Alright, I should post some notes/questions/whatevers. This isn't nearly everything I have, but the other things I have might not be worth posting yet:
Questions
1) What makes Frisian’s views of the joker different than CW’s?
2)
Whoopin: In
this post you speculate that if Hawk turned up innocent AWdeV might have known better and wanted to seem helpful to the village. What is your view on this idea now?
3)
Whoopin, you
said here that your asking for votes got some stellar results, but didn’t expand on that. What were you referring to?
4)
Xardob, you mentioned that you thought Hawk was innocent and you’d rather have a vigilante kill him. That’s fine, but what if there was no vig? We’d still have Hawk as a distraction. Additionally, doesn’t it work both ways? Why not just say “whoever we don’t lynch today, the vig should kill in order to remove the greatest distractions?” I understand you’d rather do it your way because you didn’t suspect Hawk, but isn’t it riskier to leave the more distracting option alive with the potential to not be killed?
5)
Avian, are
these still your thoughts on voting? Should we still go for a less vocal player?
6)
CW, you expressed
Whoopin voting for two people who ended up innocent is wolfy. To me, this seems like a cheap way of trying to add suspicion to Whoopin. Is everyone who voted for an innocent player suspicious? Do you think a wolf would avoid voting for Hawk, knowing he would inevitably get lynched, so that they can claim the Hawk voters are wolves?
7)
CW, you imply you suggested Hawk was
obviously not a wolf, but after having gone through you posts, you actually never commented on what you thought of him between when Aust said there was no joker until the start of Day 2. Are you deliberately lying in order to keep your “hands clean” and **** the blame on others (as people accused Mag of on Day 1)? – This is a rhetorical question, in case you were not sure
Things that are not sitting well with me:
1)
Xardob and Whoopin hoppin' on the AWdeV train. Xardob's vote is reasonable since he thought Hawk was probably innocent. K. But Whoopin was all for lynching Hawk earlier, and while he did suggest that his suspicion of CW and Fishy made him dubious of Hawk's guilt, AWdeV is neither CW nor Fishy, so I don't exactly understand it. The reason why I bring Xardob into this is because
they have previously voted together. This makes it three times. I might be thinking about it too much, but my gut is tingling.
2)
This post by Whoopin. Day 1 is problematic for his hunches, but his whole pack idea was based off his hunches. If you know your Day 1 hunches are not always the best, why put so much weight into them and basically refuse to consider other arguments made for others?
3)
Whoopin’s comment here about Hawk. I agree that getting Hawk’s suspicions down is a good idea in case he was to get lynched, but Whoopin seems to take it for granted that Hawk was going to die. He
did the same with Magorian, but that one seems more reasonable because it came much later in the day. Preemptive?
4) While I am not super suspicious of Soot,
Hulk’s post here, specifically on AWdeV, almost sounds like a wolf coming in after being inactive for a while to distance himself from a packie in order to look helpful (like Pilgrim’s Llandy case last game). This idea is probably a result of me finding AWdeV suspicious, but if we find out he is a wolf, this could be an interpretation. Or I just have mega-tunnelvision.
5)
Ej’s post here seems a bit out in left field. Sure, if he saw Whoopin reading it would make sense to ask his thoughts, but the beginning “we haven’t interacted much” bit sounds… “forced.” I don’t know how else to explain the vibe it gives me, but it’s there. Same thing with the
two posts starting here with Whoopin and Ej.
6) Whoopin’s argument that CW and FF are
”guility by association” with Adaham… who we didn’t even know was guilty of anything at that point. Do I need to further explain?
7) Llandy's obsession with a guy who hasn't been showing up. I get it, and I understand your argument, but I'd like to see more of your thoughts on others if you can provide them. While the wolf hunt might be difficult if your suspects aren't active, you can always still find more reason to believe others are innocent. "Innocent hunting," perhaps. I dunno.
8. Soot’s switching from Mag to Ej to Whoopin. It's like he is willing to bandwagon everyone except AWdeV.
That is actually unfair to say because he suspects those three anyways, but while he has explained it, I am innately suspicious of anyone who is willing to jump around so easily (see Whoopin).
I'm going to attempt to now look at votes and ****.
