oroboros said:
Why do you compare a normal longsword with a balanced sword/scimitar?
A balanced IIIa has 95 speed, 105 reach and deals 47c and 28p dmg, compared to the balanced Elite Scimitar which deals 42 dmg and is 5 points faster and has 5 length less.
Sorry if I mislead you a little with my comprision. I give to compare two normal bastard swords and then show 2 one handed that I think is better then Hand and half sword which almost can't be found as balanced in shops.
oroboros said:
But the slowliness of the longswords give them a nice bonus from horseback due to momentum - slower weapons from horseback, with the right timing, are more devastating than 1-h swords.
I should disagree. One man, very respected by me wrote before
oroboros said:
If you use twohander with a shield or from horesback, you get -23.5% damage penalty if that twohander can be used with a shield (ie has onehander animations). If not, the penalty is -15%.
- Both cases above also have some sort of a speed penalty.
--> you'll receive -15% on dmg/speed with 1/2-h weapons (the ones you can wield with a shield)
and I believe this words. So damage by balanced IIIa will be 47c - 15% ~40, lower then 42 by one handed sword/scimitar. And much slower.I had experience to use both types of swords and prefer one handed.