Please fill the feedback, reply this topic :D (for the 3rd version)

Users who are viewing this thread

WilliamBerne

Master Knight
I did lots of changes, but have no enough time to play the mod nor cover every corner. With the help of your feedback/report about how your game goes, I can know better of how are the system working.
It’s ok if you cheated, but you have to report faithfully, detailedly. Thanks!

Report form:

Survey
Game days:
Have you cheated:
Faction you are in:
Centers number you are holding:
Military forces you have:
Other factions military forces:
Automatic weapons
When would you use burst fire mode:
When do you prefer automatic fire mode:
What's your opinion of this automatic weapon system:
Battle tactics and squad formation
How often do you use combat plan and squad formation:
Do you find this tactic system helpful:
Army
Where did you get the soldiers:
Do you use "arm soldier" frequently:
How often do you manufacture weapons:
Which weapons do you order most:
The troops you find most helpful:
How do you feel about the auto recruit:
how do you feel about the weaponry system:
New buildings
Which are the useful buildings you think:
What do you think about the prices and building times:
Public order system
How would the public orders of your centers normally be:
Did they change too fast:
Can you feel the influence of this system:
Generally, how do you think about this version:
 
Survey
Game days:Around 50-100
Have you cheated:Renown and Money cheat. And Truesight. And edited character file to get higher engineer to check out the Buildings.
Faction you are in:NPCA
Centers number you are holding:A Village and a Castle (and its fief)
Military forces you have:Around 50 Riflemen, a few mounted cavalry. Officers as well.
Other factions military forces:None, excluding the odd mercenary.
Army
Where did you get the soldiers:Recruiting from any neutral town or from the camp.
Do you use „arm soldier“ frequently:Yes.
How often do you manufacture weapons: It's a bit slow, so I do try and get a decent armory up.
Which weapons do you order most:Rifles.
The troops you find most helpful:Medics, Officers and Riflemen.
How do you feel about the auto recruit:Saves me from running around all the time, but the quantity's a bit slow.
how do you feel about the weaponry system:It's nice, but I'd like an assault unit with SMGs only.
New buildings
Which are the useful buildings you think:Armory, Camp.
What do you think about the prices and building times:Certainly better than Native.
Public order system
How would the public orders of your centers normally be:Low/Medium.
Did they changed too fast:Never bothered to look.
Can you feel the influence of this system:I think I found that I could recruit more troops in places with higher public order.
Generally, how do you think about this version:Better than the last version because of the lower quantity of grenades, but they still are annoying. Sieges are still horrible against an enemy of MGs, Grenadiers, Snipers and mortarmen. A larger quantity of weapons produced and the ability to produce more than one type at once should you have more craftsmen would be nice.
 
thanks man, I would send you a flower if there was the same forum funtion that the chinese MnB forum has.

by the "Other factions military forces", I mean how are the other factions going? Is your main enemy faction as strong as the game begin or weaker?
which one is the " odd mercenary"?  :roll:
 
The Odd mercenary means the local hunter, the medics, the craftsmen that I need to hire every so often. The balance of power shifts rather regularly, there are constant attack/withdrawals. It's like a stalemate. Sieges don't really go anywhere because of Grenadiers and mortarmen. Once the Manchurian Puppets managed to capture Asugan, but retreated when the National party intervened, then they retreated when one of their northern castles was besieged by the Japanese. The hotspots are in the Puppet/Manchurian and CP border zone commonly.
 
Survey
Game days:Save one 39 Save 2 60
Have you cheated:Money and True sight
Faction you are in:Save one Local Army Save two NEAJA
Centers number you are holding:save one a castle and one village + feifs (same on save 2)
Military forces you have:Save One, 70, mainly infantry with 3 generals and 10 or 15 officers roughly the same
Other factions military forces:Havent really changed yet when the Lords come back they seem to have either more men or just the sameish
Army
Where did you get the soldiers:Villages and saving the odd person
Do you use „arm soldier“ frequently:No (As it has taken me ages to figure out how to get craftmen)
How often do you manufacture weapons: not very
Which weapons do you order most:ammunition/rifles
The troops you find most helpful:Machine Gunners
How do you feel about the auto recruit:doesnt seem to do anything for me
how do you feel about the weaponry system:Bit complex but its ok just would prefer to have SMG troops aswell instead of just rifles and machine gunners (on foot not mounted)
New buildings
Which are the useful buildings you think:Workshop, Armory, Arsenal (or w/e) and Camp/barracks
What do you think about the prices and building times:Prices are ok, the times are too long to wait for me as I'd like the amount of craftsmen to reduce the time
Public order system
How would the public orders of your centers normally be:60-80 never really take notice
Did they change too fast:dont really notice to give that feed back
Can you feel the influence of this system:Not really
Generally, how do you think about this version:better then the last but more things could be added like death of lords (man they'r a pain when you get you castle to average) and people with names instead of "Note Sure" and "Gerneral 4"
 
Survey
Game days: 155 days
Have you cheated: Money cheat, True sight, Teleportation
Faction you are in: Currently my own
Centers number you are holding: um, 1 town and a few villages
Military forces you have: mostly mercenaries
Other factions military forces: the 8ra, and manchurian prisoners
Army
Where did you get the soldiers: taverns, rescuing, recruiting from camp, my fiefs
Do you use „arm soldier“ frequently: yes
How often do you manufacture weapons: ehh all the time
Which weapons do you order most: grenades
The troops you find most helpful: riflemen and grenadiers
How do you feel about the auto recruit: awesome but sometimes even when my officers are ordered to auto recruit they dont
how do you feel about the weaponry system: nice, but i want to know how do i equip someone with a rifle bayonet???
New buildings
Which are the useful buildings you think: camp, stall, armory, school and colleges
What do you think about the prices and building times: prices are ok, building times are short which is good
Public order system
How would the public orders of your centers normally be: freaking low
Did they change too fast: no
Can you feel the influence of this system: i think so
Generally, how do you think about this version: its awesome
 
Game days:120
Have you cheated:Money, Levels, Attributes etc. Teleport.
Faction you are in:8RA
Centers number you are holding:2 castles 2 Villages
Military forces you have:8RA infantry ( bout 50 ) 10 8RA officers 2 Generals
Other factions military forces:One or two Mercs and NPCA
Army
Where did you get the soldiers:VIllages, Prisoner Rescuings etc.
Do you use „arm soldier“ frequently:No
How often do you manufacture weapons: 24/7
Which weapons do you order most:Subs and Ammo
The troops you find most helpful:Machinegunners and Grenaders
How do you feel about the auto recruit:I havent seen it work properly yet
how do you feel about the weaponry system:Its OK
New buildings
Which are the useful buildings you think:Arsenal Tree
What do you think about the prices and building times:Its Good, Realism in this aspect can GTFO
Public order system
How would the public orders of your centers normally be:50-
Did they change too fast:No
Can you feel the influence of this system:Yes
Generally, how do you think about this version:Awesome
 
Report form:

Survey
Game days:80.
Have you cheated: Yes, only to give myself HP in battles.
Faction you are in:8RA.
Centers number you are holding:1 town, Curaw.
Military forces you have:In Curaw, I have around 150 troops situated now. I have around 20 men in my own party. But I have access to all of my factions military, since I'm a marshall of the 8RA.
Other factions military forces:Pretty strong & a lot. I constantly get attacked, but it is great fun. I'm slowly pushing the enemy inland - I already have conquered Nelag and Vyincourd castle. That kept them off until they re-conquered them.

Army
Where did you get the soldiers:Recruiting a few guys at first from towns and villages if I could, then attacking parties with a lot of prisoners. Later, I get to recruit the prisoners to my party.
Do you use „arm soldier“ frequently:Yes, very often.
How often do you manufacture weapons: Not sure, I just have 8 pioneers in my town and I have it automatically on always. I keep my relationship with the town up by giving the Tavern Keeper some cash.
Which weapons do you order most:Rifles.
The troops you find most helpful:Machinegunners. Seriously, they're really good. But they're harder to get, too, so mainly I use the riflemen.
How do you feel about the auto recruit:I find it quite nice! I've got 2 generals in my town, not sure if this increases the count but I have noticed that I get around 4-8 recruits after each a while.
How do you feel about the weaponry system:Great, I love the fact that you can bribe the baggage officers, and such.

New buildings
Which are the useful buildings you think:Workshop and Upgraded Workshop.
What do you think about the prices and building times:The building times are fine, but the prices could be lower. Nothing too much, though, I just had to do a lot of quests everyone gave me (Guild Master, Lords, Kings, etc).

Public order system
How would the public orders of your centers normally be:Around 40-70. First, when I captured the town, I had +5 relationship but public order was -44. So I put a general to Impose a Curfew. That got my public order to around 50 but relationship to -3. So I've been slowly paying the Tavern Keeper for increase in relationship (Money is not really a problem for a guy like me, who attacks and gets attacked a lot).
Did they change too fast:Nah, it's fine I think.
Can you feel the influence of this system:A bit.. You should have some larger negative effects when you're in minus with the Public Order. Perhaps rebellions start then, or something.

Generally, how do you think about this version:
It's nice, but could be a bit better. Some lords are named 'General 1' and 'not sure', etc. Otherwise, it's awesome!

cdvader
 
Survey
Game days: 140 - 150
Have you cheated: No
Faction you are in:NPCA
Centers number you are holding: 2 Towns 2 Castles and 5 villages
Military forces you have: 75 NPCA Infantry, 5 NPCA Officers 2 NPCA Generals
Other factions military forces:8RA soldiers
Army
Where did you get the soldiers:Villages/Castles/Towns recruitment
Do you use „arm soldier“ frequently:Sometimes
How often do you manufacture weapons:razz:retty often
Which weapons do you order most:Sub machine guns
The troops you find most helpful:Machine gun man
How do you feel about the auto recruit:It needs to recruit more men
how do you feel about the weaponry system: Its confusing
New buildings
Which are the useful buildings you think:what?
What do you think about the prices and building times:!?!?
Public order system
How would the public orders of your centers normally be:around 70 except for 1 castle went to 30 :neutral:
Did they change too fast:yes
Can you feel the influence of this system:sort of
Generally, how do you think about this version:its very incomplete
 
Survey
Game days:88
Have you cheated:no
Faction you are in:8th and central army
Centers number you are holding:0
Military forces you have:
Other factions military forces:
Army
Where did you get the soldiers:
Do you use „arm soldier“ frequently: i have not been able to use fief properly but otherwise yes
How often do you manufacture weapons: havent yet
Which weapons do you order most:rifle and grenadiers
The troops you find most helpful: medic cavalry
How do you feel about the auto recruit:good
how do you feel about the weaponry system:good
New buildings
Which are the useful buildings you think:armory
What do you think about the prices and building times: good
Public order system
How would the public orders of your centers normally be:
Did they change too fast:
Can you feel the influence of this system:
Generally, how do you think about this version: its good, id like a kingdom mod and maybe another faction
 
Report form:

Survey
Game days: 120 - 125
Have you cheated: yes only ctrl-x
Faction you are in: npca
Centers number you are holding: 1 town and its fiefs
Military forces you have: 70 npca cavalry, 3 machinegunner, 10 coehorn
Other factions military forces: puppets
Army
Where did you get the soldiers: recruiting
Do you use „arm soldier“ frequently: yep
How often do you manufacture weapons: always. i get my weapons from only factory
Which weapons do you order most: carbines coehorns and ammos
The troops you find most helpful: officers and coehorn guys
How do you feel about the auto recruit: i dont use it
how do you feel about the weaponry system: i like that system very much
New buildings
Which are the useful buildings you think: stall and armorys
What do you think about the prices and building times: wonderfull
Public order system
How would the public orders of your centers normally be: low - medium
Did they change too fast: no
Can you feel the influence of this system: yes
Generally, how do you think about this version:
i like it.
 
Survey
Game days: Around 100
Have you cheated: no
Faction you are in: 8RA
Centers number you are holding: Castle and two villages
Military forces you have: mixed ranged cavalry/ grenadiers
Other factions military forces: Doctors and medics
Army
Where did you get the soldiers: Village/ Town recruitment
Do you use „arm soldier“ frequently: Very
How often do you manufacture weapons: quite often
Which weapons do you order most: SMG's
The troops you find most helpful: Ranged cavalry
How do you feel about the auto recruit: good, but recruits too slow
how do you feel about the weaponry system: love it, but wish I could give soldiers coehorns
New buildings
Which are the useful buildings you think: radio post, workshop
What do you think about the prices and building times: very good
Public order system
How would the public orders of your centers normally be: moderate
Did they change too fast: yes
Can you feel the influence of this system: not particularly
Generally, how do you think about this version: I enjoy it, but I would like to see a major change in sieges and siege scenes.
 
Survey
Game days:20
Have you cheated:yes for money and training troops
Faction you are in:Kuomintang central army if thats it
Centers number you are holding:1 village
Military forces you have:20
Other factions military forces:0
Army
Where did you get the soldiers:village and towns
Do you use „arm soldier“ frequently:yes
How often do you manufacture weapons: 24/7 unless my stock is full
Which weapons do you order most:the only rifle i have but looking for an assault rifle
The troops you find most helpful:any
How do you feel about the auto recruit:auto recruit i have no clue what that is
how do you feel about the weaponry system:love is so far
New buildings
Which are the useful buildings you think:factory
What do you think about the prices and building times:just fine or increase them a small amount
Public order system
How would the public orders of your centers normally be:no clue what it is
Did they change too fast:no clue
Can you feel the influence of this system:no clue
Generally, how do you think about this version:i love it but i feel there should be heavy weapons and some artillery the battle scenes dont feel like WWII it feels more like medieval warfare 
 
Survey
Game days:100-120
Have you cheated:Money, Char export/import
Faction you are in:N4A
Centers number you are holding:Faction holds a city and three castles, I hold one city
Military forces you have:500+
Other factions military forces:80-120 in each army

Army
Where did you get the soldiers:Most were recruited from villages, very few from Generals
Do you use „arm soldier“ frequently:Yes
How often do you manufacture weapons: Every day until the village/city's inventory is full
Which weapons do you order most:Rifles
The troops you find most helpful:Machine Gunners
How do you feel about the auto recruit:Needs to recruit more frequently
how do you feel about the weaponry system:Very nice

New buildings
Which are the useful buildings you think:Schools/Colleges/Arsenals
What do you think about the prices and building times:Prices on weapons and ammunition should be lowered a bit

Public order system
How would the public orders of your centers normally be:Very low unless curfew is instated.
Did they change too fast:No
Can you feel the influence of this system:Not at all
Generally, how do you think about this version:Very nice, just needs the map and new leader names for the other factions. Also, you DEFINITELY need to be able to choose how many weapons/ammunitions to be manufactured. Such a pain in my ass having extra weapons and ammo cluttering up my inventories.
 
xSpartaNx_MyK said:
you DEFINITELY need to be able to choose how many weapons/ammunitions to be manufactured. Such a pain in my ass having extra weapons and ammo cluttering up my inventories.
good point, will do that.
 
Survey
Game days:40
Have you cheated: can't say I haven't.
Faction you are in: since I got kicked out of the japanese faction. ( thanks a lot for that... ) I have been playing the  8th route army
Centers number you are holding: 1 castle, 2 villages
Military forces you have:here comes the cheat... 2726
Other factions military forces:150 or so
Army
Where did you get the soldiers:Tavern, and some raw recruits.
Do you use „arm soldier“ frequently:3/10
How often do you manufacture weapons: none, I can't get my pioneers to work on the damn machines...
Which weapons do you order most:Tommy Gun ( Thompson )
The troops you find most helpful:Officers
How do you feel about the auto recruit:I didn't notice any difference
how do you feel about the weaponry system:It's okay, but deffinetely needs improvement
New buildings
Which are the useful buildings you think:Workshop should be useful, but I couldn't get my pioneers to work
What do you think about the prices and building times:Prices and building times are OK
Public order system
How would the public orders of your centers normally be:62
Did they change too fast:not really
Can you feel the influence of this system:no
Generally, how do you think about this version:I think it's a great mod, but you guys should definetely map it to fit China, not Caladria.

oh, btw.. why do you have Kraut helmets in China?
 
killerrabbit said:
oh, btw.. why do you have Kraut helmets in China?
have answered such questions:
before 1938, hitler and Jiang Jieshi, these two dictators were allies, and the nationalists got the first hundred thousands M35 helmets even before german soldiers.

most of national party's military equpments were learned or copied from german. hanyang made rilfe copied german Gewehr 1888, Zhongzheng type copied german Kar98k, chinese favorite pistol was mauser military pistol, gong type grenade copied german M24 wood handle grenade...
 
Survey
Game days:244
Have you cheated:No
Faction you are in:8RA communist party
Centers number you are holding:1 Castle, 2 Villages
Military forces you have:96men in party
Other factions military forces:90-150
Army
Where did you get the soldiers:Villages, My Castle, Towns, Taverns.
Do you use „arm soldier“ frequently:Always
How often do you manufacture weapons: Its manufacturing :smile:
Which weapons do you order most:Muskets + Ammo
The troops you find most helpful:Trained Rifleman, Grenadiers, Machinegunmen
How do you feel about the auto recruit:Slow, it should be possible to muster more men.
how do you feel about the weaponry system:Great, but more weapons, the best :smile:
New buildings
Which are the useful buildings you think:Armory , Barracks
What do you think about the prices and building times:Better than the Native version.
Public order system: Bad. We should have more options to control it such as police/ guards houses to keep order.
How would the public orders of your centers normally be:They are bad believe me.
Did they change too fast:To regain order its slow
Can you feel the influence of this system:Not really
Generally, how do you think about this version:Well this version is really good compared to the first one. But if you read our suggestions the next version will be even better.
 
Survey
Game days:200 (Game time represents about a fun two days)
Have you cheated:Nope
Faction you are in:8th Route Army
Centers number you are holding:Ruluns (Village near Tehlrog castle and Kelredan Castle),  Jelbegi village and of course Jelbegi Castle
Military forces you have:10 Generals (I think 6 are my faction and the others are rescued allies), a lot of infantry (All 8RA) and officers (I would say two third are 8RA and the rest are rescued allies), SO yeah mixture of all United Front.

Other factions military forces:Presently the Japanese Invaders along with both Puppet Factions are on the defensive.  Initially JapInvds had much success on the battlefield due to highly trained armies.  Though after two hundred days they continue to find themselves outnumbered by the United Front forces in each battle.  Nationalist Armies tend to be in the 150s or higher.  Communist forces are beginning to move into the 100-149 zone of troop levels per lord, (one exception is Lord Hans who epically  tries to besiege castles that have 200+ with his army of 30...).
JapInvds have ceded the following centers Jelbegi Castle + Jelbegi village to 8RA (Myself) , Hrus Castle to the K Local Army.
Puppet Regimes have ceded the following centers Jeirbe Castle + Village, Tilbaut castle + Village, both to the New 4th Army. Also Ismirala Castle + Village, captured by the NorthEast Anti-Japanese Alliance.  Along with Radoghir Castle + village, being taken by the K Central Army

As of Day 200  Tilbaut is currently besieged by the Puppet Regime.
PR Manchuria have made a series of random raids against the K Local Army... for some odd reason, and the Japanese are currently on the defensive with three major battles near Hrus Castle,  Knudarr Castle, and outside Suno.
Puppet Regime- 12 Armies
Japanese Invaders- 9 Armies
PR Manchuria- 2 Armies
8th Route Army- 12 Armies

Army
Where did you get the soldiers:Where ever is convenient...
Do you use „arm soldier“ frequently:I do now that I have an arsenal, I pump out rifles and grenades primarily (Returning the pain inflicted by the Japanese, two fold!)
How often do you manufacture weapons: All the time, considering as of day 197 (Conquest of Jelbegi) How much I need to defend new territory and continue with the momentum I have, I'll be needing weaponry constantly.
Which weapons do you order most:Rifles and Grenades
The troops you find most helpful:Infantry-  I have found to be the most versatile due to their unaltered state of being just armed with spear and firearm.  Being the most base of troops they have proven many a time to be valuable at holding high ground on the battlefield.      Riflemen-  Give some infantry rifles and you get veterans, far more lethal at their original role and stand up better in close combat.  Officers-  Mounted in small numbers are only good at mopping up after a fight or flanking a beleaguered force, but officers placed on ahead of infantry work wonders at skirmishing if used effectively.  Place officers on a hill near your other infantry forces will generate a deadly kill zone,  while mounted and on the charge however in quantity is a dreadfully low survival rate...  Generals-  Though they are sucking cash out of my pocket these guys are durable in battle while their tactic bonus has turned the tide in several key battles in favor of me and fellow allies.    Last my favorite troop being the most helpful is the Grenadier-  I hated the Japanese early game, especially when I was such a small force being nade' to hell and back on more than one occasion.  Now I'm using them to devastating effect in battle, defending hills or ridge lines I have been cracking the Japanese Cavalry charges easily with these guys.
How do you feel about the auto recruit:I hardly use it, I'm roaming around so often that I recruit when its convenient, though I suspect now that i have expanded beyond just one village and now control a second vil and a caslte I will be using this method more often.
how do you feel about the weaponry system: It so far seems satisfying, though I feel that It would be helpful to make machine guns in castles instead of being exclusive to towns this way players at this stage can compete with the chaotic flow of power that ebbs back and forth.

New buildings
Which are the useful buildings you think:Radio station, though its been hard to keep a radioman from dying on the battlefield, the station has proven its value many times at informing me that village was being raided, For instance I have my game open as I type this and was just informed that some one is raiding Ruluns.  Workshop + upgrades has leveled the playing field for me to compete against numerically and technically superior forces many times now.
What do you think about the prices and building times:Very reasonable considering the games speed and the constant flow of activity in game world.

Public order system
How would the public orders of your centers normally be:Um, before Day 197, my first village was doing fine.  The castle and its attached village are low and will eventually be consolidated to the same level as first village.  Public order (Jelbegi) 13-59 (Ruluns)
Did they change too fast:No it was a slow increase and my decisions tended to reflect the speed.
Can you feel the influence of this system:Yes, I have at times wondered when my weapons order would be completed, while recently I have been surprised at Ruluns for finishing the order sooner than expected, and the number of extra craftsmen recruited (though I suspect that has more to do with officers).
Generally, how do you think about this version:I have only played this version, so far its very enjoyable and addicting.  Congratulations and making and exceeding expectations.  I'll be playing this some more while writing up a list of suggestions and will of course report any bugs I come across.
 
Back
Top Bottom