjornBedaBodoBrunhildCeawlinClovisDwyweiMorgant50
Party_#2AgathinosAilchuBodoCaioClovisDonnchadhMorgantReginhard40

and the "stable" parties (9 members):

1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9.extra moralemorale penalty
Party_#1AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBodoBrunhildCaioClovisDonnchadhMorgant34
Party_#2AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgantReginhard34
Party_#3AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoBrunhildClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgant36
Party_#4AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoDonnchadhDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard36
Party_#5AilchuAsbjornBedaBodoDonnchadhDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard16

and also all the 8 member "stable" parties (the first two of these are already listed above, since they are also strictly stable):

1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.extra moralemorale penalty
Party_#1AsbjornBedaBodoBrunhildCeawlinClovisDwyweiMorgant50
Party_#2AgathinosAilchuBodoCaioClovisDonnchadhMorgantReginhard40
Party_#3AsbjornBedaBodoBrunhildClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgant52
Party_#4AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoClovisDonnchadhMorgantReginhard42
Party_#5AgathinosAilchuBodoBrunhildCaioClovisDonnchadhMorgant42
Party_#6AgathinosAilchuBodoCaioDonnchadhEgilMorgantReginhard42
Party_#7AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBodoCaioClovisDonnchadhMorgant32
Party_#8AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoClovisDwyweiMorgantReginhard32
Party_#9AilchuAsbjornBedaBodoClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgant32
Party_#10AilchuBedaBodoClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgantReginhard22
Party_#11AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoBrunhildClovisDonnchadhMorgant44
Party_#12AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoDonnchadhHelgiMorgantReginhard44
Party_#13AgathinosAilchuBedaDonnchadhDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard44
Party_#14AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBodoBrunhildClovisDonnchadhMorgant34
Party_#15AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoBrunhildClovisDwyweiMorgant34
Party_#16AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgant34
Party_#17AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoDonnchadhDwyweiMorgantReginhard34
Party_#18AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard34
Party_#19AgathinosAilchuBrunhildCaioClovisDonnchadhMorgantSolveig34
Party_#20AgathinosAilchuBedaClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgantReginhard24
Party_#21AgathinosBrunhildCaioCeawlinClovisDonnchadhMorgantSolveig24
Party_#22AgathinosBrunhildCaioClovisDonnchadhHelgiMorgantReginhard24
Party_#23AilchuAsbjornBedaBodoDonnchadhHelgiMorgantReginhard24
Party_#24AilchuBedaBodoDonnchadhDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard24
Party_#25AsbjornBrunhildCaioCeawlinClovisDonnchadhMorgantSolveig24
Party_#26AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBodoBrunhildCaioClovisDonnchadh14
Party_#27AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBodoBrunhildCaioClovisMorgant14
Party_#28AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBodoBrunhildClovisDwyweiMorgant14
Party_#29AilchuAsbjornBedaBodoDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard14
Party_#30AsbjornBedaBodoCeawlinDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard14
Party_#31BedaBrunhildCeawlinClovisDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard14
Party_#32AgathinosBrunhildCaioCeawlinClovisHelgiMorgantReginhard04
Party_#33AgathinosBrunhildCaioCeawlinDonnchadhHelgiMorgantSolveig04
Party_#34AgathinosBrunhildCeawlinClovisDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard04
Party_#35AsbjornBrunhildCaioCeawlinDonnchadhHelgiMorgantSolveig04
Party_#36AgathinosAilchuBedaBrunhildClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgant26
Party_#37AsbjornBedaBodoDonnchadhDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard16
Party_#38BedaBrunhildClovisDonnchadhDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard16


As noted above by Kalarhan these lists are only valid for those save games that were started under a version that has the above interaction matrix. These lists were generated just for fun, use them on your risk.
 
Could we possibly get a list of the companions personalities?  I'm thinking of giving one a fief and would like what kind of lord I will be getting.  I tried searching for it but I couldn't find anything. Thanks!
 
Here is the rough data, I need to format it.

Morality 1
Morality 2 (if any)
Home
right to rule argument
Contacts
Faction (if any)
Personality (determines Noble)

Caio
egalitarian +4
aristocratic -1
Hadrian Wall
argument_ruler
Bebbanburh
roguish

Egil
aristocratic +4
honest -1
Ribe
argument_victory
Ribe
Danmark
roguish

Brunhild
humanitarian +2
egalitarian) -1
Kennemer
argument_lords
Dorestad
selfrighteous
     
Donnchadh
aristocratic +4
honest -1
Dun_Onlaigh
argument_claim
Dun_Onlaigh
cunning -- Noble

Morgant
egalitarian +3
p_town_17
argument_ruler
p_castle_30
Cornubia
cunning -- Noble
     
Bodo
aristocratic +4
honest -1
Cantwareburh
argument_victory
Cantwareburh
custodian
     
Dwywei
humanitarian +3
Dun Taruo
argument_victory
Dun Taruo
custodian
     
Reginhard
egalitarian +3
Dorestad
argument_claim
Dorestad
Frisia
roguish

Clovis
aristocratic +2)
honest +1
p_castle_19
argument_lords
p_castle_19 Redlaesdham
East Engle
martial -- Noble

Ceawlin
humanitarian +2
egalitarian +1
Lundenwic
argument_ruler
Lundenwic
Wessex
benefactor
     
Solveig
egalitarian +3
Tunsberg
argument_claim
Tunsberg
custodian

Asbjorn
humanitarian +3
Heidabyr
argument_claim),
Ribe
benefactor

Helgi
aristocratic +3
p_castle_53
argument_claim
p_castle_53
roguish

Ailchu
aristocratic +4
egalitarian -1
Caiseal
argument_victory
Caiseal
selfrighteous -- Noble

Agathinos
egalitarian +2
honest +1
Hordaland
argument_ruler
Tunsberg
custodian

Beda
humanitarian +3
honest -1
Witan Ceaster
argument_lords
Witan Ceaster
selfrighteous -- Noble
 
Does someone know which companions won't complain after killing villagers or trade caravans? I've noticed that Brunhild for example will get angry when you raid villages. Trying to figure out whats the best raiding party.
 
DrunkenFrenchman said:
after killing villagers or trade caravans?

See post above for the morality type (1 and 2) of each companion

Here a short list of the events related to them
Code:
slot_troop_morality_type       = 62
tmt_aristocratic = 1  -> flee battle
tmt_egalitarian = 2 -> excessive deaths, no food
tmt_humanitarian = 3 -> loot village, steal food, scorch town/fort, ...
tmt_honest = 4 -> steal cash on quests (lord/merchant), kill merchant, capture fugitives, fail quest
tmt_pious = 5 -> not used
 
Lohi-soturi said:
Ivan Khan said:
Relationships based on first released Source Code:

CharacterLikeDislikeDislike
AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBeda
AilchuAgathinosCeawlinBrunhild
AsbjornBodoAgathinosReginhard
BedaAgathinosSolveigEgil
BodoBedaHelgiSolveig
BrunhildClovisReginhardAilchu
CaioEgilBedaDwywei
CeawlinSolveigAilchuDonnchadh
ClovisBrunhildEgilHelgi
DonnchadhMorgantDwyweiCeawlin
DwyweiBedaDonnchadhCaio
EgilReginhardClovisMorgant
HelgiReginhardEgilClovis
MorgantDonnchadhSolveigEgil
ReginhardHelgiBrunhildAsbjorn
SolveigBrunhildReginhardEgil

Thank you Ivan Khan for digging that up!

Here are the corresponding strictly stable parties (8 members):

1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.extra moralemorale penalty
Party_#1AsbjornBedaBodoBrunhildCeawlinClovisDwyweiMorgant50
Party_#2AgathinosAilchuBodoCaioClovisDonnchadhMorgantReginhard40

and the "stable" parties (9 members):

1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9.extra moralemorale penalty
Party_#1AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBodoBrunhildCaioClovisDonnchadhMorgant34
Party_#2AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgantReginhard34
Party_#3AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoBrunhildClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgant36
Party_#4AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoDonnchadhDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard36
Party_#5AilchuAsbjornBedaBodoDonnchadhDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard16

and also all the 8 member "stable" parties (the first two of these are already listed above, since they are also strictly stable):

1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.extra moralemorale penalty
Party_#1AsbjornBedaBodoBrunhildCeawlinClovisDwyweiMorgant50
Party_#2AgathinosAilchuBodoCaioClovisDonnchadhMorgantReginhard40
Party_#3AsbjornBedaBodoBrunhildClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgant52
Party_#4AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoClovisDonnchadhMorgantReginhard42
Party_#5AgathinosAilchuBodoBrunhildCaioClovisDonnchadhMorgant42
Party_#6AgathinosAilchuBodoCaioDonnchadhEgilMorgantReginhard42
Party_#7AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBodoCaioClovisDonnchadhMorgant32
Party_#8AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoClovisDwyweiMorgantReginhard32
Party_#9AilchuAsbjornBedaBodoClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgant32
Party_#10AilchuBedaBodoClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgantReginhard22
Party_#11AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoBrunhildClovisDonnchadhMorgant44
Party_#12AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoDonnchadhHelgiMorgantReginhard44
Party_#13AgathinosAilchuBedaDonnchadhDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard44
Party_#14AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBodoBrunhildClovisDonnchadhMorgant34
Party_#15AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoBrunhildClovisDwyweiMorgant34
Party_#16AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgant34
Party_#17AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoDonnchadhDwyweiMorgantReginhard34
Party_#18AgathinosAilchuBedaBodoDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard34
Party_#19AgathinosAilchuBrunhildCaioClovisDonnchadhMorgantSolveig34
Party_#20AgathinosAilchuBedaClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgantReginhard24
Party_#21AgathinosBrunhildCaioCeawlinClovisDonnchadhMorgantSolveig24
Party_#22AgathinosBrunhildCaioClovisDonnchadhHelgiMorgantReginhard24
Party_#23AilchuAsbjornBedaBodoDonnchadhHelgiMorgantReginhard24
Party_#24AilchuBedaBodoDonnchadhDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard24
Party_#25AsbjornBrunhildCaioCeawlinClovisDonnchadhMorgantSolveig24
Party_#26AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBodoBrunhildCaioClovisDonnchadh14
Party_#27AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBodoBrunhildCaioClovisMorgant14
Party_#28AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBodoBrunhildClovisDwyweiMorgant14
Party_#29AilchuAsbjornBedaBodoDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard14
Party_#30AsbjornBedaBodoCeawlinDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard14
Party_#31BedaBrunhildCeawlinClovisDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard14
Party_#32AgathinosBrunhildCaioCeawlinClovisHelgiMorgantReginhard04
Party_#33AgathinosBrunhildCaioCeawlinDonnchadhHelgiMorgantSolveig04
Party_#34AgathinosBrunhildCeawlinClovisDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard04
Party_#35AsbjornBrunhildCaioCeawlinDonnchadhHelgiMorgantSolveig04
Party_#36AgathinosAilchuBedaBrunhildClovisDonnchadhDwyweiMorgant26
Party_#37AsbjornBedaBodoDonnchadhDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard16
Party_#38BedaBrunhildClovisDonnchadhDwyweiHelgiMorgantReginhard16


As noted above by Kalarhan these lists are only valid for those save games that were started under a version that has the above interaction matrix. These lists were generated just for fun, use them on your risk.

Necro'd since I just came back to WB and started playing VC

Gona assume these are for 2.023, correct me if i'm wrong.

TwxlQVD.jpg


Siding with the viking: Bodo left and killed in the sea fight, Reginhard killed by me and Brunhild gone, didn't want to be on the viking side.

Four nice parties to have after story mode in Sandbox mode for me is:

1. Solveig, Egil (to have to make some story sense), Ceawlin, Helgi, Ailchu, Agathinos, Caio  = 7 in total

2. Solveig, Ceawlin, Clovis, Morgant, Donnchadh, Agathinos, Caio, Brunhild (ok i get it, you really don't like Egil, go find Brunhild in taverns)    = 8 in total (my choice)

3. Solveig, Ceawlin, Clovis, Morgant, Donnchadh, Asbjorn, Dwywei, Beda, Brunhild (same as above)  = 9 in total

4. Solveig, Morgant, Donnchadh, Clovis, Ailchu, Agathinos, Beda, Dwywei, Brunhild (same as above),  = 9 in total

Any other requests to match your roleplay feel, do pm me. i'll try to help.
 
tis always confusing to keep track of that...

I guess you are right, idk, I highly dislike how companions are handled by VC, for you have not only to handle dislikes and annoying decision triggers (like someone pestering you because you've raided a village or whatever), you aslo have to deal with religion, which can't be amended by all means... IF there was some way to convert companions as to avoid the extra negative hit it would be OK, but apparently there isn't...
 
xdj1nn said:
tis always confusing to keep track of that...

I guess you are right, idk, I highly dislike how companions are handled by VC, for you have not only to handle dislikes and annoying decision triggers (like someone pestering you because you've raided a village or whatever), you aslo have to deal with religion, which can't be amended by all means... IF there was some way to convert companions as to avoid the extra negative hit it would be OK, but apparently there isn't...

Well, now we have the source code it is pretty easy to modify the system if you want. Easiest is to use VC Tweaks Tool:

https://forums.taleworlds.com/index.php/topic,348186.0.html

But, if you want you can go in and read the source code about companions and modify, likes, dislikes, religion, etc.
 
xdj1nn said:
tis always confusing to keep track of that...

I guess you are right, idk, I highly dislike how companions are handled by VC, for you have not only to handle dislikes and annoying decision triggers (like someone pestering you because you've raided a village or whatever), you aslo have to deal with religion, which can't be amended by all means... IF there was some way to convert companions as to avoid the extra negative hit it would be OK, but apparently there isn't...

Just tweak companions so they're not petty and can get along with their fellow comrades.  I have all companions (one as minister and one as a lord) fully armored and in my warband. #harmony.
 
what characteristics makes a hero the best kingdom administrator?  I would guess it is different based on religion and type of kingdom one is running
 
Lohi-soturi said:
Lets review the info that has been posted here on the relatioships between the characters:

The relationships for 1.03b, by Ivan Khan. This was obviously well tested and trustworthy, but is now supposedly outdated:

CharacterLikeDislikeDislike
AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBeda
AilchuAgathinosCeawlinBrunhild
AsbjornBodoAgathinosReginhard
BedaAgathinosSolveigEgil
BodoAsbjornHelgiSolveig
BrunhildClovisReginhardAilchu
CaioEgilBedaDwywei
CeawlinSolveigAilchuDonnchadh
ClovisBrunhildEgilHelgi
DonnchadhMorgantDwyweiCeawlin
DwyweiBedaDonnchadhCaio
EgilBrunhildClovisMorgant
HelgiReginhardEgilClovis
MorgantDonnchadhSolveigEgil
ReginhardHelgiBrunhildAsbjorn
SolveigBrunhildReginhardEgil


The relationships for 2.012 by Baki667:

CharacterLikeDislikeDislike
AgathinosAilchuAsbjornBeda
AilchuAgathinosBrunhildCeawlin
AsbjornBodoAgathinosReginhard
BedaAgathinosEgilSolveig
BodoBedaHelgiSolveig
BrunhildClovisAilchuReginhard
CaioEgilBedaDwyvei
CeawlinSolveigAilchuDonnchadh
ClovisBrunhildEgilHelgi
DonnchadhMorgantCeawlinDwyvei
DwyveiBedaCaioDonnchadh
EgilBrunhildClovisMorgant
HelgiReginhardClovisEgil
MorgantDonnchadhEgilSolveig
ReginhardHelgiBrunhildCaio
SolveigBrunhildEgilReginhard

and the relationships for 2.012 by Sir Mordred:

CharacterLikeDislikeDislike
Agathinos  Ailchu            Asbjorn Beda
Ailchu          Agathinos    Brunhild Ceawlin
Asbjorn      Bodo            Agathinos?
Beda          Agathinos    Egil Solveig
Bodo          Asbjorn        Helgi Solveig
Brunhild      Clovis          Ailchu Reginhard
Caio            Egil              Beda Dwywei
Ceawlin      Solveig        Ailchu Donnchadh
Clovis        Brunhild      Egil Helgi
Donnchadh Morgant      Ceawlin Dwywei
Dwywei      Beda            Donnchadh?
Egil            Reginhard  Morgant?
Helgi          Reginhard    Clovis Egil
Morgant    Donnchadh    Solveig?
Reginhard  Helgi            Asbjorn Brunhild
Solveig      Brunhild      Egil Reginhard

Hopefully I've copied their posts succesfully.

We notice that according to Baki's information the changes in 2.012 vs 1.03b are that now:
1) Bodo likes Beda instead of Asbjorn
2 )and Reginhard dislikes Caio instead of Asbjorn.

However, Sir Mordred's (unfortunately not quite complete) info says otherwise: Bodo still likes Asbjorn and likewise Reginhard still dislikes  Asbjorn and not Caio. In Sir Mordred's version the change from 1.03b is that now:
1) Egil likes Reginhard instead of Brunhild

hopefully both have started a new game under 2.012 as we have been told that the relationships are set when the campaign starts. But since the new information is contradictory they can't both be true unless they have been started under different post 1.03b versions of the game or in worst case the developers have made the dislikes (gasp) partly random.

The obvious corollary is that we still don't have good enough information to produce any maximal stable party listings for 2.012. Is there anyone out there who is skilled enough (and willing to spend the time) to reverse engineer the exact relationship info from the game text files? It was xyp's great reverse engineering work that originally made it possible to make these listings for Brytenwalda. As I don't have any time to play the game for a long long time, I'm not going to even try to do it myself.

Cheers, lohi.

sorry to bump this thread.. now its 2.028

is it true the relationships are linked to ur original save game? i know i started playing a few patches after 1.03b but way before 2.012
everything seems to fit except for Caio.. he's happy with my choice of companions even though both Beda and Dyweiwei are in my party (who he hates according to all of these charts), giving him -2 , or -3??? (according to this post which says Dyweiwei hating Caio too will further reduce stability), also Egil isn't even in the party. i dont get it -_-
 
harpred said:
is it true the relationships are linked to ur original save game? i know i started playing a few patches after 1.03b but way before 2.012

yeap, but you should start a new game at some point, you are missing out the new features from 2.0 (RE Edition) by playing a pre-RE game.
 
kalarhan said:
harpred said:
is it true the relationships are linked to ur original save game? i know i started playing a few patches after 1.03b but way before 2.012

yeap, but you should start a new game at some point, you are missing out the new features from 2.0 (RE Edition) by playing a pre-RE game.

i think i started with reforged edition .. the main quest before you go into sandbox was the Irish one  , right?
 
It was during sandbox, but yeah that's reforged edition. All the same there's been quite a few big-fixes and rebalances since then. I'm kinda impressed though, what day are you on?
 
Back
Top Bottom