Hm, it seems that the opinions on these animations are mixed. While I personally think they look alot better than the native ones, I feel that the TLD team could do a better job with more fitting animations made from scratch.
For example, I've always wanted to see Elven swordsmen in M&B using the down-upwards motion slash when using two-handed swords. Not sure if this is true to the lore, but at the beginning of the first LotR movie you could see Noldor swordsmen repelling an entire rank of orcs with this technique at Dagorlad.
Anyway, even though the Fire Arrow anims may not be the ideal replacement, I'm glad that they at least made some people happy.
For example, I've always wanted to see Elven swordsmen in M&B using the down-upwards motion slash when using two-handed swords. Not sure if this is true to the lore, but at the beginning of the first LotR movie you could see Noldor swordsmen repelling an entire rank of orcs with this technique at Dagorlad.
Anyway, even though the Fire Arrow anims may not be the ideal replacement, I'm glad that they at least made some people happy.